3 ms·
Your interpretation of the article is not supported by the body. If the CBO believed in the effect you postulate, they would not predict fewer jobs (more precis
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Your interpretation of the article is not supported by the body. If the CBO believed in the effect you postulate, they would not predict fewer jobs (more precisely, reduced effort equivalent to fewer jobs).
According to the body, hours worked and full time employment will drop. This is a straightforward supply shock, along the same lines as the oil shortage of the 70's (assuming of course you believe in reducing the entire economy to 2 graphs, as the Keynesians often do).
Also, increasing wages in a recession is a big no-no if you believe in Keynesian economics. Assuming this effect is not taken into account by the CBO's headline number, it means there will be further job losses.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> If the CBO believed in the effect you postulate, they would not predict fewer jobs. They're predicting a smaller labor force (non-institutionalized population of working age working or actively seeking work) resulting from the reduced health insecurity from the ACA, not fewer jobs. [1] To see where that fits into the unemployment picture, understand that the unemployment rate is (1 - (Filled Jobs / Labor Force)). > Also, increasing wages in a recession is a big no-no if you believe in Keynesian economics We're not in a recession. We're in an expansion in which both wages and employment rates have recovered slower than normal -- which was also true in the last expansion between the 2001 recession and the Great Recession -- which is why it feels like we've been in a 13 year recession to many people who aren't major capitalists, though there have only been 26 months of official recession in that period. [1] The ACA effect is described on p. 14 of the report [2], which is linked from the NYTimes article, in the section under the heading "Labor Force Participation" (heading on p. 13). [2] https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/45011-LaborMarketReview.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments...
- CWuestefeld 13y agoI think you're missing the point about changes to the labor market. The unemployment rate you cite is correct, but it's just as you said - a rate, not an absolute total. What the report states is that the total number of jobs will decrease. Together with the fact that we know that hours per job is not going to increase (and may actually be decreasing, thanks to other PPACA regulations), simple algebra tells us that there will be fewer hours worked overall. Barring an external development that causes productivity per hour to increase, we can expect lower total production. Bottom line, then, is lower GDP as a result of this. That is the opposite of a good thing for the economy.
- rtpg 13y agoconsidering that one of the measures of production (and GDP) is salaries, your argument is a bit iffy (salaries could rise proportionately due to the labor shortage, thus increasing GDP anyways, but that goes to show the uselessness of GDP in measuring "real" production). One argument for better healthcare is people end up less sick. These guys(http://www.forbes.com/sites/brucejapsen/2012/09/12/u-s-workforce-illness-costs-576b-annually-from-sick-days-to-workers-compensation/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/brucejapsen/2012/09/12/u-s-workf...) seem to think that productivity decreases in the US account for almost 10% of spending on salaries and whatnot. There are 120 million or so people in the workforce, so 2 million jobs is something like 1%. So if we make people "10%" more health , it would end up with us saving the same 1% (thus on the long-term allowing more investment later). We could get people to do the same amount of work for less, thus we are more productive. I do not vouch for the validity of the numbers, just for the idea behind it (healthier people means more productive people).
- hga 13y ago"One argument for better healthcare is people end up less sick." Indeed. Unfortunately, it is entirely unproven that Obamacare, which focuses on health insurance, is going to result in better health care. For reasons we can go into if you want, Obamacare compliant polices tend to have extremely narrow networks of doctors and hospitals. E.g. look at all the fuss the Seattle Children's Hospital is raising, and there's a lot of individual cases where people are losing their doctors who've been treating their conditions for a long time, this is just the latest report to pop up: http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-obamacare-patients-20140205,0,5417742.story#axzz2sPjqUBV0 http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-obamacare-patients-201... There's a reason Reagan got a lot of mileage with his joke "The nine most terrifying words in the English language are 'I'm from the government, and I'm here to help.'"
- CWuestefeld 13y agoObamacare compliant polices tend to have extremely narrow networks of doctors and hospitals This is a good point. The narrower networks can, I think, be expected to result in more time off work. I'll have to drive a farther distance to see my doctor, or I'll have to settle for an appointment in the middle of the day. Either way, it's a hit to my time that wouldn't exist under "traditional" schemes. it is entirely unproven that Obamacare, which focuses on health insurance, is going to result in better health care. So the fact that you're insured doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to get better faster. The doctor can't do anything for you if you've got a cold or the flu; you've just got to ride it out. I suspect that it's cases like this that make up the lion's share of health-related lost productivity. And even when healthcare can have an impact on your health, I don't believe that the positive effects on worker productivity could be that great. Most employers already provide healthcare insurance, so there's no improvement to the situation there. The only positive effect will be toward those who are already employed but without health insurance, which is a minority.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThey're predicting a smaller labor force (non-institutionalized population of working age working or actively seeking work) resulting from the reduced health insecurity from the ACA, not fewer jobs. According to the CBO, the difference between actual and potential GDP will decline to 0.5% by 2017. At that point (and possibly before) a reduced labor force is reduced jobs and (more importantly) reduced production. It could result in reduced jobs/production even before that if workers who choose to reduce output are not interchangeable with unemployed [1] workers willing to take those jobs at the same wage. We're not in a recession. We're in an expansion in which both wages and employment rates have recovered slower than normal Either we need fiscal/monetary stimulus or not. If we need stimulus, increasing wages is a bad idea according to all mainstream economic theories (Keynesian, Monetarist, Structuralist). Which is it? Here is the report, btw: https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments/45011-LaborMarketReview.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/attachments... [1] Including discouraged, at least if employers can find the discouraged workers.
- dragonwriter 13y agoAs we are in an expansion, we don't really need stimulus, we need retraction of the policy changes of the last 35, and particularly the last 15, years that redirected more of the gains from private sector expansion to the capital and the very upper end of non-capital income earners, at the expense of everyone else; stimulus in these conditions doesn't really address the fundamental problem. At best, it provides a short-term backstop against the fundamental weakness of a poorly-distributed expansion crashing back into recession, but even that is hampered by the same distributional problems when using traditional monetary and fiscal stimulus levers. Sure, from the POV of much of the workforce the economic. car isn't going anywhere, but stimulus is like trying to give it a jump start when the engine is runnin but the transmission is in neutral.