5 ms·
Oh come on guys. It's much more fun to assume that he's right! This is why you know his name at all: it's a fascinating idea. This is why I believe the singula
by skrebbel 13y ago
Oh come on guys. It's much more fun to assume that he's right! This is why you know his name at all: it's a fascinating idea.
This is why I believe the singularity will happen in my lifetime. I honestly, genuinely, have no idea whether it really will, but believing that it does makes for excellent ideas, great conversations and a whole lot of excitement (and Judgment Days) in general. I want to believe it. This might be difficult for a certain type of rationalist (that many HN'ers are) to appreciate, but if you really want to believe something very much, the step to actually believing it is very small. Even if it's a conscious process.
In general though, no need to squeeze those butt cheeks so much, this is not the stock market. Fun predictions are fun!
- davidw 13y agoSo how is that not basically a religion?
- elorant 13y agoBecause a) that belief is based on scientific facts although some of them are highly exaggerated and b) basically you’re not bashing/attacking/humiliating anyone who tells you otherwise. Personally I don’t believe that Singularity will be achieved in the time frame Kurzwell predicts. Especially regarding AI progress I think that we need at least half a dozen paradigm shifts in order to get to the milestone of a truly self sustained AI entity. But you know in some sense believing it gives you an extra motive on pursuing some of these goals and I think that’s the real benefit of this idea. A few visionaries out there like Kurzwell could push science to new frontiers.
- acqq 13y agoReligion by definition is an acceptance of the claims based on the faith instead of critical thinking and the observation of reality. If the claims use scientific-looking statements which can be proved to not match with the reality or logic they are the "dogma." Of course it's not an "organized religion" but the beliefs are religiously accepted by those that promote it.
- XorNot 13y agoThe Singularity ... whatever, doesn't make positive claims about reality as it exists today or as it existed in the past. Religions do. Talking a lot about a possible future isn't the same as religious belief.
- acqq 13y ago"Talking a lot about a possible future" is "religiously" propagating the belief if what is being talked about is known to not be supported by the current state of the science. Specifically, Kurzweil "sells" to his "believers" this one: http://xkcd.com/605/ http://xkcd.com/605/
- Houshalter 13y agoWhat can be proved not to match with reality? Calling it a religion is needlessly antagonistic and does not address any of the arguments for it. On top of that it quite frankly isn't anything like a religion. There is no faith or supernatural belief or churches or rituals. Sure you can make superficial analogies but it's still entirely different.
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoIt is also fun to imagine fairies exist. More seriously, Kurzweil snake-oil selling is just distracting us from serious research in AI. That is the problem. Belief in this woo woo might actually stop us from getting real AI.
- panacea 13y agoDude peddles exponential snake-oil curves while we deal with sine++ waves.
- CmonDev 13y ago"distracting us from serious research in AI" - like how? By hiring DeepMind to work on pattern recognition?
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoTell me again how DeepMind bested humans in Jeopardy! or had success on hard publicly scrutinizable objective AI problems. My point is that all these "deep" X folks shy away from really hard AI problems which other paradigms are solving more easily.
- CmonDev 13y agoNo, they are taking cutting-edge findings in neuroscience (which studies an actual intelligence that is actually already "implemented") and applying them to computer science. At least this "shying away" will not unleash the 'AI winter' that "hard AI problem" "solvers" have caused.
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoAh. Then we need not worry about the singularity coming from Google. (Call me when Google measures up to IBM's Watson.) At least this "shying away" will not unleash the 'AI winter' that "hard AI problem" "solvers" have caused. Umm. Yeah...
- 13y ago
- oskarth 13y agoSounds like religion without many of its benefits (for example, human terminus) and with a more superficial form of belief. If this is a trend, it feels like the potential for a revival for organized spiritually in the coming generation or three is high. I mean this in a good way, unlike Singularity which I personally think is mostly harmful and bullshit masqueraded as science.
- melling 13y agoNo, it's a lot better to assume that he's wrong and keep working extremely hard and investing in science and engineering. We went to the moon in 1969 and had commercial supersonic flight in the 1970's. I imagine that in the 1970's we were pretty optimistic too. High-speed maglev trains were in the foreseeable future. Instead, today we protest because slow busses with wifi carry Google employees to Silicon Valley every morning. In short, the future we dreamed about 40 years ago hasn't arrived, so I wouldn't bet on the one you think is 30 years away.
- Houshalter 13y agoSo some people's predictions in the past were wrong, therefore everyone's predictions for the future now must also be wrong by default?
- RivieraKid 13y agoI think it's quite likely to happen. Once we're able to simulate the brain on a computer, it's just a matter of time until we understand how the brain works. I really wonder what would happen. The super-human AI would be able to replace basically all of the jobs. What will people do?
- admbk 13y agoCharles Stross dubbed it The Rapture of the Nerds many years ago.
- joesmo 13y agoIt's just as fun to assume that: 2 + 2 = 5 I want to believe it. Now all my programs are spitting out wrong answers and must be fixed to be in line with this belief. Are we getting the drift of the danger belief poses here yet?
- Ygg2 13y agoBut 2 + 2 is 5. Didn't you read your guide to Ingsoc?