4 ms·
So you have to find two places of work, shopping, school (potentially several different schools), worship, and recreation all within say 2 miles of your home?
by ars 13y ago
So you have to find two places of work, shopping, school (potentially several different schools), worship, and recreation all within say 2 miles of your home?
Good luck with that.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoHuh? EDIT: Ah I guess you are saying two places of work, one for each adult in a household? Well have you heard of these things called buses and trains? They're awesome. You don't need everything to be in walking distance, as long as both ends are walking distance from transport. Also the nice thing about not being a superstitious throwback is I don't have to find any place to worship, walking distance or otherwise.
- eddieroger 13y agoJust because you don't live ars' life doesn't mean the world should be your way and not his/hers. The term "superstitious throwback" is a really assholic way of dismissing an argument because you don't agree with it.
- sliverstorm 13y agoYou don't need everything to be in walking distance, as long as both ends are walking distance from transport. ... and that would be the problem, in much of the USA.
- atgm 13y ago> Well have you heard of these things called buses and trains? They're awesome. They ARE awesome, but often come at the expense of time. I live in Tokyo, which has an amazing public transportation network. Including walking to/from stations and bus stops, taking the bus/train costs me around 80 minutes of my day each way -- that's over 2 1/2 hours of my day. If I take a taxi directly from my apartment to work, it takes about 15-20 minutes to get directly to work. Let's call it 40 minutes of my day. I can get back two hours of my life every single day with point-to-point transport. That's two hours I could be catching up with friends, reading a book, cooking, exercising, etc. It matters so often to me that I end up paying the 4000 yen or so it costs to take a taxi twice a day a horrifying number of times. This is to say nothing of the fact that I can sit in the taxi and read a book or something rather than being crammed and crushed in public transport.
- saraid216 13y ago> I live in Tokyo, which has an amazing public transportation network. > Including walking to/from stations and bus stops, taking the bus/train costs me around 80 minutes of my day each way That's not actually how we define "amazing public transportation network". My experience of public transit in Seattle is "about 5 minutes away from a bus stop, anywhere, and about 30 minutes to anywhere I care to go in the city, and maybe an hour if I go across the lake to Bellevue or Redmond". The fact that it takes you longer for traveling within the city than it does for me to change cities suggests to me that Tokyo's public transit is either ridiculously bad or you have an extremely unusual case.
- atgm 13y ago> That's not actually how we define "amazing public transportation network". It's pretty comparatively amazing to me. I grew up in rural Pennsylvania in a town with no buses or taxis. The closest train/bus station was about 50 minutes away by car. My apartment has a bus stop right outside its door, but I have to travel the entire bus line to get to where I want to go, and that's 15 minutes from work. There's a train station five minutes from work and two others within ten minutes from work, but none of them go directly to the station closest to my apartment.
- DerpDerpDerp 13y agoThat's trivially easy in most cities, on foot or bike, because we're talking about 12 square miles of city. Add in reasonable public transportation between places, and we're talking more like within 5-10 miles. I simply don't believe that there's an area anywhere around an urban center where you can't find all of that within ~75-300 square miles, as most urban areas simply aren't that big.
- ars 13y agoMost cities already have plenty of public transportation. I thought we were talking about expanding it to sub-urban areas too, and in those places finding all those things within distance is much much harder.
- jeffasinger 13y agoSuburbs as anything other than streetcar suburbs are basically only a thing due to the subsidization of the automobile infrastructure.
- burntsushi 13y agoThen you're just arguing for one way of life over another. I like living in the suburbs. I don't want to feel like a sardine packed into a can. You (or whoever is arguing for it) would rather not live in a world that has tainted nature with roads and automobiles. Why does it have to be one way or another? In the present, there are plenty of places to go and see nature that hasn't been tainted by cars and roads. Many of the people in this thread write as if cars are manifestly obviously bad, and that we should go to great lengths to remove or drastically reduce them from society. I guess I didn't get the memo.
- wtallis 13y agoLiving in the suburbs doesn't mean you avoid the sardines feeling: https://maps.google.com/?ll=35.833819,-78.909173&spn=0.026373,0.033603&t=h&z=15 https://maps.google.com/?ll=35.833819,-78.909173&spn=0.02637... Cars aren't manifestly bad, but that kind of neighborhood is.