12 ms·

Well, every reason except that the site for trading Magic The Gathering Online cards never went live. And that trading currencies is a completely different tas

Well, every reason except that the site for trading Magic The Gathering Online cards never went live. And that trading currencies is a completely different task than trading cards.

gnaritas 13y ago
That it never went live is not relevant, it doesn't mean code wasn't written or re-used. So he pivoted before going live, so what?
- benologist 13y ago
  In this fantasy is the surviving code supposed to be mission critical stuff that magically applied to the completely different second business and survived the years and growth since 2011?
  - gnaritas 13y ago
    > In this fantasy Fuck off then.
    - benologist 13y ago
      Numerous people have posted information with sources that directly conflicts with most of your opinions, while you ride on this apparent "4+ years ago some dude maybe reused some source" for whatever that's even supposed to mean. MtGox has more traffic than HN, survived immense press and growth over the last couple years as bitcoin rose into mainstream popularity, and did so as a market leader for most of that time. That alone should tell you very little if any source remains, it's not like that dude's beta that apparently never even launched was likely to just scale through several orders of magnitude more traffic and solve every problem and new or different need along the way. Fantasy sounds like exactly the right term. Unless you have any proof. Do you?
  - TeMPOraL 13y ago
    Well, I have a hobby project for trading X, then I decide I want to have a project for trading Y; isn't this an obvious instinct to modify the one I'm already working on to fit a new purpose, instead of starting for scratch? If the author didn't know much about complexities of money trade, I'm pretty sure he did just that. I've seen people retrofitting their CMSes to do everything. Hell, I even did this myself with my hobby game engine. It's common for programmers.
    - gnaritas 13y ago
      Thank you for some common fucking sense; that's exactly what programmers do and exactly what would have happened. Gox most certainly has code originally built for a card game.
username223 13y ago
> And that trading currencies is a completely different task than trading cards. Right -- you can use Magic cards to play a fun game, as well as to try to make speculative bets. Bitcoins are that, minus the fun.

Well, every reason except that the site for trading Magic The Gathering Online cards never went live. And that trading currencies is a completely different task than trading cards.

gnaritas 13y ago

That it never went live is not relevant, it doesn't mean code wasn't written or re-used. So he pivoted before going live, so what?

benologist 13y ago
In this fantasy is the surviving code supposed to be mission critical stuff that magically applied to the completely different second business and survived the years and growth since 2011?
- gnaritas 13y ago
  > In this fantasy Fuck off then.
  - benologist 13y ago
    Numerous people have posted information with sources that directly conflicts with most of your opinions, while you ride on this apparent "4+ years ago some dude maybe reused some source" for whatever that's even supposed to mean. MtGox has more traffic than HN, survived immense press and growth over the last couple years as bitcoin rose into mainstream popularity, and did so as a market leader for most of that time. That alone should tell you very little if any source remains, it's not like that dude's beta that apparently never even launched was likely to just scale through several orders of magnitude more traffic and solve every problem and new or different need along the way. Fantasy sounds like exactly the right term. Unless you have any proof. Do you?
- TeMPOraL 13y ago
  Well, I have a hobby project for trading X, then I decide I want to have a project for trading Y; isn't this an obvious instinct to modify the one I'm already working on to fit a new purpose, instead of starting for scratch? If the author didn't know much about complexities of money trade, I'm pretty sure he did just that. I've seen people retrofitting their CMSes to do everything. Hell, I even did this myself with my hobby game engine. It's common for programmers.
  - gnaritas 13y ago
    Thank you for some common fucking sense; that's exactly what programmers do and exactly what would have happened. Gox most certainly has code originally built for a card game.

username223 13y ago

> And that trading currencies is a completely different task than trading cards. Right -- you can use Magic cards to play a fun game, as well as to try to make speculative bets. Bitcoins are that, minus the fun.