3 ms·
Interestingly, I observed that the inverse seemed to be true in college (I was a computer science major). People (mostly math majors) who were very good math st
by baddox 13y ago
Interestingly, I observed that the inverse seemed to be true in college (I was a computer science major). People (mostly math majors) who were very good math students, meaning they breezed through the college calc courses, struggled when we met again in more CS-relevant classes like Discrete Mathematics and Algebraic Structures. It should be troubling to any educator to see people excel at Calc 2 integrations, yet struggle to accomplish much simpler (at least to me) tasks like proving that the product of two even integers is an even integer.
- cowsandmilk 13y ago> struggle to accomplish much simpler (at least to me) tasks like proving that the product of two even integers is an even integer. I always see articles that claim I didn't do math in high school, and then people talk about things like this. I did this in high school. In the US. In 2001. Literally, one of our test questions was: (a) prove the product of two even numbers is even (b) prove the product of two odd numbers is odd (c) prove the product of an odd and even number is even And this wasn't regurgitating a proof we learned in class or had on homework, it was a question we had not seen before. Blanket statements about what people see and don't see in high school are worthless.
- baddox 13y agoI didn't make any blanket statements. I simply didn't encounter any proofs in high school math courses, other than "geometric proofs" which weren't formal proofs.
- j2kun 13y agoThis is the problem: the way calculus is taught is not very mathematical.