8 ms·
All empiricists have faith that physical laws do not vary in time.
by javajosh 13y ago
All empiricists have faith that physical laws do not vary in time.
- baddox 13y agoAlso that sensory experience and human perception in general is a reliable source of truth.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Antiquarian 13y agoA belief is not faith if, given evidence, the advocate will discard the belief.
- pfortuny 13y agoYes, but do you have evidence of what will happen? I, on my part, tend to think that I have faith, not proof.
- Antiquarian 13y agoI think that proof is inconsistent with empiricism. There are hypotheses; an observation either strengthens, weakens, or leaves unchanged the confidence in the hypotheses.
- syncerr 13y agoHuh? A physical law is defined as a "... [conclusion] based on repeated scientific experiments and observations over many years and which have become accepted universally within the scientific community."[1] In other words -- something that has been shown not to vary. Faith by definition a "belief that is not based on proof".[2] So you're arguing against the validity of formal logic or the scientific method or that a reached consensus cannot be trusted? EDIT: I think you're overestimating the certainty that an empiricist would have about future events. ___ [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_law [2] http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/faith http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/faith
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pfortuny 13y agoNot that it cannot be trusted but that believing it is a matter of faith. This does not mean it is less human to believe, but that it is patently human to have to believe something. Do not confuse formal logic (which deals with sintax, not meaning, so it has no truth in itself) and the scientific method for which belief is utterly necessary. Trust is not a bad thing. But trust requires faith. Faith is not a bad thing. "Consensus" is not an absolute source of unerring knowledge of reality.
- syncerr 13y agoI wasn't trying to imply that an empiricist would assert anything to be wholly true. Again from the same wiki article: Empiricism, often used by natural scientists, asserts that “knowledge is based on experience” and that “knowledge is tentative and probabilistic, subject to continued revision and falsification.”
- rz2k 13y agoI don't think that is what people are getting at. The precision and accuracy of an empiricist's observations can be off without violating ones faith in empiricism. However, the notion that something can happen, or that the past doesn't change, or that there are causes and effects are necessary assumptions of empiricism. Though assuming that causality is a thing seems to have worked out pretty well, you can also at least conceive a Looking Glass universe where the rules don't work the same and cause and effect are turned on their head.
- weland 13y agoThis is a well-known debate which, IMO, stems from people making word mean what they want them to mean, at various moments, so that they can put up an argument. Empiricist thought means that I do not have faith in, say, Ohm's law. I have simply observed it to be true sufficiently often that I have been able to formulate a set of rules based on which I can tell when it holds and when it doesn't, and that, if I have doubts at any time, I can test it. I carry on my everyday activity being convinced that it is true as a consequence of having observed it. In a sense, yes, I can figuratively say that "I have faith in classical electromagnetism", but not because I think classical electromagnetism is infailible, but because I have observed it making good predictions. I don't have faith that it will work, I have a) proof that it worked before and b) proof that the things now are just like they were before, when it worked. If I stumble upon a case when it doesn't, I will first check my understanding of classical electromagnetism and, after making sure it's correct, I'll try to see why the prediction was incorrect and review my options about the cause of the phenomenon I am observing. Contrast this with my faith in Othin: I haven't observed him anywhere, I'm yet to see a giant and I can't really test whether he exists or not. I carry on my everyday activity being convinced that he exists, but only as a consequence of my faith. If this religious system makes a wrong prediction, I will typically review my understanding of it, but no my doubts. No giants around? Yeah, 'cause Thor HAMMERED THEM ALL!!! YEAH! No one has seen Othin in a thousand years? Well he likes to wander as a stranger, maybe they didn't know it was him. Both mechanisms can fail, of course, but I think their possible failures stem from different origins and through vastly different mechanisms.
- glomph 13y agoThe article isn't really about that. (I made a similarly pithy comment but have deleted it having read the article.)
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoNo, they don't. Or at least they don't need to. If empiricism actually works and gives us (a good approximation of) the truth/reality, then it's probably a good idea to use it, as it allows us to influence our future (assuming free will or whatever, I don't want to get into that). If empiricism doesn't work, then all bets with regards to influencing our future are off, anything you do is essentially random, and what happens as a result is pure chance. Behaving as if empiricism worked does not change that outcome, though. That's why assuming that empricism works is the safe bet, no need to actually believe that it works - it's the one strategy that makes you better off if it works and doesn't change the expected outcome if it doesn't work.
- crpatino 13y agoThis seems awfully close to: sed 's/God/Science/g' PascalWager.template I think in both cases, the meta argument goes like this: "If the world is like I want it to be, then everything conforms to my preferred set of values, so it's worth to follow those values. Otherwise, the world is just too appalling to think about, so let's pretend I did not mention that and stick to following my preferred set of values, ok?"
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoYes, the superficial structure is similar, the content is not at all, plus your summary fits neither Pascal's wager nor my argument for empiricism, I think. Pascal's wager assumes that there either is no god or a god that has particular values, and then deduces from that that you should follow those particular values, because, if no god exists, it won't cost you anything to have done so, while you get a big payoff if that god actually does exist. There are two big flaws in that reasoning: First, it simply ignores the possibility that a god exists, but its values differ from what you assumed them to be, in which case you presumably would lose the game, and secondly, it's kinda obvious that following certain religious doctrine can have major costs. My argument, on the other hand, does not assume any values (except perhaps that it's advantageous to be able to influence your future - find me anyone who seriously disagrees with that and also thinks that it matters whether you believe in some god or not (if you can't influence it anyhow, why should it matter?) ...). It simply shows that as a matter of fact, almost by definition, your only chance of gaining control over you future is empiricism. Possibly, it's impossible, but if it is possible at all, then empiricism is the only way that could possibly work - just assuming some randomly made-up laws of nature instead of extrapolating from past observations can not be a more reliable way to predict the future, in the worst case your extrapolations are also completely unreliable, in which case they are no worse than randomly made-up laws.
- nyan_sandwich 13y agoThis is true but the english expression of it is prone to misunderstanding. See the no free lunch theorem for the technical version of the problem of induction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Free_Lunch_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Free_Lunch_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_free_lunch_in_search_and_optimization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_free_lunch_in_search_and_op...
- moocowduckquack 13y agoGiven there are experiments run to explicitly check for stuff like that (http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10619127.2010.506119#.UvkfJF4fOWM http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10619127.2010.506...), I think you are possibly wrong. I'd put it as "All empiricists have faith that there is not much point in being an empiricist if there is a comedy god fiddling the numbers on purpose, purely to screw with the notion of empiricism, so therefore they cheerfully discount that notion as otherwise they wouldn't get much done."