2 ms·
The problem with "fully a quarter" is WRT Chicago they're talking about a metro area, Skokie and Romeoville, maybe Lake Geneva, heck maybe Milwaukee... I'm tal
by VLM 13y ago
The problem with "fully a quarter" is WRT Chicago they're talking about a metro area, Skokie and Romeoville, maybe Lake Geneva, heck maybe Milwaukee... I'm talking about actually in the city, walk to work, urban renewal stuff, not suburb a long commute away. Like the north side of Milwaukee or south side of Chicago. Not say, Chenequa (which is a rather wealthy suburb of Milwaukee, more or less, but is technically part of the "metro area")
For example, and I speak from experience, there are no middle class people left anymore in the city of Milwaukee. School district stats show 90%+ poverty rates in the public schools, and a couple $25K/yr private schools for the wealthy leaders, and almost nobody in between, until you commute at least 5 to 10 miles away.
- rayiner 13y agoThe idea of urban renewal is getting people to move back from the suburbs into core cities or satellite cities. Your contention was that this is ridiculous, because for "99% of the population" their urban living options are places like Camden, not NYC or SF. My point is that 25% of the population lives in metro areas where moving to the core city or a satellite city would not mean moving to a place anything like Camden. This is particularly true for places like New York or Chicago (combined, almost 10% of the whole U.S. population), where you can live in a little satellite town with a walkable, urban, downtown area, and commute to work in the core city on METRA/Metro North/LIRR/NJT. Re: school statistics. Chicago also has 90% low-income in the school district, but there are tons of middle class people in the city. A lot of the gap is filled by parochial schools. For example, Chicago has ~400,000 school aged kids enrolled in CPS, 87% of which are low-income. But it has ~615,000 school-aged kids. There are 30,000 kids enrolled in Catholic schools alone.
- akgerber 13y agoThere are plenty of middle class people left in the city of Milwaukee, on the East Side, and in Bay View, and the Third Ward, and Downtown, beyond. MPS has an 81% student poverty rate, not 90+%[0]. Good students in MPS can access the magnet schools, where, to use my sister as an example, one can complete sufficient IB classes to get a BS and MS within 4 years, leading up to a PhD from MIT. Marquette University HS, the high-end Jesuit school, has tuition of $11,000. And the cost of private school is reflected in the lower home prices and property taxes in the city of Milwaukee. Milwaukee isn't a shining city on a hill, but there's plenty of good living to be had there, and at a very low price compared to many cities. It has more than its share of problems due to un- and underemployment since its industrial fall, but it's nothing like Camden. [0]http://www.milwaukeenns.org/2013/08/09/poverty-crime-contribute-to-uncertain-outlook-for-mps/ http://www.milwaukeenns.org/2013/08/09/poverty-crime-contrib...