10 ms·
I have a feeling that people in the Bitcoin community are going to start learning the results of a truly free market, lack of regulations, and the dangers of de
by slg 13y ago
I have a feeling that people in the Bitcoin community are going to start learning the results of a truly free market, lack of regulations, and the dangers of dealing with a bank that you can't trust.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- celticninja 13y agountil you can transfer fiat money, either USD/GBP/EURO, into a decentralised exchange it just wil not work. A decentralised exchange would work for pure crypto currency to cryptocurrency trading but never for fiat exchanges as they will always need to be tied to a bank account somewhere.
- celticninja 13y agoI thunk that is scaremongering nonsense. This is nothing to do with a free market, this is a software bug that has been well known but until yesterday it didnt affect many people. Someone is now trying to use it to obtain some sort of advantage but it doesnt actually allow them to steal any bitcoins. Quite how you manage to link it to be a result of a "truly free market" is beyond me.
- schrodinger 13y agoWhen it's a bank, the bug and liability is on them
- celticninja 13y agoSo what? This is an exchange not a bank. There are no missing bitcoins so there is no liability issue. All that has happened is that there has been an introduction of a delay in withdrawing. Because that delay is 72 hours it seems like a long time in bitcoin because of usually instant transactions. Compared to traditional banking it is relatively normal length of time to access funds.
- gtirloni 13y agoPrecisely because it's an exchange and not a bank that any delays in transactions are problematic. I don't think the comparison is fair.
- yohanatan 13y agoFYI: It takes 3 days to get USD out of TD Ameritrade too.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ogreyonder 13y ago5+ days for Fidelity
- dandelany 13y ago...TD Ameritrade is a bank.
- yohanatan 13y agoI was referring to a trading account at TD Ameritrade. I cannot speak of their banking capabilities nor do I see how it is relevant.
- slg 13y agoThe lines are blurred here between an exchange and a bank. Exchanges normally don't hold your personal assets. Bank of America holds my equities. I trust them to execute the trades on my behalf on the NASDAQ exchange. If something goes wrong with the exchange, I trust Bank of America to have my back (or at least trust that I have legal ramifications if they don't). With Bitcoin the entity holding your assets and operating the trading mechanisms are generally the same company. This leaves a customer in a weaker position and could allow the exchange/brokerage/bank to get away with shadier practices. They can do things like delay the execution of a transaction until it better benefits them. Or they can unillaterally suspend the ability to withdraw funds with no advance notice, just as what is happening here.
- jwr 13y agoMy banks regularly have bugs in their software, and regularly make mistakes. The mistakes are "on them". So what? At the end of the day I don't have access to my money, or I have to call their "customer support" and spend hours explaining the problem that they created. If the bank goes down completely (as in: goes bankrupt), my deposits are only guaranteed by the state up to a certain limit, which isn't that high. Regulation and "liability" buy me very little in real terms.
- Jtsummers 13y agoWhat sort of bugs have you seen in your bank? My money, at BoA (was several different banks before they got merged into that monstrosity) and later USAA has always been accessible to me. No debits against my account that didn't belong.
- AndyJ1972 13y agoNot sure why this is being down-voted as it is essentially true. Large banks do have bugs, and sometimes even admit it. [0][1] The fractional reserve system basically means if there is a problem, you need to be the first at the counter. If you are not, you will only get a certain amount of money back. [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/2737388/Bug-crunches-Halifax-mortgage-numbers.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/2737388/Bug-crunches-Hali... [1] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/lloyds-banking-systems-failure-hits-22m-retail-customers-8199975.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/lloyds-bankin... Edit to add: (But not quite the same as the one above) http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2426519/Gang-arrested-1-3million-Barclays-hijack-plot-carbon-copy-Santander-scam.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2426519/Gang-arreste... http://article.wn.com/view/2012/06/26/Lloyds_TSB_computer_glitch_delays_mortgage_customers_complet/ http://article.wn.com/view/2012/06/26/Lloyds_TSB_computer_gl...
- JumpCrisscross 13y ago>The fractional reserve system basically means if there is a problem, you need to be the first at the counter. If you are not, you will only get a certain amount of money back. In any system with deposit or investor insurance, e.g. the United States, you will get back the full insured amount (up to $250 000 for bank deposits, $500 000 for investor funds). Beyond that you will be treated as the senior creditor that, as a depositor or investor, you are. If you want more certainty as to the return of your capital, buy Treasuries.
- msgilligan 13y agoWhen it's the banks, and the bug is big and systemic -- the liability is on all of us.
- baddox 13y agoUnless that "bug" is a propensity to offer predatory loans. In that case, the liability is on the taxpayers.
- CamperBob2 13y agoWhen it's a bank, the ... liability is on them Stop, you're killing me here.
- bboston7 13y agoDo you care to offer any sort of evidence instead of just a snide remark? Any FDIC insured bank has your back up to $250,000.
- CamperBob2 13y agoI think the events of the last few years have provided adequate evidence regarding the nature of "liability" as it applies to banks.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ok_craig 13y agoEveryone involved already knows things like this can happen.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoI think a lot of it has to do with the mentality of considering exchanges to be banks.
- snitko 13y agoNo. People in the Bitcoin community would not in a million years want governments be involved in Bitcoin, regulating things. Exchanges need independent audit and insurance, but not greedy government bureaucrats waiting to be bribed. We want information and independent audit, not regulation.
- pessimizer 13y agoDoes using Bitcoin require one to join the libertarian hivemind?
- snitko 13y agoNo, but you have to be kidding yourself if you believe that Bitcoin will not make governments weaker and libertarian-minded people stronger. Satoshi, who one can argue, is a libertarian/crypto-anarchist allegedly holds 10% of all Bitcoins. You think if Bitcoin takes off that's going to mean nothing? If not, you better start fighting Bitcoin now.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ninjac0der 13y agoNo, but becoming aware of the immense problems with our current financial system helps.
- dragontamer 13y agoDogecoin has a much lighter outlook on the whole cryptocurrency. I suggest playing with Dogecoins. It is beginning to become serious, and their community prefers to stay out of this political nonsense. Dogecoins took some practical things and made them better. No ASICs exist yet for Dogecoin, so its still possible to mine them on normal computers. 1-minute block times means they're much faster than Bitcoins, and its refreshingly silly that people are sending each other thousands of DOGE at a time. (current exchange: $10 == 5,680 DOGE) So it is ridiculously easy to get yourself thousands of DOGEs to play with.
- baddox 13y agoGovernment regulated banks are no more trustworthy. This appears to be a software bug revealed by an organized attack. Government software, and software regulated by governments, is also vulnerable to software bugs and organized attacks.
- dragontamer 13y agoYou are guaranteed $100,000 in free insurance when you deposit your money at an FDIC-insured bank. No matter what bugs, attacks, malware or whatever happens, the US Government will pay you back your deposited money, to the fullest extent that it can. If you don't see why this is useful, maybe you need a sanity check.
- baddox 13y ago> to the fullest extent that it can. That's the key.
- dragontamer 13y agoPlease, in the hundred year history of the FDIC, give me an example where it has failed to pay back the deposit of a failed bank.
- afterburner 13y agoThe only way it won't pay you back the full 100,000 is if the US goes bankrupt. Which considering the US dollar is the world's reserve currency, is not going to happen.
- skorgu 13y ago$250k per institution actually.
- Jtsummers 13y agoAnd per ownership category [1]. If you're married and set things up right you can have a lot of money insured at a single institution. [1] http://www.fdic.gov/deposit/deposits/dis/ http://www.fdic.gov/deposit/deposits/dis/
- jdreaver 13y agoCan you give me an example of a truly free market from history? By that, I mean absolutely no government involvement and regulation? I want to know what you mean by free market.
- joelhaus 13y agoA "truly free market" is like a unicorn, it only exists in fairy tales. In reality, Somalia is probably the closest you'll come.
- patrickaljord 13y agoSomalia is anything but a free market. Free market supposes that there is rule of law, that is to say individuals are free to pursue their own lives so long as they respect the equal rights of others. If you think this is the case in Somalia, you should go on a trip there and have fun. It's not an example of limited pro-freedom governments either as it is ruled by war lords, and what are war lords if not despotic numerous governments?
- walden42 13y agoI agree. People will soon start seeing more and more responsibility over time as more bugs and bad practices get exposed, and more competitors start getting involved to solve existing issues. You can be sure this problem won't happen anymore, and we certainly won't need any regulations and other regulatory obstacles to overcome.
- VMG 13y agoThey already are, and it works tremendously. There are multiple exchanges all around the world that compete for the business of customers and innovating in a break-neck speed, none of which would even exist if there was government regulation. Bugs are fixed and problems are addressed faster than the average legislator can spell "malleability". It would work even better if there was less regulation and investors could fund exchanges in the US without having to buy a bank, so that development could actually happen everywhere and not only in Japan and Slovenia.
- gamblor956 13y agoRegulation would have provided that they would have gotten their funds back/in a timely manner. Lack of regulation means that others learn from their misfortune.
- Hermel 13y agoRegulation would have suffocated Bitcoin already in its early days. Regulation comes at a cost. As it eliminates risks, it also eliminates chances.
- VMG 13y agoThe exchanges we are talking about are not based in the US because it is impossible to create an exchange thanks to regulation.
- baddox 13y agoEven a "perfect" regulatory system can't preempt all potential issues, so one could also say that regulation only comes about due to the misfortune of others. For example, surely a bunch of people died from bad drugs before the FDA existed.
- drcross 13y agoBitcoin "Banks" (read exchanges) exist only through their reputation. They can die within a few days as shown from MtGox. This is the way traditional banks should operate instead of being propped by tax payers so that they are allowed privatize gains and socialize losses.
- logicallee 13y agoI have a feeling they won't, and will just solve the problem technically. It's how security is done.
- rajacombinator 13y agoYes. In a regulated, unfree market, the banks you can't trust can send armed government stormtroopers to your home.