3 ms·
While an interesting idea, I have the same objection to that idea that I have to the idea that life in general is abundant today, which is that we should see th
by jerf 13y ago
While an interesting idea, I have the same objection to that idea that I have to the idea that life in general is abundant today, which is that we should see the evidence of it. Any truly long-lived society is going to have to engage in some cosmological engineering to survive, and we don't see it.
Furthermore, while any given species might not have survived from so long ago, life itself should never have died out, if intelligent life was common and abundant. The challenges of surviving that era are such that even we can plausibly imagine being able to meet the challenges in a century, or less if we were concentrating.
It's a poetic idea, but the universe does not look like one in which we are some last dying ember living in the carcass of past giants; it looks like one in which there's little-to-no intelligent life in our past light cone.
- andreftavares 13y agoIf you consider the "infinite" of space and, especially, time, I believe that the probability of the existence of (at least) one "inteligent" species capable of reaching any given place of the universe is 100%. The question of why they don't contact us is simple: Prime Directive (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Directive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prime_Directive) Disclaimer: I'm not a particular fan of Star Trek and bumped into this interesting principle, which I believe makes perfect sense.
- NathanKP 13y agoThe Prime Directive only works if you assume that these hypothetical species are much more altruistic than we ourselves are. I find it highly unrealistic that any species, however highly evolved, would be 100% altruistic, with no rebels/thieves/slavers/prospectors that would desire to interfere with or destroy us humans. And that's not to mention that realistically it would be almost impossible for a civilization to completely hide its presence. For example as humans our radio footprint from TV and radio and satellite broadcasts is spreading out of our solar system. That's going to keep on traveling and I don't see any way that we'd be able to just "erase" that so that no one else would notice it.
- jerf 13y agoTime is not infinite, and our past light cone is not infinite. It grows as less than the cube of the space we can observe (the universe is very not universally distributed), while the independent probabilities of whatever is required for life multiply exponentially. The idea that the odds of life are 100% is just a naive "Big Numbers" fallacy. The Prime Directive was created to preserve the desired structure of drama on a TV show. It is ludicrous from any other perspective.