4 ms·
If you're acting on the results of your heuristic, without being completely sure, that neatly fits my definition of faith. This whole topic is arguably one of m
by andrewflnr 13y ago
If you're acting on the results of your heuristic, without being completely sure, that neatly fits my definition of faith. This whole topic is arguably one of mismatched definitions.
You're backlashing against other people's bad logic, and in so doing letting it cloud your own thinking.
- leobelle 13y agoYour definition of faith is so large to allow you to believe anything and you will end up deluded as a result.
- andrewflnr 13y agoUm, not really. If I act on my "faith" that I can fly off rooftops, I will die. That doesn't strictly prevent me from doing so, but that's probably not what you mean when you say "believe anything". If I say I believe I can fly but refuse to actually jump off a roof, you can pretty safely call me a liar. Practically and biblically, faith is defined by action. Anything else is probably just smoke.
- leobelle 13y agoYou have written a bunch of nonsense. And of course you won't ever believe that you can fly off of rooftops, because it will be immediately apparent that you cannot do so. It's the same why nobody believes God will ever heal amputees. Nobody prays in public for someone who's lost an arm to grow one back. But vague beliefs where you can fudge the truth a bit with a little religious delusion, sure you believe that stuff. Now let's go all laugh at the Flat Earth Society.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoThis topic has lots of problems with mismatched definitions, but there is an actual problem hidden in all of that - namely, one side tends to use inconsistent definitions, while the other does not. Your definition of "faith" for example seems to be "anything you believe even though you are not completely sure about it"? By that definition, some fundamentalist's belief in god is not faith, but when some physicist tells you that some house exists, say, then that is faith? Sounds like a pretty useless definition to me - plus I doubt that that is the actual definition you use, outside of providing a definition?
- jerf 13y ago"Your definition of "faith" for example seems to be "anything you believe even though you are not completely sure about it"?" andrewflnr just told you what his definition of faith is, and that was manifestly not it. Try reading again. I notice this easily because I favor this as the most useful of the myriad definitions of "faith" in real life. It isn't the only one, and it isn't the most popular one, but it's the most useful one. And that is the beginning and the end of the definition; it simply does not encompass "what you believe in even though you know it isn't true" or anything like that; it is an action-based definition that pays little attention to what people say, which, in this particular domain, is a major virtue. To see what someone has faith in by this definition (which, again, is not the only one), watch their actions.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoNo, he didn't, he only gave an example, and I extrapolated from that. As for your definition, I don't think it's particularly useful, because there already is a word for that, but well ... @"what you believe in even though you know it isn't true": that strikes me as nonsenical. How could anyone consider something to be true ("believe" it) while knowing it isn't (thus presumably believing that it isn't true?)?
- andrewflnr 13y agoActually, jerf understood me perfectly.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoGiven that I obviously did not, then, you might notice that that is a somewhat pointless reply.