3 ms·
That's just the kind of thinking that hasn't worked for anyone yet. It didn't work for Rome or anyone since. The collapse always comes when the public coffers
by protomyth 13y ago
That's just the kind of thinking that hasn't worked for anyone yet. It didn't work for Rome or anyone since. The collapse always comes when the public coffers are drained.
"if government deficit spending increases stimulate economic expansion"
Which it didn't and hasn't - the best times in our economy were when the government spent and taxed less (e.g. 1946 & 1948 fiscal changes).
"the tax funds to pay for the spending can be produced by the spending"
No, they cannot and that's just twisted logic - you cannot spend your way out of debt
- dragonwriter 13y ago> No, they cannot and that's just twisted logic - you cannot spend your way out of debt If that was true, corporate finance would be a lot different.
- protomyth 13y agoWhich company continued to spend money in excess of its revenues and took out debt to compensate then somehow without increasing revenue above spending paid off its debt?
- dragonwriter 13y agoIncreasing revenue -- and the source of that increase -- was part of what I pointed to. So your question is irrelevant.
- protomyth 13y agoAnd who pays this increased revenue, the tax payer - so your chain of comments to contradict my original point is untrue
- dragonwriter 13y ago> And who pays this increased revenue, the tax payer But not out of funds that they would have had without the expenditure. So they have literally given up nothing.
- protomyth 13y agoYou must have missed how those stimulus packages actually worked or have some view of economics that isn't a reality. Debt has an upper limit and revenue increases mean taxpayers pay it. Stimulus doesn't create any wealth and hasn't worked. There is not one concrete case of what you describe working in history.