3 ms·
Maybe that's not the purpose of karma on HN. Maybe the purpose is to assist its users in making judgments about various issues. If a bunch of smart people read
by mhb 17y ago
Maybe that's not the purpose of karma on HN. Maybe the purpose is to assist its users in making judgments about various issues. If a bunch of smart people read a thoughtful comment and indicate their agreement or disagreement via voting, why isn't that useful to someone when forming their own opinion?
As an analogy, consider the issue of global warming. Very few people can invest the time to decide the issue based on primary research. Instead they rely on secondary or tertiary reports, consensus of the scientists involved and their reputations. This is the comment karma system made large.
- scott_s 17y agoI use the moderation system here as an asymmetric control: if I agree/like something, I upvote it. I don't downvote if I disagree/dislike something. I only downvote when I think something is not a part of legitimate discussion. If I encounter a 0 or -1 post that I think is legit, I will upvote it.