3 ms·
> It's a situation that takes the usual morality of theft piracy question and makes it harder No, it just highlights the fact that you cannot assume that illeg
by wtallis 13y ago
> It's a situation that takes the usual morality of theft piracy question and makes it harder
No, it just highlights the fact that you cannot assume that illegal implies immoral.
A little piece of fine print claiming that your purchase was actually an indefinite rental that can be unilaterally cancelled has only tenuous legal power, and absolutely no moral authority. If you bought an eBook in a transaction that was essentially the same as buying a paper book, then you've fulfilled all moral obligations for compensating the author and publisher. No amount of legal shenanigans will create a moral obligation for you to censor that book from your personal library, any more than a legal action can create a moral obligation for you to burn your personal paper books.
There's a problem here, but it's not a moral dilemma, it's just another imperfection in our legal system - an indication that we need to change the laws.