4 ms·
I was looking for the same WHO statistics you refer to while you were writing your reply. I see we both found the same landing page, but you are referring to fi
by tokenadult 17y ago
I was looking for the same WHO statistics you refer to while you were writing your reply. I see we both found the same landing page, but you are referring to figures that thus far neither of us can find on a specific webpage giving figures for the United States. Where did you get them?
Using some of the keywords you kindly provided, I Google and see lower mortality figures for the United States, by more than an order of magnitude, I think. It also appears that most cases of malnourishment in the United States are secondary to disease states. Remembering that my dad was paralyzed and unable to swallow for the last six years of his life (he was fed by a gastric tube, with the help of a relative) brings to mind examples of people who could starve to death in the United States, although they wouldn't be able-bodied people who were not eating because they can't afford to get a meal.
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/mor_oth_nut_def-mortality-other-nutritional-deficiencies http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/mor_oth_nut_def-mortality-...
(The numbers I am finding on the above site, which claims to be based on WHO statistics, don't back up the numbers in your reply, which evokes my curiosity about how we can a primary source for the official figures.)
http://www.answers.com/topic/protein-energy-malnutrition-3 http://www.answers.com/topic/protein-energy-malnutrition-3
http://www.worldmapper.org/display_extra.php?selected=411 http://www.worldmapper.org/display_extra.php?selected=411
http://books.google.com/books?id=L5fGm_7ThKEC&pg=PA496&lpg=PA496&dq=kwashiorkor+incidence+United+States&source=bl&ots=3Pl9fA5NbE&sig=4_qbVjRwzE8yjbs-C7xAL2TEh0k&hl=en&ei=R4dnSsnNGY-Etgfr-KWyAg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4 http://books.google.com/books?id=L5fGm_7ThKEC&pg=PA496&#...
Let's keep following up on this. I'll ignore your invidious personal criticism [smile] in the interest of getting the facts on the issue. What magnitude of problem are we talking about in the United States by the standard WHO definitions, which I accept as an authoritative count of deaths by malnutrition in each country? How many of the United States deaths are secondary to neglectful caregivers of minors (a problem I acknowledged in my first reply) and how many are secondary to adult medical complications (an issue we both forgot in previous replies)? How do the United States figures compare to specific countries elsewhere in the world?
It sure ought to be possible to get the WHO figures directly from the Web, but I'm still searching. The keywords in your reply were helpful for finding other sources.
- kragen 17y agohttp://www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/bodgbddeathdalyestimates.xls http://www.who.int/healthinfo/statistics/bodgbddeathdalyesti... is the spreadsheet I got the numbers from; I downloaded it years ago, which is why I didn't know where it was linked from. Unfortunately it doesn't cite sources. It's linked from http://www.who.int/research/en/ http://www.who.int/research/en/ as "Causes of death [xls 3.03Mb]". The NationMaster number is 0.056 per 100 000 population per year. I don't see how to square that with the 50× higher numbers from the WHO spreadsheet. Thanks for the reminder of adult medical complications. The US figures seem to be in the normal range for OECD countries, although maybe toward the high end, and they are much lower than the worst countries (typically those in the middle of a war). http://www.worldmapper.org/extraindex/death_notes.html#table2 http://www.worldmapper.org/extraindex/death_notes.html#table... (from your third link) matches the stats from the WHO spreadsheet (at least for Mali and Angola, to all three decimal places).
- tokenadult 17y agoThanks. I learned something about finding WHO statistics with your help. I think the conclusion here is that people in the United States who die of severe malnourishment do so mostly because they have diseases that impair their eating (something I didn't consider at all in my first reply). So I learned something else today. In the overall context of this thread, I am not particularly worried that the economic crisis we are now in is going to push my family, or even much poorer families, into starvation. People will still buy and sell and trade and (in North America) mostly eat very adequately.
- kragen 17y agoOn the other hand, it's still totally implausible that the answer to "Has anyone in the United States, and I mean anyone, actually died of a cause attributable to undernutrition caused by anything other than mental illness in the lifetime of anyone posting here?" is "No," even if you modify the question to exclude not only starvation due to insanity, but also starvation due to the powerlessness of children and starvation that's secondary to some other illness. The odds ratios would have to be hundreds of thousands to one.