4 ms·
Right, and the reason SOD tips work is that they don't need to be anonymous--as with laundering money, there's a legitimate front that the information is passed
by derefr 13y ago
Right, and the reason SOD tips work is that they don't need to be anonymous--as with laundering money, there's a legitimate front that the information is passed to (e.g. some known minor criminal who can be leaned on), which can then be cited as its source.
- tptacek 13y agoAre there documented cases of that happening? It's one thing for an SOD tip to put a cop at the right place at the right time to observe a transaction or pull over a car driven by a guy with warrants out. It's another thing entirely for an SOD tip to be the totality of probable cause, and for the police to lie to prosecutors or prosecutors lie to a judge about it. The latter case sounds much less likely to me, given the effort these slide decks show of LEOs trying to stay within the confines of the law (I don't happen to agree with where those confines are, but the evidence we have shows the DOJ paying at least lip service to it).
- smsm42 13y agoWith the tactics being top-secret I doubt there would be a lot of documented cases of it happening that could prove it exists - that would kind of defat the whole purpose of it being secret. It would probably take another Snowden to get any evidence on it.
- pessimizer 13y ago>It would probably take another Snowden to get any evidence on it. And I think that the possibility of another Snowden for this requires that there be some functioning mechanism by which requests to do this are centrally cleared, or even recorded, which I don't think is a sure thing. I see it just as likely that different agencies and departments within them are operating under a lot of different standing blanket orders in the form of legal interpretations, and that once a parallel construction is created, the records of any alternate explanation are destroyed (or were never created.)
- smsm42 13y agoNot necessarily - some policeman or policewoman doing this or seeing her peers do that can one day wake up and say - I had enough with violating rights of Americans, I'm just going to document everything we're doing that is wrong and then publish it, and be whatever it will be. Fat chance, I know, but who thought it could happen in NSA before it did? You never know. And after that happens, of course higher-ups will deny that happened, but once the cat is out of the bag and the attention of the society has been captured that would be a different story altogether than now. It would move from "those crazy libertarians are breaking out their tinfoil hats again" to "omg omg police is really doing it right under our noses! It could even happen to me!" For once, somebody could get and publish all those training manuals - unredacted, with all the juicy details. With it being this entrenched, something must be written down - you can't rule system this vast on lore alone.
- ellyagg 13y agoUnbelievable. Yes, we know they do this. We had this conversation a couple months ago and it was attached to an article describing exactly what they do. They don't just put cops "in the right place at the right time", which is your favorite and flawed analogy. They tell cops to pull someone over at the right place and the right time and make up a reason to pull them over. This should be illegal. It should be illegal even if something perfectly analogous has existed in that past. The extensiveness of a technique and the power that it allows matters. I'm not going to go back and find this conversation because I shouldn't have to. It's not my job to follow you around and make sure you are being intellectually honest. It's pretty frustrating that someone as well-respected as you are here, and someone who is such a prolific poster, refuses to update his model of the world when new information is introduced into it. You are mind-bogglingly tenacious in trying to quell the outrage over civil liberties abuses and apparently go as far as selectively forgetting relevant information.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, that's not your job. It's weird that you think it is. Could you cite a link to the case you're thinking of, where evidence from SIGINT surveillance was used directly as probable cause for a search? Also, could you yourself update your mental model of what's happening on HN? You obviously think I'm a tenacious foe of civil liberties causes. The opposite is true. I've done as much in the real world to support civil liberties causes as most anyone else on HN has. I contribute to candidates who I believe support a strong fourth amendment. I've canvassed for candidates like them. I donate to civil liberties causes. What I have a problem with are batshit conspiracy theories, which is something HN is rife with. People should stop pretending that conspiracy theories are helpful when they're of the right valence. They aren't. If you've actually followed me around HN, you know that I'm not at all unwilling to acknowledge when I'm wrong, as a cursory look at HNSearch will show. So, instead of yelling at me, why not show where I'm wrong?
- lawnchair_larry 13y ago> If you've actually followed me around HN, you know that I'm not at all unwilling to acknowledge when I'm wrong HAH! Sorry, continue.
- girvo 13y agoI know that police here in Australia will lie about where a tip came from, including to a Judge -- solely because one of my best friends is a cop and we've discussed it before. The thing is, that could be an isolated incident, I've no idea whether that happens a lot. That said, yesterday there was the article on HN about the Kings County police officer who indeed tried to lie about what had actually transpired, only he was caught out and fired(! Holy crap how good is that). I think none of us have enough info to really know what goes on, so I personally withhold my judgement about it in general, unless in a specific case I have seen credible info to lead me to believe otherwise. Hard topic, tbh.
- kdragon 13y agoOh, you're going to enjoy this read. A story that happened just recently: http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/LAPD-Los-Angeles-Police-Lawsuit-Accuses-Officer-Framing-Father-in-Gang-Related-Murder-242458661.html http://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/LAPD-Los-Angeles-Pol... LEOs and DAs have no problem paying for false testimony, whether it's to cover SOD or not. They can use taxpayer money and there's no real repercussions for getting caught. Innocent people are routinely murdered by police in my area, with no justification or repercussion. The lucky ones who survive get million dollar settlements in taxpayer money. The cops never face serious punishment. We had a group of LEOs literally beat a defenseless man to death, captured in full audio and video, and they got off scot free. Look up Kelly Thomas.