6 ms·
As far as I can tell, in parallel construction they use illegitimate cause or illegal evidence and ensuing investigations to construct a hypothetical way that t
by pessimizer 13y ago
As far as I can tell, in parallel construction they use illegitimate cause or illegal evidence and ensuing investigations to construct a hypothetical way that they could have legitimately found cause or evidence, and then they lie and say that they did it the legal way.
With SOD tips, they are getting tips from illegal sources and using them for cause, and simply lying and saying that they got the tip from somewhere else, like an anonymous informant, because there is no legal way they could have known. It's just a step away from hiring actors as witnesses, which I'm thinking is not very far away.
- Crito 13y agoAssuming the people they claim are the informants actually exist, and are not complete fabrications, then really the only difference between these 'informants' operating in this capacity and actors are what guilds they do or do not belong to.
- fleitz 13y agoWhy hire witnesses when you can get them for free by offering to reduce ridiculous sentences?
- tptacek 13y agoThese sound like identical processes. In both cases, it helps to be clear about terminology. You can't simply introduce evidence and conceal its source from a judge; that evidence would be excluded from trial. You also can't introduce evidence that chains back to excludable evidence. But the products of NSA/FBI fusion (or "SOD", or whatever you want to call it) are never introduced as evidence, either directly or as cause to authorize a search. That's why the process is called "parallel construction": it is the legal opinion of the DOJ that you can use excludable evidence as intelligence so long as you then build a case from probable cause (either for a warrant or arrest) that doesn't stem from that intelligence. In other words, you can exploit the NSA to put a detective in the right place at the right time. But the detective will need to observe you doing something that gives them probable cause for a search: you'll need to, say, do an open-air drug transaction, or get stopped for running a red light and then have drugs plainly visible in your car (or have a dog authorize the search, which is plainly problematic). The way parallel construction works, the information coming from parallel construction is never brought to court. This bothers criminal defense attorneys and civil rights advocates. It has never been the case that prosecutors are required to furnish all the information they collect on a suspect (though they are required to furnish any potentially exculpatory information, per Brady v. Maryland). But people opposed to parallel construction see this process as a bridge too far; one way to look at it would be that the whole process of discovering probable cause is something that a criminal defense can challenge, and so that whole process is potentially exculpatory. It's also helpful to know that parallel construction isn't a new thing. It's similar to the process that works when the FBI/DEA has a highly-placed informant in a criminal organization. They want to make cases from that CI, but they don't want to expose the CI, not least because they'll have more cases to make down the road.
- mikecb 13y agoJust to add the relevant terms of art to this post for people to google if they're interested in the legal doctrine: "exclusionary rule", "fruit of the poisonous tree", "independent source", "inevitable discovery", "attenuation", "good faith reliance", and "standing".
- tptacek 13y agoAlso "totality of the circumstances".
- pessimizer 13y agoAnd the accumulation of these concepts and precedents have added up to the current, nearly-legal, total surveillance state that we're developing into; a court decision, a failure to allow a challenge to a court decision, a secret interpretation by an executive branch counsel that is made illegal to either see or challenge but the executive operates as if it's established law... The problem isn't that there isn't a body of precedent that allows a lot of this garbage, it's that those precedents tend to be equally horrible and biased towards the powerful. edit: Just saying:) Not trying to be antagonistic. Just venting.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>you'll need to, say, do an open-air drug transaction, or get stopped for running a red light and then have drugs plainly visible in your car (or have a dog authorize the search, which is plainly problematic). Or be a totally innocent person who is unknowingly transporting contraband and say, "of course I don't mind, search my car, officer."
- SoftwareMaven 13y agoWhy would anyone willingly give up their protections under the law? Of course, if you say "no", they'll just get their trained dogs to give them "permission".
- 13y ago
- JimboOmega 13y agoThere's no implication that the source is necessarily illegal. Let's imagine a more traditional wiretap scenario. Say the police are gathering information on a major drug kingpin, and they need more information from him. But they want to bring in one of his lieutenants because of information they've found on the wiretap. It'd make plenty of sense to find a way to bust the lieutenant without making the existence of the wiretap public. It's not really about "laundering" evidence, in this case. Though it could very easily be used that way, since the actual source of the actions is hidden. The original wiretap could have been perfectly legal.