14 ms·
The race to keep younger and younger babies alive is fueled with ego and dollars. If you actually look at the global data on neonatal mortality [1], that doesn
by pavlov 13y ago
The race to keep younger and younger babies alive is fueled with ego and dollars.
If you actually look at the global data on neonatal mortality [1], that doesn't seem to be true.
Countries like Finland, France and Cuba perform better than the United States on this metric. These countries offer completely free healthcare to babies and pregnant mothers.
Frankly, I find your assumption borderline offensive. Maybe you should take your USD-tinted healthcare analytics glasses off for a while and contemplate the possibility that human lives are worth saving.
[1] http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.NMRT http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.DYN.NMRT
- thaumasiotes 13y agoYou can look at the data, but you can't conclude much from it; those numbers are not comparable to each other. From 2008: http://pjmedia.com/blog/the-doctor-is-in-infant-mortality-comparisons-a-statistical-miscarriage/?singlepage=true http://pjmedia.com/blog/the-doctor-is-in-infant-mortality-co... Some (OK, rather extensive) points from the link: > In the United States, all infants who show signs of life at birth (take a breath, move voluntarily, have a heartbeat) are considered alive. > In Belgium and France — in fact, in most European Union countries — any baby born before 26 weeks gestation is not considered alive and therefore does not “count” against reported infant mortality rates. The baby at issue here would have been just under 22 weeks. (France changed their standard in 2008-2009; their page defining stillbirth ( http://www.insee.fr/en/methodes/default.asp?page=definitions/enfant-sans-vie.htm http://www.insee.fr/en/methodes/default.asp?page=definitions... ) now includes a warning that French numbers cannot be compared to other European neonatal mortality numbers, so it seems safe to assume the rest of Europe has carried on as before.) > According to the way statistics are calculated in Canada, Germany, and Austria, a premature baby weighing <500g is not considered a living child. The article baby weighed well over 500g. But this is quite relevant to the question of who has better neonatal mortality. > In Switzerland and other parts of Europe, a baby born who is less than 30 centimeters long is not counted as a live birth. Therefore, unlike in the U.S., such high-risk infants cannot affect Swiss infant mortality rates. This baby's length is not reported, so this is of questionable relevance to this particular baby. But, again, it remains very relevant to the question of "do countries like Finland, France, and Cuba have better neonatal mortality than the US?" > If a child in Hong Kong or Japan is born alive but dies within the first 24 hours of birth, he or she is reported as a “miscarriage” and does not affect the country’s reported infant mortality rates. This could be a non-premature, 8-pound baby! > Efforts to salvage these tiny babies reflect this classification. Since 2000, 42 of the world’s 52 surviving babies weighing less than 400g (0.9 lbs.) were born in the United States. Still think "USD-tinted healthcare analytics" biases you against saving premature babies? Full disclosure: I'm with your parent; I consider spending so much pumping life into these very premature "babies" a self-aggrandizing waste of time, effort, and money. But your comment seems to be grotesquely misinformed.
- pavlov 13y agoThe article you quote is out of date. Many of the countries mentioned, like Germany and Austria, are self-aggrandizingly wasting time and tax money pumping life into <500g babies regardless of whether the law considers these living children or not. After all it's the doctor who makes the call, not a lawyer. You can verify this by looking at the Tiniest Babies Registry [1], which was also mentioned in the article (those 52 surviving babies -- but the toll today is already at 155). The numbers are not so skewed towards the US as they were in 2008. In recent years, about half of these tiny babies were born in Europe, Japan or South Korea. [1] http://webapps1.healthcare.uiowa.edu/tiniestbabies/ http://webapps1.healthcare.uiowa.edu/tiniestbabies/
- a3n 13y ago> contemplate the possibility that human lives are worth saving. Here fucking here. What do we want to accomplish with the most advanced civilization history has ever seen? Advertising? A flourishing human condition? Fart apps? All? None? Anarchic meritocracy? It's all on the table.
- dangrossman 13y ago"Hear hear", imploring people to listen to someone. /pedantic
- a3n 13y agoThanks. I was actually thinking about that when I wrote it, but opted for full-on indignation of the moment, rather than calm and contemplative dictionary checking.
- adwn 13y agoThis is one of the most profound and insightful comments on this page, and I wish I could upvote it more than once. Did we come all this way so that we could buy a second SUV for 25 people, or do we instead want to save a human being with a life full of potential (and spare incredible grief from at least two other persons in the process)? We should do a cost benefit analysis! [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7206436 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7206436
- judk 13y agoGoogle search [Premature]
- bigchewy 13y agosigh. >> Maybe you should take your USD-tinted healthcare analytics glasses off for a while and contemplate the possibility that human lives are worth saving. FYI - I've dedicated the last 10 years of my life to the cause of saving and improving as many lives as possible. Haven't had a paycheck for going on 4 years. Personal attacks like yours don't bother me but are frustrating because it's an example of the difficulty we face as a nation in our effort to improve our healthcare system. We all (myself included) get emotional over individual stories (e.g. Armstrong's comments over 2 lives) but have a much harder time seeing the invisible wreckage and thousands of people dying because of our distorted economic incentives.