6 ms·
If you've heard the overused phrase "the internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it" the obvious analogy is intentional destruction of infras
by VLM 13y ago
If you've heard the overused phrase "the internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it" the obvious analogy is intentional destruction of infrastructure results in lower population, lower population density, lower property values...
I don't know the specifics of the linked article, but stereotypically some outsider comes in, says "you have some nice profitable land here, and I have a plan to fix that...". If you'd like to experience anti-car infrastructure, we have plenty of semi-abandoned residential in the poorest parts of the inner city, and some vacant abandoned commercial space in the bad parts of town with limited parking. Of course the restaurant right off the interstate is doing booming business although there's always someone with a plan to "fix" that for them.
"We need more customers... I know, we'll make it impossible for anyone outside walking distance to get here, that'll fix everything..."
What we need is more money spent on roads and parking. Done the right way, of course. Nothing wrong with wide roads, wide sidewalks, strips of parks and trees and green spaces. Just remember where the bread is buttered, pedestrians = homeless panhandler but car = customer.
- pyre 13y ago> pedestrians = homeless panhandler but car = customer. This isn't inflammatory at all... not at all...
- VLM 13y agoGoogle claims "intended to arouse angry ... feelings." I'm trying to be informative. May not like the way things are, but pretending "most people" don't look at the world that way isn't going to produce anything useful. I also have the defense of truth. Other than downtown Manhattan or downtown Chicago, this is how it is. You make money off someone who drives to your business, not some homeless dude who needs to use your bathroom. Customers come in cars. That's just how it is.
- saraid216 13y agoCustomers come in cars because there's no other way to get there. Cars, being hugely inefficient uses of space, actually decreases the number of customers who can get to your store. You can take a fully-packed car and compare the space used to people on a sidewalk: that's the difference in customers you're losing out on.
- VLM 13y agoSeriously? So the best way to get more people in a sports stadium would be to get rid of the parking lot, or walmart's sales would go up if they got rid of their parking lots? Or on a small scale, I'd be more likely to go to a restaurant or small retailer if I knew for certain I couldn't get there on foot and if I drove there, I wouldn't be able to park? Now I do see your point for a stereotypical neighborhood local bar where they shouldn't be driving drunk anyway, or even a small local pharmacy or convenience store/gas station. I've seen poor parts of downtown with empty sidewalks and boarded up storefronts. Must be the parking lots?
- thrownaway2424 13y agoThe principle of charity has long since expired and now we are left to ponder whether you've ever even been to a city. To answer your question, yes, the best way to get people to a stadium is, by far, to remove the parking lot. Here's one of the most well-attended MLB stadiums in the country. It's served by two streetcar lines and a mainline railroad. https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@37.779165,-122.390703,3a,75y,79.92h,94.55t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1sgOor2VIW6zcDwyQCEsYTfA!2e0 https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@37.779165,-122.390703,3... Here's Wrigley Field: https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@41.949016,-87.655596,3a,75y,101.36h,79.79t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1sZG47gz5jCGeHFtqN6Y4NAA!2e0 https://www.google.com/maps/preview/@41.949016,-87.655596,3a... At Yankee stadium they built a parking garage and so few people use it that the garage operator is bankrupt. They are tearing them down. The stadium is served by a subway line and Metro North even has a station literally called "Yankees". I suggest you get out of Mom's basement and see the country before holding forth on its infrastructure.
- chrismcb 13y agoYou are going to compare most of America to New York? The city with perhaps the best American public transport, and the lowest per capita car ownership? I'd rather take public transit to a stadium (barring the recent super bowl) but due to poor public transportation in some places I don't have a choice. The solution isn't to decrease parking lots first. The solution is to improve public transportation, then you can remove the parking lots.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoMultiple studies demonstrate that customers who arrive by car come less often and spend less in total than customers who arrive by any other means. Why? Because it costs the customer a fortune to drive and park their car, so they are spending more on transportation and less on whatever you are selling. The same studies have demonstrated that business owners do not know this. This is why the small business parking delusion persists. This is why small business owners show up at city council meetings across the country to argue against their own best interest. Here's one and you can google for the rest: http://kellyjclifton.com/Research/EconImpactsofBicycling/TRN_280_CliftonMorrissey&Ritter_pp26-32.pdf http://kellyjclifton.com/Research/EconImpactsofBicycling/TRN...
- ffumarola 13y agoI wish establishments that thought this would post it in their windows so I could walk my money right past them. It sounds like you don't live in an urban area, correct me if I'm wrong... because most people I know walk to where they are going in Philadelphia.
- moron4hire 13y agoYou live in South Philly, don't you?
- jessaustin 13y agoWhat we need is more money spent on roads and parking. Done the right way, of course. Nothing wrong with wide roads, wide sidewalks, strips of parks and trees and green spaces. Have you ever visited an urban area? Where on earth would this "infrastructure" be placed? Next to the Best Buy and the Outback Steakhouse?
- jchrisa 13y agoPrinciple of charity requires me to imagine that you just have had the bad luck to be only exposed to outdated ideas... Plenty of places to start, maybe here: http://m.fastcoexist.com/3021074/making-the-economic-case-for-cycling-friendly-cities-with-bikeonomics http://m.fastcoexist.com/3021074/making-the-economic-case-fo...
- gburt 13y ago> Just remember where the bread is buttered, pedestrians = homeless panhandler but car = customer. Hah. What? Driving consumes a tremendous amount of most people's disposable income. I know people who spend $5-10k a year on transportation.
- briandon 13y agoIf someone is living in an urban area without a vehicle, they are likely to be paying more for housing and living in a significantly smaller space than someone living in a lower-density setting (e.g. suburbs) who owns and uses a vehicle of their own and may have a lawn, swimming pool, tool shed, little machine shop or sewing/crafts room, etc. Can you sell more gardening products (seeds, soil, tools, fertilizer, etc.) to someone who has a yard or someone who has a balcony that could potentially accommodate a planter or two? Will you sell more pool toys and equipment to someone who has a pool in their yard or to someone who may periodically use their building's clubhouse's pool or walk to the local municipal pool? How much less furniture or art or carpeting or pretty much anything can you sell to someone who has 500 square feet to live in versus someone who has 1000 to 2000 square feet of space in their home? Smaller kitchens translates into less counter space, so less space for kitchen appliances or even fancy pasta storage containers. The knock-on effects of your customers living in smaller, urban spaces vs. larger suburban-type homes are huge.
- cylinder 13y agoSo the downside to beautifying and reclaiming our cities by discouraging the automobile is that ... we buy less useless crap and live more efficiently? Shudder.
- nhaehnle 13y agoJust remember where the bread is buttered, pedestrians = homeless panhandler but car = customer. I'm not sure if you're trolling or just a bit tone-deaf, but this is an incredibly US-centric way to see things. Seriously, it makes you seem a bit clueless. Clearly, the mindset you voice here is something that city planners in the US need to take into account. The question is, where does this difference come from, and can something be done about it? After all, cars and all the infrastructure surrounding them take up an enormous amount of space, which seems wasteful in the design of efficient and compact cities. How can those inner cities be "revived" in a way that makes them livable?