2 ms·
One of the examiners candidly admitted that if the person identified had been someone without these characteristics, like the Maytag repairman, the laboratory m
by jessaustin 13y ago
One of the examiners candidly admitted that if the person identified had been someone without these characteristics, like the Maytag repairman, the laboratory might have revisited the identification with more skepticism and caught the error.
I know We're All Bayesian Now, but does this really seem like the way a "laboratory" ought to work? If fingerprinting really is a science, then it's a study of patterns and how they do or do not match. I'm pretty sure we have computers for that sort of task. Why isn't this totally automated by now? From the outside, the reason that springs to mind is because fingerprinting, as practiced by the FBI, is not scientific at all, and exists merely as window-dressing for the prejudice and misjudgment of agents.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe software would anyway have some threshold of confidence. I'm also not sure your assertion that being scientific makes it easy to encode in software is true (easy of course being a relative term).
- jessaustin 13y agoSkin and its details map pretty directly to the 2D Cartesian plane. (If that weren't the case, what would the concept of "fingerprint" even mean?) It is straightforward to represent values in that space in a computer, and to compare sets of such values to each other. It's true that there are affine transformations to consider, but computers are pretty good at those too (better than humans!). If there are actually any other considerations, throw some ML at them, but don't give us any "human interpretation" bullshit. In fact, Mr. Mayfield wouldn't even have suffered so if computers couldn't already do this job: it's quite unlikely that the FBI has enough staff to compare twenty-year-old military service records to Spanish bombing evidence by hand. The problem, as you nearly realized, was the threshold used in the query. There were no actual matches, yet the FBI required twenty "matches" to "investigate", so it produced twenty "matches". If the FBI had been a bit more overstaffed/bored, they would have pulled 100 "matches". It's like when we pull receivables out of the billing system to write off at the end of the fiscal year: the CFO tells us what the final number should be, and we just get the oldest accounts that sum to the proper total. You seem to have missed the point, though, which is that if fingerprinting must be done with detailed knowledge of the field agents' pet theories, that implies fingerprinting is not scientific.
- maxerickson 13y agoDeciding when your machine learning was working well enough is exactly the same thing as human interpretation bullshit.
- raverbashing 13y agoIt's not as matches/doesn't match as it looks like Taking a print is not perfect, even in perfect conditions. From a print in an object, not good at all. And a lot of people have similar prints. You can't have one print you recovered from some place and find a perfect match with 100% confidence in a database (your target may not even be on the database) Having a known identity and matching a provided sample to that DB is much better, as is having a smaller DB (for example, entering a gym) So, yes, you can have a computer finding candidates but then you can have a human to match it more carefully (that's what the Spanish did apparently)
- aestra 13y agohttp://science.howstuffworks.com/fingerprinting4.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/fingerprinting4.htm Fingerprint matching is automatically done by computers. The FBI has 1/6th of the American population in its database. Prints found in the wild aren't whole, the are usually partial prints. They ran the partials, found 20 people who it could be from that database with whatever degree of probability, probably very small. This of course was misused, but it wasn't the science was wrong so to speak rather the humans utilizing it were wrong and acting without good judgement and ethics.
- jessaustin 13y agoThe problem then is that the FBI laboratory, without consequence, utilizes the science "without good judgement [sic] and ethics." Are there any forensic laboratories in the USA that operate with good judgment and ethics?
- stefantalpalaru 13y ago> The FBI has 1/6th of the American population in its database. And all the foreign tourists who crossed its border at least once.
- robterrell 13y ago> If fingerprinting really is a science Fingerprinting isn't really a science. The law-enforcement practice pre-dates the common use of the empirical scientific method. The assertion that fingerprints are unique is unproven. http://www.michaelspecter.com/2002/05/do-fingerprints-lie/ http://www.michaelspecter.com/2002/05/do-fingerprints-lie/