5 ms·
massively corrupt The data, comparative experiences, and commons sense, disagrees with you. Single payer is easier to audit. Because it's more simple. Health
by specialist 13y ago
massively corrupt
The data, comparative experiences, and commons sense, disagrees with you.
Single payer is easier to audit. Because it's more simple.
Healthcare Fraud: Auditing and Detection Guide [2012]
http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Guide/dp/1118179803/ http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Gu...
Healthcare Fraud: Auditing and Detection Guide [2007]
http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Guide/dp/0470127104/ http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Gu...
And before you say "tort reform", single payer and universal coverage largely eliminates need for malpractice insurance. Again, because we have existence proofs (every country that has single payer) that discerning people can use to inform their opinions.
- cwaniak 13y agoof course! Centralized economic solutions always work the best. The USSR is the best example of that. You people go back to coding and leave economics to economists.
- huherto 13y agoThat is simply not true. Centralized economic solutions work better for some things. Free market soluctions work for other types of things. The USSR was a dictatorship where everything was managed by the State. This is not what it is being proposed.
- specialist 13y agoMarkets are not always the most efficient way to determine price information. Further, most transactions are private or semi private, meaning not conducted via an open market. The amount one business unit (or agency) charges another for goods and services may be informed by a market price, but not necessarily.
- cwaniak 13y ago> Centralized economic solutions work better for some things. I could also say that 2 and 2 not always is 4. Please give concrete examples.
- arg01 13y agoTragedy of the commons type problems. Concrete example: CFC Regulations. Prisoners Dilema type problems. Concrete example: Cigarette advertising bans. (I'll clarify that this is better for the companies involved on a competition between company basis and "better" for the public in the form of a shrinking tobacco market) More to the point a real concrete example is healthcare costs. Per person they are cheaper in comparable countries to the US such as UK, Australia, Canada all countries with public healthcare systems (this is including the tax money spent). I would also point out that if you are going to argue that health outcomes are better in the US than those other systems (Maybe that's true, I couldn't say) you are missing the key point of what these non free market systems can be good at (that is capturing externalities, like in this instance bankruptcy or inability to afford service).
- cwaniak 13y agoYou claim cigarate bans helped tobacco industry? CFC helped grow corporations? Because if all you are saying is that regulation is destroying industries, well that's actually my point. And yes the US Government involvement and regulation in the Healthcare industry in the US destroyed it too. Up till 1960s and invention of Government intervention into US healthcare system, the healthcare in the US was cheap, affordable and the US kept #1 spot for longevity in the world. After medicare, medicaid and all the other Government involvement and regulation in healthcare in the US (i.e. 10% of GDP in the US goes to healthcare) we have #50 in longevity and nobody can afford it. Blaming capitalism for that just shows your ignorance.
- specialist 13y agoApologies, I don't follow. Healthcare was cheaper before cigarettes were heavily regulated or after? Which is it? Or perhaps you're arguing that corporate profits are more important than people?
- cwaniak 13y agoJust read again and if you still don't get it, keep reading. And no, Government regulation isn't more important than people.
- mikeash 13y agoI'll leave economics to economists the moment economists can agree on, well, anything.
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoI'm continually amazed at the number of ways the current US system is centralized, usually in an arcane manner e.g. prices that hospitals can charge for things being set by a committee. You've got all the bad parts of centralized bureaucracy without any of the good bits. (edit: also, it's hard to tell how many layers of sarcasm your post has, but economists generally agree on centralising certain aspects of healthcare. Insurance is a fairly well studied topic in general.
- ElDiablo666 13y agoTort reform also has no bearing on cost outcomes, according to the data. Texas is one example. It's solely designed to prevent human beings from holding corporations accountable for their actions. The reason people bring it up is because it's just straight up propaganda preventing them from thinking. Single payer is inarguably more effective, efficient, and cheaper. Also, "I'm against a public system because it's corrupt"? But this private system is a-ok, no corruption at all! FFS.