9 ms·
I am shocked, shocked that anyone could have experienced issues banking with Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange.
by PhasmaFelis 13y ago
I am shocked, shocked that anyone could have experienced issues banking with Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange.
- pekk 13y agoWhich is what people call it now that it lost credibility. Rewind a few months, and the story is different.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoIn my defense, I was mocking Mt.Gox before it was cool.
- dsuth 13y agoPeople have been calling it that for as long as I've followed BTC and MTGox; that is, after all, it's name. And there have been serious questions about it's credibility in all that time as well.
- schenecstasy 13y agoMy Treant casts Protection from Normal Missiles and makes an attack of opportunity.
- benologist 13y agoReferring to it like that is just as stupid as when people used to say "M$".
- lmm 13y agoNot when that's its actual name. (Also I hear it's written in Personal Home Page)
- benologist 13y agoThey were never under any obligation to use mtgox.com for their original idea for all eternity, and on HN of all places there is no shame in pivoting to a better idea.
- gnaritas 13y agoThere's no shame in a pivot, but there's also valid reason to criticize a pivot to something you can't handle. Trading cards is not like trading currencies.
- kinghajj 13y agoThe person who started the card-trading site is not the same person who currently owns MtGox. The original owner did convert it into a Bitcoin exchange, but then sold early on (I believe pre-2011 spike) to let someone else deal with the hassles.
- gnaritas 13y agoI'm aware of that, but it's not relevant to the point I made. If the original site was re-purposed, it doesn't matter who currently owns it.
- gnaritas 13y agoNot the OP, but no, no it's not. That Gox used to be a trading site for game cards very much speaks to their being unprepared for the difficulty of being a currency exchange. You can't honestly think a trading card site had the correct platform to just become a currency exchange and not suffer any technical debt or architectural issues from not being built as a currency exchange from the beginning.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- benologist 13y agoThat Gox used to be something else means nothing. What matters is what it is - and that is not a trading card site. Millions of domains were something else. Many of us have pivoted from one idea to the next while salvaging what we can or what we learned. I also don't think being in over your head or having architectural issues is a crime - it's the default state for startups, especially ones trying to keep up with big growth. Putting shit on mtgox for being the quintessential bootstrapped startup, on HN, is just stupid.
- gnaritas 13y ago> That Gox used to be something else means nothing. I just explained why it does mean something, so we simply disagree.
- benologist 13y agoIf they're still using the source code from 2010 when it was a completely different business with a completely different name with a completely different purpose owned by a completely different person, according to the Wikipedia link you posted.
- gnaritas 13y agoYou're pretending this was just a domain name sale; that's not what the public story is, the story is that it was re-purposed by the original owner who then sold it to the current owners so there's every reason to believe it's based on the original code.
- elif 13y agoA pivot from a real-time exchange to a real-time exchange isn't that hard. They've had 2 years to implement proper security and safeguards. It's not like going from, say, refrigerators to cruise missiles[0]. The real failure is the way this company operates, not how it gained its popularity. I am shocked that gox still has 8-9x the volume of btc-e[1] after at least 3 avoidable long term service interruptions. The real sardonic mockery should be directed at the clowns who still have their coins and dollars on gox's one server. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raytheon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raytheon [1] assuming the trade volume isn't being manipulated somehow
- anigbrowl 13y agoIt's not like going from, say, refrigerators to cruise missiles Well you don't want either to go off accidentally :>
- dingaling 13y ago"It's not like going from, say, refrigerators to cruise missiles" Raytheon didn't suddenly jump or "pivot"from domestic appliances to missiles. They acquired Hughes Aircraft and its 40,000 employees of expertise in the mid-1990s, by which time Raytheon was involved in nuclear power, general aviation ( Beech Aircraft ), polymers, pharma... Hughes brought with it the major 'brands' of Tomahawk and AMRAAM.
- blhack 13y agomtgox is just a domain name. Not only is it not the same service at this point, it isn't even the same owners at this point. Throwing "lol Magic: The Gathering", is pretty ignorant.
- CompleteMoron2 13y agowell call me ignorant. They act like it's still a unlaid nerd game.
- cazlab 13y agoyeah goldman sachs was also named after a children's game
- anologwintermut 13y agoIf a magic card trading site starts trading bitcoins using mostly it's existing infrastructure and then sells to someone else, the question is are the new owners still using that hacked together infrastructure? The answer would appear to be yes.
- gwern 13y ago> If a magic card trading site starts trading bitcoins using mostly it's existing infrastructure and then sells to someone else, the question is are the new owners still using that hacked together infrastructure? If someone asks a question based on a false premise by assuming that a site in question ever traded certain things and was not only ever Bitcoin-based, the question is, does that person not know what they're talking about? The answer would appear to be yes.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoEven worse, because the new owners probably don't have a clue about decisions that resulted in the original ifrastructure.
- yohanatan 13y agoEven worse than that because the new owners do not do robust engineering themselves; multiplying fragility by fragility.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]