4 ms·
I support this effort 100%, but... there's something a bit off about the messaging that I can't quite put my finger on. Perhaps "the day"? This is going to be
by davidw 13y ago
I support this effort 100%, but... there's something a bit off about the messaging that I can't quite put my finger on. Perhaps "the day"? This is going to be a long haul, not like killing SOPA or some other bad bill. This system is entrenched, and has a lot of support. It's going to be a long fight, and it's going to be a slog.
For those in the US, though, please do call your representatives.
- KiwiCoder 13y agoIf I had to point to one thing it would be "the day". * It's clearly going to take more than a day to achieve a positive outcome in a system that was established over many decades * What happens when "the day" ends? * Since the action is framed as "the day", this is how the media will report on it - including outcomes of the day. These outcomes, whatever they are, will be packaged with the day and thus more easily dismissed than, say, "the movement" (which continues to grow) or "the tide" (that is turning) or "the big cleanup" (which must be repeated regularly)
- dkrich 13y agoI think drives like these (whether intended to or not) result in heightened awareness of a problem, not necessarily a fixed outcome. If something like this took place once a year (where sites protest mass surveillance) it would assure that people continue to discuss the issue instead of slowly forgetting about it. Labeling the effort "The Day We Fight Back" has a certain "shock" value that intrigues people. If instead it were marketed as "let's talk about long-term strategies for dismantling mass-surveillance" support would probably trickle in. After all, signing a petition or putting a url on your site isn't really "fighting back," it's a protesting.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoAgreed. Even if the media gives "the day" plenty of coverage, their 24-hour news cycle will simply bury it, and CBSABCNBCCNNFNC viewers will have forgotten it by Friday, and likely not see it again.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThis is the marketing effort. Getting out a message means bringing as many voices together at the same time. Getting press coverage. Making noise. Diluting that influence over a longer period of time dilutes the call. That said: yes, a longer-term call to action would be a damned good thing.