3 ms·
I'm really surprised (though maybe I shouldn't be) at the number of people here who are conflating "learning to code in an hour" with "learning how to teach pro
by moron4hire 13y ago
I'm really surprised (though maybe I shouldn't be) at the number of people here who are conflating "learning to code in an hour" with "learning how to teach programming in an hour".
If your skill as a programmer were dependent on the skill of your teacher as a programmer, then we wouldn't be anywhere. If your skill in anything were dependent on how good your teachers were at the skill itself, rather than at the skill of teaching, then we would really be a lost society.
I don't think I had a single teacher in high school or a professor in college that was a better programmer than me, and half of my professors probably couldn't code beyond the old linked list example they were putting up on the projector every semester. They didn't teach me how to program. They taught me how to reason about software.
But that isn't the point. As far as I'm concerned, the act of programming is unteachable. The physical act of typing characters in a text editor, running tests on it, and changing some characters with new characters, is all you can teach, but the mental leaps of figuring out which are the right characters and tests and changes for the failing tests takes a lifetime of experience and practice.
But that doesn't mean there isn't a role that a teacher can play to instruct students during that personal experience. Otherwise, what is the point of art teachers? It's the same thing, you can't really teach someone to make good art. You can teach them the mechanics of holding a brush and putting paint on a canvas, or taking photos, or writing. I've seen dozens of kids spend small fortunes on art educations at Ivy League schools and they still aren't artists. Because you can't teach them how to make something have meaning.
And I knew dozens of kids in my own computer science program who spent the equivalent of a luxury car on a software development education and they still aren't software developers. Few of us stayed in the field, post-graduation, and fewer still are any good at it.
The only problem I can foresee with the "Learn To Code" movement is not "not everyone can learn to code." It's that, having the ability to write text in a text editor and run a compiler against it, is going to give everyone opinions on what software development should be, but they will have no experience, no knowledge of what distinguishes software development from programming. I can see it reinforcing the asshole manager view "it's just pushing buttons on a keyboard, what is so hard?" Because "pushing buttons on a keyboard" is all they are going to teach.
It would be as if we replaced our art classes with paint-by-number sessions.
But, on the other hand, we do force people through art museums and art appreciation classes and they don't seem to try to tell artists what creating art should be. Or, at least, not more often than busy-bodies in general try to tell everyone what to do.
If we could only get rid of the busy-bodies.