4 ms·
I'm skeptical about all these new frameworks solving uniquely new things. This is not a syndrome of the Javascript community alone but of all IT: we never look
by gtirloni 13y ago
I'm skeptical about all these new frameworks solving uniquely new things. This is not a syndrome of the Javascript community alone but of all IT: we never look to previous solutions and research, and think we are discovering the wheel every day.
Be it IT vendors rediscovering "cloud" concepts that were published in the 70's or a JS developer releasing a new framework that he rewrote using more functional idioms because object orientation is so-yesterday.
Besides it getting boring for us old farts, it feels exactly how the author describes it: more noise than value.
- kawera 13y ago"cloud" concepts that were published in the 70's Not only published, I did use cloud computing in the 70's - we called it time sharing. And our keyval, schemaless databases obviously couldn't be called noSQL before the advent of SQL!
- briantakita 13y agoHistory has a habit of repeating itself.
- danellis 13y agoCloud computing and time sharing are not the same thing, though. Time sharing was just a way for multiple people to access the same computer at the same time. In cloud computing, people aren't accessing a particular computer as far as they're concerned; they're accessing a service that's out there somewhere, and they might even have two consecutive requests handled by computers in different data centers.
- kawera 13y ago...they're accessing a service that's out there somewhere... Exactly what IBM offered in the late 70's.
- ninkendo 13y agoIf you want to distill all of what "the cloud" means into just "accessing a service", then sure. Nothing's changed in 40 years because it's all still just "clients" accessing "services". Also, transportation hasn't changed in millenia because we're still just humans moving places, and information retrieval hasn't changed since the invention of the written word, because we're still just absorbing information from glyphs on something that has distinct colors.
- mikeash 13y agoHe's not saying "hasn't changed". He's just saying that he was using something that could easily be described as "cloud computing" four decades ago.
- ninkendo 13y agoWell, he said that "accessing a service that's out there somewhere" is "exactly" what IBM was offering in the 70's. I interpret that to mean that it hasn't changed.
- kawera 13y agoYou are right. The technology has evolved but the concept is the same; we had terminal servers connected to the nearest point of their private network over a dedicated line and they run our software in one or more of their servers.
- collyw 13y ago"we never look to previous solutions and research" That's something I see as the sign of a poor / inexperienced developer. Assuming they can do something better than an accepted well tested solution. Also why I can't sop far get too excited about NoSQL, its the same as Berkley DB was years ago more or less, no?
- kawera 13y agoYes, it's almost the same as Berkeley DB, dependability notwithstanding. There is a place for noSQL, though maybe not as your main datastore.