6 ms·
New Evidence: There is No Science-Education Crisis
- the_watcher 13y agoWhen will these articles learn that the fact that we are graduating enough STEM students, but still have a shortage of those who can fill the jobs, is a symptom of the science education crisis. No one would argue we aren't graduating enough students (or lawyers, etc). We still have a general education crisis, and a severe legal education crisis.
- vonmoltke 13y agoThe second paragraph of the following article argues precisely that: http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/technology/287435-a-short-and-long-term-solution-to-americas-stem-crisis http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/technology/287435-a-s... Additionally, the National Math and Science initiative is focused on the dual goals of improving the quality of education and quantity of students: https://nms.org/Education/OurStrategy.aspx https://nms.org/Education/OurStrategy.aspx
- mathattack 13y agoMy 2 cents... If 2 degrees have the same difficulty, and offer careers with similar "non-cash benefits" but different salaries, then there is an issue. STEM grads go into finance and consulting because that's where the pay is better. Meanwhile philosophy majors struggle to get any jobs. Net - either we need more STEM majors because STEM is the only rigorous career path out there, or we should steer more folks in that direction.
- cafard 13y agoIndeed. I was at a commencement several years ago, where I noticed a heartening number of hoods in a color indicating an engineering or science degree. Somebody then told me that two thirds of the wearers were going into finance.
- mathattack 13y agoYou know something is wrong with finance and economics undergrad education when the Phd programs look for folks with other majors. :-) This should be a sign to more people that science and engineering programs are places where you can solve real problems.
- rayiner 13y agoWe have a legal education crisis?
- ilbe 13y agoI don't think it's legal per se. A lot of people who graduate college haven't learned anything. I've seen it in both CS and legal.
- geebee 13y agoYou know, I actually think we do. I understand your response (there are so many law school graduates), but think about it - there's a huge number of unemployed or underemployed lawyers, legal costs remain sky-high, and most Americans can't afford a lawyer for very basic needs. We force all lawyers to graduate from college without acquiring any particular background that is strictly necessary for the study of law, then force them to go through three years of very expensive graduate school, and in spite of that, many of them are almost completely incapable of practicing law or even finding reasonable employment when they graduate. It's a 7 year education path that results in an unemployable person while a substantial need for affordable services goes unmet.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's a strange market, but it makes sense if you consider two points, neither of which is really related to education: 1) Legal services is a product that's hard to mass produce because each job is idiosyncratic. Plumbers and mechanics, jobs which have similar characteristics, charge $80-100/hour. Nearly everyone fits in one of a dozen sizes of shoe that can be cheaply manufactured in China, but every landlord-tenant dispute is slightly different. 2) At nearly every level, there is a limited supply of experienced lawyers (this is true for plumbers and mechanics and also consultants and bankers). Compare with management consulting. The field has zero educational or certification requirements, as far as I know, but McKinsey doesn't charge less per hour than a high-end law firm. Corporate clients in particular don't want to hire professionals that don't have prior, real-world experience with corporate matters. There are a limited set of opportunities to work on a real litigation or real merger, and so there is a limited supply of professionals with the desired experience. The educational system can't really remedy either problem. There are schools that put a huge emphasis on clinical, real world education, and yet firms and clients still focus most of their recruiting on schools that offer classes like Ethnoracial Identity in Anthropology Language and Law: http://abovethelaw.com/2013/12/6-ivy-league-law-classes-for-spring-semester http://abovethelaw.com/2013/12/6-ivy-league-law-classes-for-....
- steverb 13y agoI believe the fact that salaries in STEM fields aren't insanely high is a symptom that we generally have enough STEM educated people to fill the jobs.
- cushychicken 13y agoI think the point he's trying to make is that there is a skill gap, not a labor gap. We have plenty of people with degrees, but not enough with the skills they need to fill the jobs at hand.
- mrxd 13y agoIf that were true, we'd expect to see wages rise.
- nickff 13y agoOnly those with valuable skills would see their wages rise, it is possible that the average STEM employee would not.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoDepends, if a skill gap develops, you can then have a corresponding drop in productivity which can depress wages.
- michaelochurch 13y agoWe have a science capability crisis. It has little to do with formal education. It's an issue of leadership, especially in top organizational roles. There is a lack of competent, available workers for low- and mid-level roles (if you've ever been on an interview loop, you've seen how uninspiring the general ability level is) but that's more an artifact of decades-long discouragement and organizational failure than an intrinsic problem of the people. Knowledge is spotty and hard to find. Formal education, on the other hand, is really easy to find in NYC or Silicon Valley or Boston. There are zillions of people with PhDs from prestigious schools (but many of those aren't any good). All of this is dangerous in the long term, because after a decade of terrible leadership, competent people tend to leave for greener pastures, or burn out and lose motivation to do anything more than follow orders. The fact that we fall short of where we should be in STEM is entirely an artifact of the (mostly terrible) organizations we build and the roles those define. It's not the teachers' fault at all, nor can it be fixed by throwing more resources at education without fixing the larger (and probably unfixable) society.
- aantix 13y agoWhy must the capability already exist? With so many specializations, isn't it partly a company's duty to train?
- michaelochurch 13y agoWith so many specializations, isn't it partly a company's duty to train? Ideally, yes. But most companies are short-sighted and tend to assume that if the talent isn't right there and ready, the task is too hard to be worth doing. Executives don't like taking risks, except for those that allow them to capture all upside while externalizing the downside. There's a Gresham's Law of executives. Forward-thinking, progressive people are driven out by quick-flash politicking psychopaths. I don't know of an easy fix for that problem.
- ahomescu1 13y agoLet's say you were a company CEO or head of HR, and decided to hire untrained people and then train them. How would you handle the following: 1) The reality that life is uncertain, and the company might be bankrupt a year from now. There's no sure thing in life, even huge companies disappear. If training a new employee would only pay off in several years, would you still do it? 2) At-will employment, where the employee could stick around for the training, then quit as soon as that's done. I think forcing the employee to stay for N months/years after that is a raw deal. 3) The fact that that employee isn't contributing as much to the company, but you're still paying him/her market wages. Would you offer them lower pay during the training period?
- inspectahdeck 13y agoOne question I think is worth considering: if the quality of STEM education increased, wouldn't that increase the number of vacancies in STEM jobs per year? Theoretically, more qualified people -> better research -> new companies -> new job opportunities.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoIf you've ever worked as a bench technician in a Bio/Genetics/Testing lab you know that the hours are totally ridiculous and/or unstructured (expected to work weekends without much notice or the like). Also you are expected to make just a touch above minimum wage (take home) as a salary while working much more than 40 hours a week. (Post-docs and Grad Students are also expected to work for similar low pay and extreme hours but this is more to further their career.) I'd say that this part of the article describes more or less exactly why the Science workforce is in such a bad shape (at least in the States): Companies would rather not pay STEM professionals high salaries with lavish benefits, offer them training on the job, or guarantee them decades of stable employment. So having an oversupply of workers, whether domestically educated or imported, is to their benefit There are very few who even bother to make it to "the top" where the actual salaries are because to get there involves getting stepped on, scooped (or outright left off papers), and generally used/abused. At a certain point most people burn out or just say screw it and move on to a different career. What you end up getting are a lot of people who had good intentions, loved the idea of a STEM job, and/or idealistic beginnings, and then were destroyed by the reality of working in Science.
- ilbe 13y agoAnyone who has read Grapes of Wrath knows that the correct statement is, "Companies would rather not pay ANY professionals high salaries..." Call it a conflict of interest or call it the market. One way or the other, the conclusion is improve your skills, increase your value, and in the name of friendly competition, skin the company alive for as much as you can get for the skill the company demands. They are playing the same game with you.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoProblem being that in this sort of industry you can't improve your skills or increase your value without the 'company' (often not a company but an institution) doing the above to you. I agree with what you're saying! I'm more pointing out that the problem isn't with educating more individuals (or doing it better) its with the way the system utilizes said individuals and their education/skills. You can't expect (or bemoan the lack of) breakthroughs if you are grinding the people you expect to make these advances into the dirt.
- Fomite 13y agoThe truth of the matter has always been "There is a shortage of STEM majors willing to work for the wages we'd like to pay them." Pumping up the idea of the "STEM Crisis" is just a way to inflate supply.
- vonmoltke 13y agoI think there is also a healthy dose of "There aren't enough candidates who meet our unreasonably high standards out there!" in some circles. Compounded, of course, by your point.
- naterator 13y ago> Pumping up the idea of the "STEM Crisis" is just a way to inflate supply. Perhaps, but this should be seen in the larger context of a general glut of supply of high-skilled AND low-skilled workers. The truth is, it isn't just STEM where oversupplied & underpaid workers exist. Humanity is becoming more efficient at everything, and there is less work to go around. White collar is the new Blue Collar, it's just that no one acts like it. Economists have acknowledged this[1], but of course haven't proposed real solutions. The real solutions are: (A) White collar Unionizes against an ever shrinking management, or (B) we come up with some kind of shared work program, where we finally start towards the goal of 100% unemployment for humanity. But no one of any power really wants to talk about that. A psychological phase change will be needed for that to happen. [1] http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21586581-economist-asks-provocative-questions-about-future-social-mobility-american?zid=297&ah=3ae0fe266c7447d8a0c7ade5547d62ca http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21586581-economi...
- alexgolive 13y agoTop tech companies end up paying more for H1-B engineers than US engineers. Not only that but they have to pay for legal fees and wait for the legal process to take place. Why would they go through this if there were good US candidates available? Also tech salaries for entry level engineers at top tech companies (Google, Facebook, Twitter, Dropbox etc.) have increased by about 50% in the last 4 years.
- redwood 13y agoPresumably the answer is because those H1B individuals do more for the same amount of investment (where we must quantify everything involved in the competitive hunt for talent). The problem comes when these individuals are more valuable not because equivalent talent wasn't available but because they're slave-like workhorses without flexibility or options. H1B offers companies power of employees that they simply cannot wield over American employees, period. This is especially popular in some industries. Look at the IT work force here in midtown Manhattan for example. It's complicated.
- geebee 13y agoWhy would they go through this if there were good US candidates available? You have to include price. Otherwise, the statement doesn't really mean much. I understand that employers must pay the prevailing wage, but a "shortage" probably indicates that the prevailing wage is too low. It's also easy to pay the "prevailing wage" for a job title that is actually lower than what you're hiring for (the oversight on this sort of thing is pretty weak). There are also other compelling reasons. A key developer actually has a lot of power over an employer at a certain point in product development. If they walk, they can do a tremendous amount of damage. So employers may vastly prefer a situation where an employee is dependent on them for a visa or green card sponsorship. H1Bs can jump ship, but it's harder than it is for full citizens or permanent residents who can change jobs freely. While it isn't total control over the employee's freedom, it does give the employer considerable power, and they take some comfort in that. So.. why would a company pay a small amount in legal fees to hire a worker who can be paid considerably less than a permanent resident would be paid, and who will have a harder time leaving the company for a different job? That's not hard to understand at all.
- bigd 13y agoI recommend this read on the topic. http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/11/hipsters_on_food_stamps.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/11/hipsters_on_food_stam...