4 ms·
Your quote is a good one, but I like this one even better: I came to the Open Source world because I liked being part of a community where my ideas, my skills
by pdonis 13y ago
Your quote is a good one, but I like this one even better:
I came to the Open Source world because I liked being part of a community where my ideas, my skills and my experience mattered, not my boobs. That's changed, and it's changed at the hands of the people who say they want a community where ideas, skills and experience matter more than boobs.
I don't at all see her failing to acknowledge that she was fortunate--she had that community, at least for a while, and she explicitly says that others who came later did not. And she makes a number of good practical suggestions for improving the situation.
- HedgeMage 13y agoExactly my point. I had it pretty good...way better than newbie women today have it. I'd like us to give them the advantages I had! Ironically, this means in many ways doing the opposite of what many of the people calling themselves feminists demand.
- mtrimpe 13y agoThe thing is though that she is in a very rare, privileged position. She liked her community, fit in well, felt protected and cared for, wasn't troubled by the gender ratio and all in all was just happy with her situation. For a very large amount of women that is unfortunately not the case nowadays and unfortunately her situation is not typical in the slightest and I didn't see much actionable advice to improve on that. It's also important to note that it seems the people she respected are separated from today's youth by almost two generations: I've never had a problem with old-school hackers. These guys treat me like one of them, rather than "the woman in the group", and many are old enough to remember when they worked on teams that were about one third women, and no one thought that strange. Of course, the key word here is "old" (sorry guys). Most of the programmers I like are closer to my father's age than mine. Ever since that generation the gender gap has been widening and she's now witnessing attempts to correct that and she doesn't like what she sees. She doesn't like the exclusion of her son, the message it sends to him about women in tech (and thus herself) and most of all the fact that gender has now become a 'thing.' And I can totally relate that for her it must be painful indeed and that is her voice and she totally deserves it. Where we would go wrong is if we took this as the right approach, if we started basing best practices from this or worse: if we would use it to belittle the work of everyone who is trying to improve the situation.
- gruseom 13y agoTo say that a 12-year-old farm girl was in a "privileged position" with respect to computers strikes me as absurd.
- mtrimpe 13y agoI'm not saying that she started from a privileged position, just that she had/has one now.
- pdonis 13y agonowadays Exactly: it isn't the case now, but it was the case before. Why is that? if we would use it to belittle the work of everyone who is trying to improve the situation But the whole point is that "trying to improve the situation" by making a huge fuss about "women in tech" is counterproductive; it makes the situation worse, not better. To the extent that there is a "right" approach, IMO it is to not fuss about anything except what each individual child is interested in. The moment you start thinking "I want more girls to do X" or "I think more boys should do Y", you've already gone wrong. Thinking of people as members of groups instead of unique individuals is what caused the problem in the first place; that kind of thinking is not going to fix it.
- mtrimpe 13y ago> Exactly: it isn't the case now, but it was the case before. Why is that? I don't know; but I do know it's been like that way before the recent fuss about women in tech got started. > To the extent that there is a "right" approach .. what each individual child is interested in. Practically speaking then, do you think we would improve the situation in tech if we told everyone who's organizing these events which do explicitly mention gender to stop doing so? From an idealistic perspective I'm also against women-only events and would prefer them to be perfectly inclusive. In practice that's a very hard thing to achieve though and if supplanting existing classes with predominantly boys with an explicit girls-only class helps to get some of these girls interested in tech then I'm not one to rain on their parade.
- Crake 13y ago