3 ms·
Because a) that belief is based on scientific facts although some of them are highly exaggerated and b) basically you’re not bashing/attacking/humiliating anyo
by elorant 13y ago
Because a) that belief is based on scientific facts although some of them are highly exaggerated and b) basically you’re not bashing/attacking/humiliating anyone who tells you otherwise.
Personally I don’t believe that Singularity will be achieved in the time frame Kurzwell predicts. Especially regarding AI progress I think that we need at least half a dozen paradigm shifts in order to get to the milestone of a truly self sustained AI entity. But you know in some sense believing it gives you an extra motive on pursuing some of these goals and I think that’s the real benefit of this idea. A few visionaries out there like Kurzwell could push science to new frontiers.
- acqq 13y agoReligion by definition is an acceptance of the claims based on the faith instead of critical thinking and the observation of reality. If the claims use scientific-looking statements which can be proved to not match with the reality or logic they are the "dogma." Of course it's not an "organized religion" but the beliefs are religiously accepted by those that promote it.
- XorNot 13y agoThe Singularity ... whatever, doesn't make positive claims about reality as it exists today or as it existed in the past. Religions do. Talking a lot about a possible future isn't the same as religious belief.
- acqq 13y ago"Talking a lot about a possible future" is "religiously" propagating the belief if what is being talked about is known to not be supported by the current state of the science. Specifically, Kurzweil "sells" to his "believers" this one: http://xkcd.com/605/ http://xkcd.com/605/
- Houshalter 13y agoWhat can be proved not to match with reality? Calling it a religion is needlessly antagonistic and does not address any of the arguments for it. On top of that it quite frankly isn't anything like a religion. There is no faith or supernatural belief or churches or rituals. Sure you can make superficial analogies but it's still entirely different.