3 ms·
Soon after this exchange, Linus started using a real source management system (BitKeeper, followed by git) for the kernel.
by sp332 13y ago
Soon after this exchange, Linus started using a real source management system (BitKeeper, followed by git) for the kernel.
- neomantra 13y agoBitKeeper, not bitbucket
- sp332 13y agod'oh, updated
- Aqueous 13y ago...but it totally wasn't because of what Eric Raymond said, right?
- sp332 13y agoWhy not?
- Aqueous 13y agojoke - I can imagine Linus grudgingly beginning to use version control, but never admitting that Raymond's rather pointed tough love led him to do it.
- onedognight 13y agoLinus wasn't against version control. He thought that CVS and SVN (the leaders at the time) were just not beneficial enough for his use case. The kernel developers worked with "patches" as their unit of work and neither of these could handle them well. More fundamentally they were centralized and Linus had experience from watching the BSDs and knew that a centralized version control was actually worse than none. He both explicitly didn't want to have anymore authority or convenience than any other developer and at the same time wanted absolute authority over his own version. Neither of these were possible with CVS/SVN.
- nousernamesleft 13y ago>More fundamentally they were centralized and Linus had experience from watching the BSDs and knew that a centralized version control was actually worse than none Watching another group from the outside is not experience. But what makes you say he even had that? He's pretty consistently suggested he has no time to pay any attention to any of the BSD projects going right back to 1993.
- bronsoja 13y agoI'm assuming there was at least some scm in place before, but my few google searches haven't turned up what it was. Do you know? *edit: Didn't look hard enough, according to this: http://git-scm.com/book/en/Getting-Started-A-Short-History-of-Git http://git-scm.com/book/en/Getting-Started-A-Short-History-o... it was just files and patches from 1991-2002. Seems crazy from a modern perspective...
- sp332 13y agoYeah, check this out from 1998 (two years before OP) https://lkml.org/lkml/1998/9/30/122 https://lkml.org/lkml/1998/9/30/122
- cshimmin 13y agoWait is this where the original idea for git came from?
- sp332 13y agoLarry McVoy was the BitKeeper guy. This was early in terms of distributed version control, but I have no idea if it was the first or just (for a while) the most popular. Linus wrote git using several lessons he learned from using BitKeeper. It's not just a copy, though.