4 ms·
Automatically generated novels aren't interesting (currently) because computers are still extremely bad at common sense knowledge and natural language processin
by Houshalter 13y ago
Automatically generated novels aren't interesting (currently) because computers are still extremely bad at common sense knowledge and natural language processing (and that's not likely to change until we get at least human level AI.) However music generation is entirely possible and some attempts have been very successful so far.
Does it have intention? Is there any way to distinguish a sound file with intention from one without? Are the bits the wrong color?
- bsaul 13y ago"Is there any way to distinguish a sound file with intention from one without?" There is a way of distinguishing a musician that plays "automatically" from a musician that plays with its heart. Every musician knows that the best performance is made when he/she is sincere. Plus, you're talking about the "bits", that is the "form" but i'm talking about the content. You can have a machine spray some paint with some constrained rules on a canvas and reproduce the style of famous painters. But it will never have its own style, its own intention. No original and new message to communicate.
- Houshalter 13y agoIt's silly human bias. David Cope's program composed music which people claimed was great. As soon as they were told it was made by a computer they suddenly thought it was terrible. In a test between an actual composer and his algorithm, the audience thought the generated music was composed by a human. It's true today's algorithms might not be completely original, but then again neither are most humans. And this isn't a strict limitation, computers could learn to experiment with new patterns, or generalize further than mere imitation.
- snikolov 13y agoa program can still generate the score that a musician plays sincerely