3 ms·
> For example, a voting system where one person determined by their status in society has their vote count and everyone elses is discarded is objectively less d
by baddox 13y ago
> For example, a voting system where one person determined by their status in society has their vote count and everyone elses is discarded is objectively less democractic than a voting system where a ballot is selected at random from all voters and is taken to determine the result.
Obviously this is true, but this is rarely one of the voting systems being considered in any discussion about voting systems.
- kybernetikos 13y agoI'm responding to your claim that Arrows theorem debunks attempts to paint some voting systems as objectively more democratic or better than other voting systems. If you think that Arrows theorem really does this, then you should stand by that assertion and defend all voting systems that Arrows theorem applies to as not objectively better than any other voting system that Arrows theorem applies to. And yes, Arrows theorem applies to Dictatorship/Random Ballot/Plurality/Condorcet-loser methods which are the ones I used in my example.
- dllthomas 13y agoIt applies to dictatorship, but doesn't actually tell you anything about it.