5 ms·
That's all very well, but often people haven't thought of whatever you might tell them. By saving them from possible offence[1] you're limiting what ideas they
by onion2k 13y ago
That's all very well, but often people haven't thought of whatever you might tell them. By saving them from possible offence[1] you're limiting what ideas they have available to use. When I was running a startup I was more than happy to hear the same advice and ideas over and over again from mentors because just occasionally you got something that was new that you'd not considered before. That was far better than being saved from listening to people who might be suggesting things I'd already considered.
Advice and ideas that came from proven and experienced people were often better and more useful but only because that meant I didn't have to spend so much time researching them to see if they might work for me or figuring out the potential pitfalls - the ideas themselves were no better or worse than if they'd come from someone "unqualified".
Regarding the 'impostor syndrome' problem, that doesn't really enter into the equation if the person listening to your ideas and advice is sensible. No one just blindly goes and does what someone outside of their startup tells them to do, regardless of how much respect they might have for that individual.
[1] Anyone who gets offended by someone offering well-meaning advice is an idiot and probably wouldn't have listened even if that advice was based on a mountain of prior experience.
- reboog711 13y agoIf they ask for advice that is one thing; if it is offered "For free" it can be a huge pain. Honestly; I've founded many different businesses over the past 20 years (of varying levels of success), and I get really tired of people telling me everything I'm doing wrong. If I wanted to hear what I'm doing wrong, I'd call my parents or talk to the wife.
- Goopplesoft 13y ago> If I wanted to hear what I'm doing wrong, I'd call my parents or talk to the wife. Interesting because I think generally the experience is quite the opposite. Parents & spouses (never had one) tend to be over encouraging and much less critical. So I can see how you found that redundant since the critiquing was coming from another source in your life.
- general_failure 13y agoYou got what he is saying right? It want meant to be taken literally.
- ihaveajob 13y agoIt probably depends on the person, but in my case, my parents' work life has been so diametrically opposite to mine that this rings quite true.
- reboog711 13y agoYou have very different relationships with your parents than I have with mine, then. It took 10 years for my mom to stop asking when I was going to get a "real" job.
- kordless 13y agoThat's the basic intent behind Non-Violent Communications. Stating opinions and experience is fine, but when you start speaking for someone's (or their company's) interests, you end up crossing a line that causes the recipient to react negatively. Nobody wants to be told what they are doing is wrong. They must choose to figure it out on their own.
- reboog711 13y agoWhen running a business; "wrong" is open to interpretation. There are a million things to do and you can't do all of them so you have to balance your time with other priorities. It seems unlikely that after 10 minutes someone would understand your situation enough to be able to judge.
- polarix 13y agoEven still, phrasing the advice as a reference rather than a moral imperative can be productive. (Avoiding the word 'should', for example...)
- javery 13y agoIt's not advice at that point though - it's essentially brainstorming. I can't speak intelligently about if something is going to work for your startup or not because I have just heard about it 10 minutes ago. I can throw out random ideas and suggestions but in my experience that is much less valuable than sharing what has worked for Adzerk.
- stevesearer 13y agoThe basic idea I'm getting is that advice is meaningful and actionable when it comes from a place of domain expertise and prior experience. "You should allow people to log in using Twitter" doesn't mean as much from someone that doesn't have experience or knowledge of running a system that uses Twitter to log in. It might be a valuable idea, but it is an idea rather than advice.
- jdmichal 13y ago> That's all very well, but often people haven't thought of whatever you might tell them. I don't think the point was, "Don't tell them about things that might help them." I understood it more as, "Tell them things, but do it in reference of what worked in your experience. Then let them decide whether that might work in their experience." Before: "You should try (this thing). It's awesome for (whatever it does) because (x, y, z)." After: "At (my place), we use (this thing). It's been great for us at (whatever it does) because (x, y, z)." Basically, you're removing the implicit assumption that you know better than the person you're speaking with about what would work for their business.
- indlebe 13y ago>Basically, you're removing the implicit assumption that you know better than the person you're speaking with about what would work for their business. Bingo. I feel that that from a psychological perspective the way you word advice can dictate how well it's received. "I think you should do X", or even worse "You're doing that wrong, you should be doing X" isn't generally something that people digest hearing that well. "I've done X in that exact situation and it worked really well for me" can be much more palatable.
- notahacker 13y agoSure, a person who can discuss how, in his experience, it's been possible to get clients to pay for X by doing Y, which to some extent overlaps with your domain Z is potentially offering you much more valuable insight than someone who simply asks "have you considered doing Y?" But the usefulness of the insight you're able to provide is an essentially separate issue from coming across as a jerk who blithely insists they can fix others' business. It's possible to discuss your experiences with Y in great detail and still be that jerk (because you come across as assuming that experience must be relevant and your way of doing it was right), and conversely possible to have no experience of Y whatsoever other than reading an article on it and still be asking a very reasonable question If someone thinks you're an asshole for simply for asking whether they'd considered a Salesforce integration, they're almost certainly the asshole.