5 ms·
I think this is a total hit piece. "They’re preying on people who are desperate for a vaccine," As a contributor (and a scientist) - I don't feel like I've be
by dnautics 13y ago
I think this is a total hit piece.
"They’re preying on people who are desperate for a vaccine,"
As a contributor (and a scientist) - I don't feel like I've been preyed upon, at all.
- Fomite 13y agoI didn't view it as a hit piece, because that's not the author talking. And while I don't necessarily agree with it, I do think that they're long on "Crowdfunded free HIV vaccine" and short on specifics. And I'd still be pleased as punch if it worked.
- reidrubsamen 13y agoHi! This is Reid, CEO of immunity project. Thanks for your comments! Our previous work is under review by a PRJ - our crowd funding is allowing us to do additional work which we will try to publish as quickly as possible! We have our white paper on our web site - if you want to discuss more details please shoot us an email at team@ImmunityProject.org
- Fomite 13y agoThanks for the reply - I know my comments sound a little harsh, but I really am rooting for you guys. I read over the white paper, but honestly, my expertise is way down the road from where you guys are right now.
- icinnamon 13y agoIan from Immunity Project here. Here's a link to our White Paper, as well: http://www.immunityproject.org/documents/Immunity_Project_White_Paper.pdf http://www.immunityproject.org/documents/Immunity_Project_Wh...
- alexnking 13y agoI'm probably missing something obvious here, but who would be desperate for a vaccine? If there were offering a cure, then I could see a complaint where they were preying on people with the disease who were desperate for a cure. Since that's not the case, do they mean the contributors, wanting to help develop the vaccine, are desperate, and being preyed upon? Because I hardly think that applies.
- nickthemagicman 13y agoThis is the way science should be funded. Imagine if the pace of medical research moved at the pace of javascript frameworks. We would all be fucking immortal. There would probably be some mutants though. But you gotta crack some eggs.
- icinnamon 13y agoHi- Ian from Immunity Project here. Thank you for your support! We know our fundraising approach for this experiment is novel, and we believe it's the fastest way to get it done.
- nickthemagicman 13y agoThanks for stepping out on a limb and doing something disruptive and new! We need more open source science!
- Fomite 13y ago"Fail fast, fail often" is less of a good thing when it's actual people's lives.
- jseliger 13y ago"Fail fast, fail often" is less of a good thing when it's actual people's lives. It depends. A lot of people are already losing their lives through inaction. This is slightly tangential, Alex Tabarrok's book Launching the Innovation Renaissance is good on the subject of FDA inertia and spending too much time trying to prove efficacy and too little emphasis on experimentation and rapid iteration: http://www.amazon.com/Launching-Innovation-Renaissance-Market-ebook/dp/B006C1HX24?ie=UTF8&tag=thstsst-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957 http://www.amazon.com/Launching-Innovation-Renaissance-Marke... .
- nickthemagicman 13y agoDamn bro you're dropping eggs of wisdom on all of us. I agree. You give the kids a PCR machine and suddenly everyone is dead. Better stop now before it's too late.
- gregcrv 13y agoYes, and I prefer many "desperate" healthy people choosing to give little money to fund alternative researches (even if sometimes it fails) than big pharmaceutical companies bankrupting "desperate" ill patients (and families) for a cure that's not guaranty to save them. Reading this http://priceonomics.com/the-rapidly-escalating-price-of-cancer-drugs/ http://priceonomics.com/the-rapidly-escalating-price-of-canc... makes me think that drug industry is broken.