7 ms·
What I take from this story is that the financial law is so complex and unapproachable one can not reliably navigate it without landing in jail, even being a se
by smsm42 13y ago
What I take from this story is that the financial law is so complex and unapproachable one can not reliably navigate it without landing in jail, even being a seasoned professional. The author's council could have given him "yes" answer as easily as "no" answer - many other lawyers obviously did since 200 companies got "yes" answers from their councils. And he'd never known anything was wrong. Basically, one can become a criminal not only without knowing he's doing anything wrong, but even without a theoretical way of finding it out - unless you survey all the lawyers you can find, you can not know if a yes from your lawyer would land you in jail or not, and you have no chance of understanding the law even if you spend years studying it - ultimately, the only thing that matters is the word of the enforcers on how they understand it.
It's like living in the same apartment with alcoholic gorilla prone to random outbursts of violence. One day it eats too much of fermented fruit and you're toast. And you have no way of knowing when it happens. Maybe you'll get lucky and you'll be out that day. Maybe you won't.
If I had code that is that bad and unpredictable and nobody knew if it would work or not except by seeking an opinion of a soothsayer which nobody can validate until it's too late, and it would be prone to random catastrophic failures which nobody can predict or find out why they happened, even seasoned professionals, I'd say not even refactor it. Just bury it and start from the design up again and redo the whole thing. That's pretty much the financial code we have now, as far as I can see. Good thing I have to deal just with segfaults and buffer overruns...
- ganeumann 13y agoThere's a big difference between going to your general counsel and asking "Is this legal?" and going to your accountants and saying "Find me a way to make this legal enough." I think the options-backdating was an example of the latter.
- smsm42 13y agoIn the case described in the story, I don't see any signs of the former. The CFO proposes certain practice, it is not obviously illegal (like not paying taxes or stealing office supplies from competitors at night), hundreds of companies do it, hundreds of lawyers approve it. If the CEO asks the council if it's OK and the council says yes, like hundreds others did, he goes to jail. If he's lucky and the council says no, he gets to write a book "how I almost went to jail but my super-smarts saved me". In both cases I don't see how this situation is good.
- dandelany 13y agoSorry to be a nitpick, but just FYI in the case of legal advice, it's "counsel" not "council" :)
- cperciva 13y agoTheoretically, your legal counsel might consist of a council of lawyers. ;-)
- smsm42 13y agoYou're right, I noticed it after I wrote it that I used the wrong word but was too lazy to fix it until it was too late :) Also, the "former" should be "latter" in the post. Too late to fix that too. But I think the meaning was clear anyway.
- RockyMcNuts 13y agohmmh... a manager changing the date on a contract after the fact so it generates more money for him/her is actually pretty obviously a red flag. Kudos to Ben for doing the right thing. If the government couldn't prove beyond a reasonable doubt to a jury that it was wrong, she wouldn't have gone to jail. (Not saying innocent people never go to jail, but it's not like she was an indigent defendant, she had a lot of resources and incentives to fight if it was defensible)
- x0054 13y agoThat's not true at all. This is a federal system, and she probably plead guilty because her choices probably were plead guilty and get 3 months in jail or plead innocent, go to trial, and get 20 years. The federal system is beyond fucked up, and they are making it worse every year.
- Spooky23 13y agoExactly. Someone decided that this individual needed to be made into an example and go to jail for some nominal amount of time. Period. Go to trial, and they would find some statement made in hours of interrogation that wasn't 100% accurate, and convict her of lying to a Federal officer.
- grandalf 13y agoFor an early stage startup, options value doesn't really change much month to month, since it is typically only determined at funding events. In such a scenario, the price of option grants is purely strategic. But for a publicly traded company, backdating may change the financials presented to investors unless the math is done and the changed numbers are explicitly presented.
- rayiner 13y agoThe premise that the author would've landed in jail for implementing the backdating scheme is flawed. His CFO went to jail, but because in the process of choosing favorable dates for backdating her stock options, she ended up deliberately misstating her income for certain years on her tax returns. By and large, people do not go to jail for simply picking the wrong plausible interpretation of tax or accounting law. There's even a Supreme Court case about this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheek_v._United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheek_v._United_States ("The Court held that an actual good-faith belief that one is not violating the tax law, based on a misunderstanding caused by the complexity of the tax law, negates willfulness, even if that belief is irrational or unreasonable.") With something like backdating, you're essentially going around saying that something happened on one date (the options grant), when it actually happened on some other date. While that may be kosher for the purposes of accounting, and PWC or E&Y will happily sign off on that, it doesn't mean that those assertions are thus okay in any other context. And that's not a subtle legal gotcha, it should be plainly obvious.
- smsm42 13y agoI'm not sure why it matters that much which day options were granted on that it is worth putting people in jail for. The company has right to compensate their workers any way they like. Including giving options for free or for any price they see fit, and doing that any day at any time. Of course, our tax code being as weird and byzantine as it is, that may mean that some ways of giving options may end up in people paying less tax than other ways, and thus we have even more complex and byzantine system of laws that prevent people from taking advantage of it. But I see it as a deficiency of the tax code, which allows you to pay different depending on the various tricks and loopholes. Now, the part where backdating is hidden from the people who have to have control over the matters - like shareholders - is another matter. That is violation of trust, embezzling and fraud. But I see no sign of it in the story we were told - I see no sign that the dating that was proposed were to be hidden from workers or shareholders.
- rayiner 13y agoThe articled linked in HN leaves out the actual basis of the indictment: http://www.justice.gov/usao/can/news/2010/2010_09_16_abrams.guiltyplea.press.pdf http://www.justice.gov/usao/can/news/2010/2010_09_16_abrams.... ("In April 2002, her joint federal tax return for the tax year 2001 was filed with a Form W-2 that included a 2001 taxable income that was calculated in part on a number of her Mercury stock options being exercised on April 4, 2001. When her joint 2001 tax return was filed in April 2002, she knew that on April 4, 2001, she had not yet told Mercury what options she was exercising. She also knew that on April 4, 2001, there had not yet been a written action by the Mercury Board of Directors that formally approved the executive loan to pay for the options. Abrams was aware that Mercury’s Stock Option Plan required notice of exercise and payment before a stock option could be considered exercised. She also knew that on April 4, 2001, her stock option exercises had not met those requirements. By failing to meet the requirements of the Plan, Abrams endeavored to claim an exercise date on which the company’s stock price was lower than on later dates. This caused her to file a tax return and amended tax return that understated her wages and caused the IRS to assess an incorrect amount of tax for 2001, thereby obtaining a tax benefit for which she was not entitled.") Basically, she said on her tax return that she had exercised her options on April 4, 2001, when not only had she not done that, but she hadn't yet met the requirements for being able to exercise her options at that time. This is not being burned by some esoteric rule where she checked Box A when she should've checked Box B. She filed a tax return that said something happened on a certain date that not only didn't happen on that date, but couldn't happen on that date. That's why Horowitz's premise is false. He wouldn't have gone to jail for implementing the same backdating scheme. Tons of companies did it, very few went to jail, and those who did went to jail because they let the backdating fiction cause them to either lie on their tax returns or commit affirmative fraud on investors. Also: to make a more general point--companies are entitled to compensate executives in whatever manner the shareholders will tolerate, but public companies aren't entitled to be deceptive about it. That was the problem with backdating: while the process itself was legal from an accounting standpoint, the fact that it was built on a fiction made it easy to cross the line into outright deception. The wikipedia article actually has a great sentence that captures the whole situation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Options_backdating http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Options_backdating ("To be legal, backdating must be clearly communicated to the company shareholders, properly reflected in earnings, and properly reflected in tax calculations.")
- Daniel_Newby 13y ago> What I take from this story is that the financial law is so complex and unapproachable one can not reliably navigate it without landing in jail, even being a seasoned professional. Because this story was written by a liar and/or idiot. Option accounting law is simple and clear. Market value – exercise price = loss taken by shareholders. This goes in the quarterly report so the shareholders know how much they spent on employee compensation. The financial planner "Michelle" was trying to simply not report the cost, to fraudently make the numbers look better. This is one of the oldest frauds in the book. Frankly I am amazed she did not get multiple life sentences for her crimes. The story author falsely tried to make it look like some sort of terrifying subtlety, an accounting landmine that nearly blew off his leg. It is not. Every responsible accountant would start shitting kittens if confronted with this fraud in their company. Edit: From other comments, the story was not even about the actual crimes. So the author is not an idiot, but manufacturing a scare story Daily Mail style.
- Mtinie 13y agoStrangely, at the time that this all occurred, there was a glut of feral kittens wandering around Mountain View. I always wondered where they had come from, but now I've got a good explanation!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jessedhillon 13y agoOh, woe be the accountants! It's difficult to take this opinion seriously when the comment author is so unread about the law that they don't know the difference between "council" and "counsel"! It's a very strong opinion which is devoid of any learning or context whatsoever -- has the author never heard of Arthur Andersen?
- mattdeboard 13y agoDid you really just write 40ish words belittling someone's opinion because they picked the wrong homophone?
- jessedhillon 13y agoI concluded that someone who can't distinguish counsel and council has probably not read a lot about legal issues, and probably has an uninformed opinion on them. So it's probably not meaningful when they decide that government and law enforcement are like an angry, unpredictable gorilla. What would you conclude?
- smsm42 13y agoI can distinguish them - I just noticed I used the wrong one when I already submitted and was too lazy to fix it as I assumed everyone intelligent would deduce what I meant. I type fast and sometimes make typos and sometimes use wrong words if they sound alike because my fingers run ahead of my brain. Usually I catch it before submitting, sometimes I do not. This was the time where I didn't. If it prevents you from understanding the text - well, I'm sorry, I guess I can't get everyone. Some would just zero in on typos and ignore the message. Protip: I probably also used a bunch of articles wrong (my native language has none) and maybe some other grammar errors crept in too. It's OK for you to dismiss everything I wrote as nonsense.
- jessedhillon 13y agoA typo is an error which results from the fact that you are typing. Consistently using the word council in place of counsel -- not even once getting it right, suggests to me that you have not even read enough about legal issues that you have seen the word in print. I understand that it can be difficult to parse the phrase "the council considered the counsel of the counselors before counseling the councilors" -- yes they are homophones in some dialects of English. In this case, coupled with your exceptionally unsophisticated understanding of the law, and not even a passing familiarity with the issue at hand, I'm more inclined to believe that you didn't actually know the difference until it was pointed out to you. I mean, you said in your comment that it doesn't seem "obviously illegal" to lie about the date when an option was granted. I don't think you even understand what options backdating is, or what was happening in the accounting world at that time. You just seem like a guy who wants to complain that government is arbitrary. Your only evidence for this is that a reasonable CFO would have looked at other CFOs and copied their behavior, therefore nobody could possibly be held responsible.
- morganw 13y ago> financial law is so complex and unapproachable one can not reliably navigate it without landing in jail, even being a seasoned professional. The CFO of the little company I worked for in the mid&late 90's said her colleagues were calling FAS 123 (draft in 1993, revised in 2004) stock option accounting guidelines from FASB the "aircraft carrier" document because of its size. The PDF http://www.fasb.org/pdf/fas123.pdf http://www.fasb.org/pdf/fas123.pdf is only a little over 100 pages, but it's some dense dense stuff and I'd guess 10x that length has been written in interpretations.
- Negitivefrags 13y agoIt's like living in the same apartment with alcoholic gorilla prone to random outbursts of violence. One day it eats too much of fermented fruit and you're toast. And you have no way of knowing when it happens. Maybe you'll get lucky and you'll be out that day. Maybe you won't. That's pretty much it. I remember not feeling any sympathy for my friends who ran in to tax problems. It's easy to assume that this stuff is well understood and it must be their fault for failing to do it properly. What I found out later is that even if you make every effort to pay your tax correctly, you will still get screwed eventually. Provisional tax law, for example, requires literally knowing the future to avoid penalties. I'm in New Zealand and I thought it was complex here. Then I encountered the US tax system. Holy crap! Even hiring expensive US accountants our company still managed to get a 20k fine out of nowhere for reasons I don't understand. Supposedly this is being appealed and our accountant assures us that we will get the fine rescinded, but there you go.
- Shinkei 13y agoAs a funny example, I read the 1040 instructions each year and some interesting points are included regarding "claiming kidnapped children" and "whale captains deducting specific expenses." If they are devoting time to these sections in the general instructions, then it's gotten out of hand.
- jeffdavis 13y ago"And he'd never known anything was wrong." A change in the benefits to employees that doesn't result in a corresponding adjustment to the books raises a red flag to me, and I'm not an expert at all. The author was probably giving too much benefit of the doubt to his former CFO. She was probably being a bit lazy and probably tried to be a bit too clever. I'm not saying the cleverness was greed; it may be as simple as wanting to feel like she could really contribute something to the company beyond what an ordinary CFO could do. But accountants are supposed to be above that. Accounting regulations are there to protect investors from a million kinds of cleverness that have proved disastrous over the past few thousand years. My only complaint is that the government itself is not held to the same standard of accounting.
- gaius 13y agoThis exactly what financial law is for. So anyone can be busted at any time. It is working as designed - but designed by whom for whom's benefit, you might ask.