2 ms·
There's a bit of a stereotype about labview that it is graphically beautiful but its not visual programming because it inevitably results in more typing of text
by VLM 13y ago
There's a bit of a stereotype about labview that it is graphically beautiful but its not visual programming because it inevitably results in more typing of text than anything else, otherwise you get a bowl of spaghetti. With textual languages you can interpret it to figure it out, perhaps a billion times slower than the computer, but exactly the same. Visual is a little harder to figure out.
Or in summary I've seen large complicated Labview that's totally write once read never.
You might be interested in screenshots from GNURadio. Same effect. Spaghetti bowl of a schematic where a plain text version would be a lot clearer. Google for a simple WBFM radio with squelch and AFC aka your $5 walkman broadcast radio, and you get something that looks like its launching the space shuttle.
- Jtsummers 13y agoI never personally used LabView (well, maybe in a Physics 101 lab in college, but that was a while back). The people using it in the offices I've worked in have generally been electrical engineers, perhaps the schematic view meshes better with their mental model of computation. It seemed to work well on most of the projects. EDIT: I should add, when I did look at the LabView stuffs, it seemed to make sense to me (as a reader), but I'm not sure how easy or difficult it would have been for me to jump into and start working on after someone else has constructed a lot of parts.
- analog31 13y agoI suspect that of equal importance to the schematic view, for electrical engineers, is the dataflow programming model. Another dataflow based programming tool, albeit non Turing complete, is Excel.
- collyw 13y agoI have thought of excel as the closest real thing we have to visual programming. Its a shame that it seems to be based on a "grid" rather than a better data structure. I guess that is why it makes sense to most non programers though.
- DougMerritt 13y agoExcel is not dataflow based and it is not non-Turing complete; you're thinking of something else altogether. To guide intuition without making things tediously formal, most things that can go into an infinite loop are Turing equivalent.