6 ms·
"But I can't go really long without facebook since all is planned from there, the parties, the social events, the foreign friends visiting my city, foreign frie
by Loughla 13y ago
"But I can't go really long without facebook since all is planned from there, the parties, the social events, the foreign friends visiting my city, foreign friends keeping in touch with me..."
I have two questions to respond to this - how did people do all of these things before the facebook platform? What is stopping you from doing these same things?
I find it fascinating that people treat websites like facebook like an actual addiction, and are scared of the withdraw problems in their social life. Is there such a thing as social addiction? Is that a thing?
- mullingitover 13y ago> I have two questions to respond to this - how did people do all of these things before the facebook platform? What is stopping you from doing these same things? 1) They used other services (e.g. Evite) which had the same effect 2) Nobody uses those other services anymore (okay, I got one evite from the one friend who refused to use facebook...and then somebody created the event page on facebook and all the party planning promptly got hijacked and moved there) So your choices are to use Facebook and get invited to parties, or be like that guy from ten years ago who refused to get an email address and was butthurt that nobody would pick up the phone to personally invite him to the party.
- Loughla 13y agoI feel like that is a false choice. The only options are to either not do anything and be 'butthurt' or use facebook? What about relationships with people? What about carrier pigeons? What about personal servants? All of those things are able to do what you're complaining about, they just take slightly more effort. I guess it's to each his own - is your support of a terrible, invasive company more important than your convenience? That's up to you.
- mullingitover 13y agoEh, Facebook isn't that terrible. I'm not saying I think they're good, but they make what is currently the modern equivalent of the telephone. It is what it is. And it's not about my convenience, it's about not inconveniencing my friends by demanding that they remember that I'm a special snowflake who won't use the dominant communication platform of the day, and I must have my special needs attended to by using older, more inconvenient channels each time they want to send out a mass party invite.
- pirateking 13y agoThat is a terrible analogy. The modern telephone is the computer, and Facebook, if being forced to stick with the telephone analogy, is some kind of phone book / telemarketer / wiretap agency hybrid. The fact that computers are too inconvenient to use for communication without using locked centralized platforms and proprietary software is a testament to the failure of computers as a communication tool, rather than a good argument for the necessity of Facebook, which actually is terrible and worth resisting.
- mullingitover 13y ago> The fact that computers are too inconvenient to use for communication without using locked centralized platforms and proprietary software is a testament to the failure of computers as a communication tool Or maybe social communication platforms are a natural monopoly and the computers are working just fine.
- Loughla 13y agoPlease describe this theory for me. I have always had a hard time understanding the concept of 'natural monopoly' when most of nature and the human experience demands diversification.
- datphp 13y agoHuh, I'm from the few who never even created a Facebook account. Whenever something is up, everyone knows I won't get the memo, and they give me a mail/text/call. Usually more than one person. And you can't compare that to email vs phone. Phone is costly, time consuming, single threaded. Sending a message on Facebook or an email doesn't make any difference.
- prostoalex 13y ago> I have two questions to respond to this - how did people do all of these things before the facebook platform? What is stopping you from doing these same things? Some of "these things" did not exist before. Like yesterday a former coworker of mine posted a bunch of pictures of her kids growing up, it was interesting and reminded me how the time flies. Would I ask around acquaintances for her phone number, then get on the phone and ask her to send me a printed photo album of her children? Yeah, that seems non-creepy at all. Friend of my spouse checked in at a restaurant that's opened just recently, I saw my wife liking it, and asked about opinion of the food. Would the "before" solution include compiling a list of my + my spouse's friends with their respective phone numbers, then calling everybody inquiring which restaurants they recently visited? Passive information discovery sucked before.
- seren 13y agoThis is a bit disingenuous to say these kind of reflection were not possible before. What happened in the old days was that your social life was much more localized : your street, your neighborhood, your village, your parish, etc. So rather that looking at pictures, you would be on your porch and you would be looking at your friend's kids playing in the street , wondering how all these years had gone so fast. Social platform allow to extend your social network beyond some (arbitrary) geographical limitations, but it does not really add anything to the human experience that was not there before, so to speak. I know that I am stating the obvious, but I think "some of these things did not exit before" was a bit too strong.
- prostoalex 13y agoYeah, communication and conversation was very location-dependent.
- interstitial 13y agoJesus H. Christ, watch some old TV shows and movies. How would one see coworkers kid's photos before facebook!?! They'd pull them out of their wallet or purse, an album on the coffee table. It was a cliche and staple of sitcoms to be annoyed by the endless stream of kid photos from a wallet.
- marvin 13y agoFacebook is simply, hands down, the easiest service on which to do these things today. It's only an addiction in the same sense that using a cellphone is an addiction. You could just as easily use a landline, or schedule meetings with friends and co-workers a day in advance, by writing them a letter, talking to them in person or getting in touch with them through common friends. Less convenient, sure, but equally functional. To me, avoiding Facebook in the absence of any negatives (you are free to log on only whenever you want to) seems like some strange puritanical or old-fashioned ritual. Why avoid something that works?
- hueving 13y ago>I have two questions to respond to this - how did people do all of these things before the facebook platform? What is stopping you from doing these same things? Simple. It was just harder so it did't happen nearly as often. If someone is complaining about an airline, you don't respond with, "How did people get from LA to NYC before airlines? What is stopping you from doing it that way?" People vastly underestimate the value of the network effects on Facebook.