8 ms·
Things I learned by pretending to be blind for a week (2013)
- jblok 13y agoIt's interesting that Facebook and Amazon have a terrible experience for blind users, considering their wealth of resources. I imagine it is common knowledge among blind users to expect the mobile site to perform better, if the desktop site is sucky.
- ljf 13y agoAll the more amazing since accessibility is supposedly one of the things that Amazon does well: https://plus.google.com/app/basic/stream/z12ld3fwhlnexv5b004cjv0oapmuflzrezc0k https://plus.google.com/app/basic/stream/z12ld3fwhlnexv5b004...
- jareds 13y agoI have no issue using the main amazon site with Jaws as a screen reader. I'm sure part of that is that I've been using Jaws for close to 20 years but it doesn't appear this guy used navigation by headers which makes amazon quite usable.
- digitalengineer 13y agoWould it be possible to build 'An app for that?' (E.g. Blind people). Browser sites and stuff through the app.
- icebraining 13y agoThat's what screen readers do; a popular one is JAWS: http://www.freedomscientific.com/products/fs/jaws-product-page.asp http://www.freedomscientific.com/products/fs/jaws-product-pa...
- huskyr 13y agoVery interesting article. I would love a followup about actual things you can do as a developer to make life easier for users with screen readers.
- NAFV_P 13y agoThe article mentioned "w3m", never come across it before, although I do have "lynx" and "elinks". Really impressive.
- kroger 13y agow3m was (is?) the most popular way read html pages in emacs http://emacs-w3m.namazu.org http://emacs-w3m.namazu.org
- yaddayadda 13y agoFirst, I applaud David Ball for doing this and sharing his results! Second, one of the first web application projects that I was a part of I was assigned as the "accessibility expert". At some point during that project I was told that the reason it is termed "accessibility" is because it makes the resource (e.g., website, print page, whatever the resource) more accessible for everyone, not just for people with physical limitations. The development version of that application lived on an unmanaged, but live server for more than a decade before it disappeared; up until its disappearance the application was still functioning, and could even be used on a mobile phone. Most of the recommendations I made, all those years ago, went uncontested by my teammates, but every now and then I had to fight for some aspect and I would make the "accessibility benefits everyone" speech. The last teammember to visit our application before it disappeared admitted that it wouldn't have been able to run on the latest technology if I hadn't been so adamant about accessibility all those years ago.
- ewiethoff 13y agoThank you. I would love an article about accessibility for people who must use voice commands or those who cannot use a pointing device. Dragon is fine with spoken keyboard commands, but much of the JavaScript out there borks site navigation by keyboard and control of normal browser functionality by keyboard.
- RodrigoGil 13y agoLike the article. It reminds me the book from Saramago that inspired the movie: Blindness (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0861689/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0861689/). But it's important to note that it's completely different the case where a born blind person and a person that becomes blind. So it might be useful to speak with a born blind person and how they manage these web browsing tasks.
- kendalk 13y agoI dated a woman who was born blind. She could listen to JAWS speak text faster than I can read. If you really want to know how your website "looks" to a blind person, ask one. Every state has an association for the blind. I am sure they would be happy to arrange a time to sit down with you. Expect some honest feedback.
- jpswade 13y agoThe most useful information I found on accessibility was this video, which really showed me how the blind use the web: "Victor Tsaran: An Introduction to Screen Readers"[1]. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izrC4R7SsH4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=izrC4R7SsH4
- octo_t 13y agoThis reminds me of this wired article[1] when Steve Jobs died, whilst not directly related to blindness - it is touched upon - in my experience few firms have gotten it as right on accessibility as Apple, and definitely nowhere close several years ago, I haven't checked much in the last few years on android. The top comment on Jobs personally intervening when a bluetooth stack had a bug in an iMac is pretty touching too. [1] - http://www.wired.com/business/2011/10/steve-jobs-disability/ http://www.wired.com/business/2011/10/steve-jobs-disability/
- jareds 13y agoFrom my experience android accessibility is about where iOS was in iOS 3.1. Usable but iOS is better.
- PhantomGremlin 13y agoWARNING: strong opinions, e.g. flames, follow. Don't bother reading if you're easily offended. At the rate we're going, most websites will never be easily navigated by blind people. How do I know? Easy ... My eyesight isn't as great as it was when I was younger. So I like to set my "Minimum font size" in Firefox to 18 pt. (Yes I know they're not technically considered "points" any more). That single simple change fucks up a lot of the web! Just that, nothing more. And it's something that any web designer could trivially test for. And yet they don't bother! Why? Probably because they're mostly self-centered 20-something hipster douchebags, who can't even imagine there's someone with worse eyesight than they have. Or maybe their sense of "aesthetics" trumps any consideration of "accessibility". In other words: "Fuck off if you're too old to comfortably read 10 pt type. We don't need your kind on our website". Worse, there are a few sites, such as Bloomberg, that somehow manage to trick Firefox into not rendering their fonts at a minimum 18 pt, but instead render substantially smaller. That's right, some hipster web designer at Bloomberg went out of his way to make sure the text displayed is small. He's probably quite proud of this. Firefox does works OK on 99% of the web in terms of font size. Unfortunately, stuff breaks in other ways. E.g. when a large minimum font is selected, text often simply disappears off to the right of a page. So then a search box is just not displayed at all, because it's off to the right of the page. Or text just disappears off the bottom of a block. Probably something to do with fixed widths, I don't know I'm not an HTML guy. Chrome apparently has a large contingent of hipster douchebags working on it. Apparently the concept of "18 pt" is too technical for their genius IQ brains. So they just have simpler font size selections such as Small, Medium, and Large. Unfortunately not granular enough when compared to Safari or Firefox. And Chrome is also far worse than Firefox in displaying pages in tiny type, even when Font size is set to Large. Still, lots of sites do it right. E.g. Hacker News is no problem. A very simple layout and very readable. (Now if they would only fix that expired link problem). I repeat, I'm bitching about something that is trivial, a mere inconvenience, compared to what the blind encounter. And yet I run into many web sites and browsers that can't even get that little bit right. So what hope is there for the blind? No nope, none at all!
- jareds 13y agoAs a totally blind developer I have to disagree. Maybe it's a bit easier for me since I don't need to worry about font sizes but I'd say 95% or more of the web is accessible if you are good with screen reading software.
- dmlorenzetti 13y agoPDF files have similar issues. Acrobat can attempt to read them out loud, but unless the PDF author adds extensive annotations, Acrobat has no idea about the "structure" of the document. For example, headers are just more text. Tables and figures that "float" to the top of a page, or in any other way interrupt the text, get read in the visual, not the logical, order. Images get "read" as a stream of binary data. Equations get mangled horribly. Etc. etc.
- mjmahone17 13y agoIs the .tex file typically easier to read/understand? Or is there a way to compile .tex into something that's easy to read and understand?
- dmlorenzetti 13y agoLaTeX, much like HTML, allows you to use either stylistic markup ("put this bit in a bigger font") or semantic markup ("mark this bit as a headline"). The PdfLaTeX typesetting engine can embed some semantic information into the PDF. However, it doesn't do everything. For example, I believe it does not handle the issue with "floats" that I mentioned [1]. I don't know whether there are TeX-aware tools for "reading" a LaTeX input file out loud (which is what I think you're asking about). But if there was such a tool, it might well be easier to understand, than listening to a dumb reading of the resulting typeset PDF. It is possible to go into an existing PDF file and mark up a lot of these things, specifically in order to help the reader along. The webmaster where I work often has to mark up PDF files (usually generated from MS Word documents, rather than from LaTeX). I've never done it, though, so I don't know what's involved. My impression is that it's pretty painful. [1] To make the issue with floats more explicit. You can tell LaTeX to add a figure, and to "float" it to the top of a page. The typesetting engine will do so. However, suppose the resulting PDF file ends page 4 with "The figure clearly shows..." and then starts page 5 with the figure, followed by "... two trends in the data." Then when the document gets read out loud, the reader will say "The figure clearly shows", then it will go into a spastic literal reading of the figure's contents, then it will finish up with "two trends in the data."
- bramd 13y agoInteresting that some commenters here seem to have an attitude of "let's build an app for the blind", "there is no hope for the blind" etc. I'm born blind and build software and do some accessibility consulting for a living. Fortunately we've reached times where the blind community can build software themselves. An excellent example is NVDA[0], an open source screenreader for the Windows platform, mainly build by two blind guys. With Firefox, I think it is the best combination for browsing the web these days, even outperforming commercial screenreaders. Oh, and if you want to know why semantics are important, grab a screenreader and read a HN discussion. The lack of nested lists and/or headings to indicate the relationship between comments makes it just a stream of comments without any structure. If proper semantics was being used, I could for example skip an entire subtree of the discussion if the starting comment didn't interest me. [0]: http://www.nvaccess.org/ http://www.nvaccess.org/
- tekacs 13y ago> I'm born blind and build software and do some accessibility consulting for a living. I have little to add here beyond the fact that this is one of the coolest comments I've seen in a long time. :) Whilst I've long known theoretically about the use of screenreaders and such technology, I've never had the chance to see someone using it in action. It's good to see that it works and is at least somewhat practical.
- ghostfacedbat 13y agoFor a good 30 seconds I thought that the author had linked to a blank page, and that it was very elegant epitome of the experience of being blink (the article initially took unusually long to load on my phone).
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoAn aside but: "I once realised when watching a DVD on my Playstation 3 that you can set the speed to 1.5x. Which means you can finish watching a 2 hour movie in only 1hour 30 mins and still understand what’s going on. “That gives me 30 minutes of life back!” I said excitedly." Or you can read the Wikipedia summary in 90 seconds and get 1 hour 58.5 minutes back but that's not really the point. How about just don't watch the movie? There's no obligation to watch any of them and there are so many that there's always going to be something you miss however much you try and cram in. Watching a movie is something which is meant to be a pleasure, or thought provoking, or profound or any number of things which are going to be largely lost at high speed. At that point you're just reducing it to consumption so you've seen it and maybe it's just me but what's the point of that?
- nitrogen 13y agoSome shows are just paced too slowly, but still provide entertainment or enlightenment. Who are you to care whether a viewer watches such a show at 1.5x speed?
- ryanpetrich 13y agoFor my tastes, most television can be watched comfortably at 1.5× and anything with a "laugh track" can be watched at 1.75× without losing meaning.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoIt's a comment on behavior I've noticed in myself. A pile of DVDs became something I had to get through, ditto books, games or albums. Talking to others I found it wasn't just me - that somehow the important thing had been completing things and enjoying them had become almost secondary. Recently I found myself listening to a podcast at 1.5x speed regularly and after a while it occurred to me that it was because I was resenting the time it was taking up and that the problem wasn't really that it was taking too long, it was that I wasn't really enjoying it but was listening out of obligation (it had popped up in the unplayed list, it must be played!). At that point I said a silent sorry to Mark and Simon and unsubscribed. I've similarly quit watching a bunch of TV shows and I'm far happier abandoning books or games part way through. Seeing someone talking about watching a movie at 1.5x speed made me think of that - consumption over enjoyment. Yes there are movies and shows that can be watched that fast and still enjoyed but given the sheer volume of stuff out there is that really the best use of an hour and a half even? Surely there was something good enough that it warranted real time viewing? Maybe it's not the case here but that's what came to mind.
- roberthahn 13y agoMany years ago, just after the beginning of the web standards movement, I was working at a design agency, and was asked to ensure that a client's site was 508c compliant. (508c is legislation mandating minimal accessibility requirements for websites.) One of the things I wanted to ensure was, at least, a tolerable experience (I'm not going to delude myself or you by claiming to make it a pleasant experience) for blind and low-vision people. For low-vision, I did two things: I worked with the design team to ensure that text colours were always high-contrast. Then I aggressively played with the adjust font-size controls to see how things would "break" - and then fixed them. For blind people, I had a bit more fun. Like the OP, I wanted to experience the site as they would, and have the text read to me. However, since I'm profoundly deaf, hearing what the computer was trying to tell me was a lost cause. Fortunately I was running Mac OS X. It has screen-reading software built in (called VoiceOver, and it's quite nice, actually), so I turned that on. Then I found within VoiceOver a feature where I could caption what was being spoken to me. Now I'm set - once I learned the controls, I could just navigate using them and read what the computer spoke. It didn't take long to learn what kind of experience blind people would get. As was popular for the time, the pages had the upside-down hockey stick design - links and graphics across the top and left sides of the page, with the content filling the rest of the space. I made the case to adjust the markup on the page such that the source code for the links were at the end of the document, then used CSS to put everything back where they should be. At that point, the experience blind people were getting when they read the page was a skip link, the title of the page, then the content. The skip link took them down to the navigation. This was hard work, done at a time when browser makers had only just begun to catch up to the importance of web standards. I ended up leaving the agency shortly after, so I never heard how well it tested out in the field. I hope the work was worth it.
- Jean-Philipe 13y agoHasn't this article been on HN already last year? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5020421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5020421 just with a slash in the end, as far as I can tell
- Aloha 13y agoThis is one of the reasons I test all the sites I work on with links - I want to get a clue as to how it will work for someone blind. If were using a javascript menuing system we add a bottom nav that has discrete links for every page on the website.
- Shwanton 13y agoSome newer HTML5 elements (Shadow DOM) are supported and some still have a ways to go. A coworker of mine wrote a great writeup about the state of the accessibility of the Shadow DOM in modern browsers. http://substantial.com/blog/2014/02/05/accessibility-and-the-shadow-dom http://substantial.com/blog/2014/02/05/accessibility-and-the...
- qwerta 13y agoI have nearly perfect vision, but I also use accessibility tools. I have uniform inverse color theme in all programs, IDE, all webpages and even in PDF reader. I work 10+ hours a day with large (40"+) screens. White background was very aggressive towards my eyes and cause of many headaches. After adopting Solarized it went away. In case someone is interested here are screenshots of my desktop and some webpages: http://imgbox.com/TiqtcFri http://imgbox.com/TiqtcFri http://imgbox.com/1PEM5M7U http://imgbox.com/1PEM5M7U http://imgbox.com/Tpyl5hrq http://imgbox.com/Tpyl5hrq http://imgbox.com/lxND4eoI http://imgbox.com/lxND4eoI I use KDE and IDEA with Solarized color theme: http://ethanschoonover.com/solarized http://ethanschoonover.com/solarized In Chrome you can use this page to filter colors. It has white/black list so you can set colors per domain: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/change-colors/jbmkekhehjedonbhoikhhkmlapalklgn https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/change-colors/jbmk...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dreamdu5t 13y agohttp://motherfuckingwebsite.com/ http://motherfuckingwebsite.com/