3 ms·
I agree with you except for your use of cryptography as an example. In anything dealing with security, unfortunately the nitty-gritty implementation details win
by ForHackernews 13y ago
I agree with you except for your use of cryptography as an example. In anything dealing with security, unfortunately the nitty-gritty implementation details wind up mattering as much (if not more) than the theoretical portion. Most cases of crypto failing are not examples where the algorithm is flawed (or outdated), but rather where the implementation is weak.
Any course on crypto needs to address both algorithms in the abstract and the particularities of how they're implemented in the real world.
- betterunix 13y ago"Any course on crypto needs to address both algorithms in the abstract and the particularities of how they're implemented in the real world." I disagree. There is a rich theory of cryptography that is entirely abstract, for which the low-level details are an irrelevant distraction. Even the AES finalists, which were designed with low-level concerns in mind, are described abstractly and can be implemented at a high level (I have an implementation of Serpent in Common Lisp, for example -- no messing around with low-level details, just a functionally correct block cipher). Within the crypto research community there are people who work on high-level languages suitable for cryptography implementation: http://www.charm-crypto.com/Main.html http://www.charm-crypto.com/Main.html To be fair, there is also an enormous body of work on implementing cryptosystems in the real world -- at least enough to have an entire course dedicated to the topic. If anything, we should really have two courses: an introductory course that covers the theory of cryptography, and a cryptography engineering course that deals with real-world implementations.
- pjmlp 13y ago> In anything dealing with security, unfortunately the nitty-gritty implementation details wind up mattering as much (if not more) than the theoretical portion. Specially if buffer exploits and pointer misuses are to be taken into account.