6 ms·
> I don't think that's the general sentiment among Americans thinking of their history, especially with respect to the last quarter of the 1900s "General" impl
by dalke 13y ago
> I don't think that's the general sentiment among Americans thinking of their history, especially with respect to the last quarter of the 1900s
"General" implies majority, yes? In which case isn't your statement almost tautologically true? At least if most Americans are part of the majority?
Instead, shouldn't we ask instead how those of the historically "wrong color", "wrong gender", "wrong religion", and "wrong politics" perceive things?
Certainly in 2006, "Atheists, who account for about 3 percent of the U.S. population, offer a glaring exception to the rule of increasing social tolerance over the last 30 years" http://www1.umn.edu/news/news-releases/2006/UR_RELEASE_MIG_2816.html http://www1.umn.edu/news/news-releases/2006/UR_RELEASE_MIG_2...
As it says, there has been a trend of "increasing social tolerance" over the last part of the 20th century, but that's not the same as couldn't.
- judk 13y agoFun fact: Most people are in some minority group; there are many groups.
- shangxiao 13y agoI would even argue that all people belong to some form of minority group ;)
- dalke 13y agoFun fact: there are only four minority groups in this discussion, those being "wrong color", "wrong gender", "wrong religion", and "wrong politics". Fun fact: discrimination in the workplace is generally legal. The law lists only a few exceptions. But when someone talks about anti-discrimination policies, they mean those few exceptions and not the entire universe of all possible ways to discriminate. Fun fact: billionaires in the US are indeed a minority, but not considered a traditionally oppressed minority which, you know, is the point of this conversation. Fun fact: there's plenty of evidence to show that being female, being black, being Muslim, and being a communist in the US is more likely to have a negative effect, compared to someone male, white, Lutheran, and Democrat. Fun facts: California still has a law preventing teachers from being in the Communist party: http://www.dailybulletin.com/social-affairs/20130113/california-law-keeps-communist-party-members-from-teaching http://www.dailybulletin.com/social-affairs/20130113/califor... , and in 2001, Michael Italie was fired from Goodwill for being a member of the Socialist Worker Party. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/chatterbox/2002/07/can_your_boss_fire_you_for_your_political_beliefs.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/chatterbox/2... or http://www.themilitant.com/2001/6543/654302.html http://www.themilitant.com/2001/6543/654302.html .
- busterarm 13y ago> there's plenty of evidence to show that being female, being black, being Muslim, and being a communist in the US is more likely to have a negative effect, compared to someone male, white, Lutheran, and Democrat. I don't think my point was entirely made if you're saying this. While I wholeheartedly agree with you, the premise was that it's a whole lot better to be female/black/communist/non-Protestant in 1980 than it was to be in 1940. The point that I was making was that it was a whole lot better to be Muslim in 1980 than it is to be in 2014 and that if anything, rather than this being some period we'll reflect on sadly like Germany, we're simply returning to the mean. Tangentially, things are going to get worse for everyone disenfranchised, not just Muslims and those who look like them.
- dalke 13y ago> I don't think my point was entirely made if you're saying this. There are two parts. First was your statement > There were a brief few decades in the United States where you couldn't be born the "wrong color", born the "wrong gender" ... I agree with jwise0, that I can't think of a decade where this assertion was true. It looks like you've toned your original statement. Second, you pointed to "general sentiment" among Americans. This isn't a valid basis for making a useful inference. In a hypothetical case where 97% are in the majority and 3% are an oppressed minority, then it's entirely possible that general sentiment is that things are well, while if you ask the 3% they will tell you that things are horrible. Thus, if all "bad" groups but one - let's say "atheists" - achieve parity, then your analysis, based on "general sentiment", would conclude that things have improved. While my argument is that you have to look to the traditionally-considered "bad" groups specifically. And yes, tolerance for traditionally "bad" groups have generally improved. I pointed out research which agrees with that statement, though it does comment that atheists are now the least accepted. That 2006 paper is at https://www.soc.umn.edu/assets/pdf/atheistAsOther.pdf https://www.soc.umn.edu/assets/pdf/atheistAsOther.pdf . Quoting from it: > Atheists are at the top of the list of groups that Americans find problematic in both public and private life, and the gap between acceptance of atheists and acceptance of other racial and religious minorities is large and persistent. It is striking that the rejection of atheists is so much more common than rejection of other stigmatized groups. For example, while rejection of Muslims may have spiked in post-9/11 America, rejection of atheists was higher. The possibility of same-sex marriage has widely been seen as a threat to a biblical definition of marriage, as Massachusetts, Hawaii, and California have tested the idea, and the debate over the ordination of openly gay clergy has become a central point of controversy within many churches. In our survey, however, concerns about atheists were stronger than concerns about homosexuals. Across subgroups in our sample, negative views of atheists are strong, the differences being largely a matter of degree It does report Gallup polling data which suggests that almost 50% of the US would vote for an well-qualified atheist for President, and that percentage is the best it's ever been. But most Americans would rather have a homosexual president, and acceptance of a homosexual president or any other polled category has increased more rapidly than an atheist one.