6 ms·
Okay? Why even bring this up unless trying to cast a disparaging light onto global warming? You are, in fact, denying human caused global warming in your last c
by Loughla 13y ago
Okay? Why even bring this up unless trying to cast a disparaging light onto global warming? You are, in fact, denying human caused global warming in your last comment, "I'm just saying that correlation does not equal causation." Every time I see this argument it's usually the first statement in the 'human's aren't really causing global warming, so we shouldn't try to fix it' circle-jerk.
What is the worst thing that happens if we try to address global warming, human caused or not? We get to keep the beneficial conditions that we've had since the beginning of humanity as we know it? Our children get to inherit a functioning and healthy planet? Society can continue on the way it has for many, many generations without plague or famine?
Stop it.
- ars 13y agoIt's horrible how climate change is now a religion not a science. "Deniers and believers".
- teraflop 13y agoYou could say the same about evolution; there are plenty of deniers there! But one side is much more responsible for turning into a religious issue than the other.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jamesaguilar 13y agoWell-established scientific theories have long had deniers. That did not make them not science.
- gfdgf546 13y agoClimate sensitivity is far from "well-established" science.
- enraged_camel 13y agoWhat, in your opinion, would make it "well-established?" Please give us some tangible ways to determine it.
- MartinCron 13y agoIt's more established than politically motivated hacks pointing out that it gets cold in winter.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoShoot, I didn't know. Someone should tell the climate scientists.
- Phil_Latio 13y agoYou mean like this? http://youtu.be/KXosjqvMtlo?t=5m35s http://youtu.be/KXosjqvMtlo?t=5m35s
- protomyth 13y agoI'm a little confused about the anti-GMO folks who believe in climate change since the science argument applies to both but they only believe it in one case. // I'm in the only way to stop current energy generation techniques is to invent something cheaper than gas and coal. Anything else won't stop the upcoming economies (e.g. China) from using gas and coal no matter how they pollute.
- glasz 13y agothere's a fine line. climate IS changing, has always been. but it's not caused by your farts. http://youtu.be/YtevF4B4RtQ http://youtu.be/YtevF4B4RtQ
- gavanwoolery 13y agoI encourage us to adopt clean energy and reusable resources either way. Please don't straw-man me without knowing my feelings on the matter. (I put this in the edit above for clarification).
- Loughla 13y agoI didn't straw man your argument. I said that your statement that correlation does not imply causation, essentially, negates the previous statement that you aren't denying human caused global warming. That is a thing that you said. It's up there. I didn't fabricate anything. I didn't exaggerate. I didn't misrepresent. I asked you what would be the worst thing to happen if we tried to stop global warming. Then I told you to stop it; I would like to repeat that statement here, again. Stop it.
- gavanwoolery 13y ago"Correlation does not imply causation" is a neutral phrase. It neither confirms or denies global warming, it simply says you have to be careful when you evaluate any given data set. If temperatures were dropping, I'd say the same thing. The goal of science is not to prove what you believe in, it is to attempt to disprove your hypothesis (that is science 101). Even if I were arguing against AGW (which I am not), it is not really in the spirit of science to say "stop it."
- gizmo 13y ago> "Correlation does not imply causation" is a neutral phrase. In scientific context it is neutral. In political context it absolutely isn't. For example, it's also the (ridiculous) argument used to argue that smoking doesn't cause cancer, or that you can't prove whether smoking causes cancer or whether cancer and smoking have a hidden shared cause. This became a fairly large debate in the 90s, even though the science is pretty one sided. If a scientific discussion can be derailed by arguments that are technically valid, that's a political problem. In the case of global warming scientists can still disagree among themselves (as good scientists should), but from a political perspective there's consensus science has been settled 30 or so years ago. It's real, it's caused by us and now action has to be taken. Truisms like "Correlation does not imply causation" in a political context just impede the political change we need.
- theknown99 13y agoThe amount of time, energy and money wasted on this "problem" is staggering to me. Imagine if we put that time, money and resources to better use to solve real problems that affect peoples lives day in and day out.
- mmanfrin 13y agoCan't tell if sarcasm...
- theknown99 13y agoDo you remember being at school, and being told that coal would run out by 2005, oil would run out by 2010, etc etc? Didn't happen. Remember seeing Al Gores film where he said the ice caps would vanish by 2012?
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> The amount of time, energy and money wasted on this "problem" You don't mean this, do you? http://drexel.edu/now/news-media/releases/archive/2013/December/Climate-Change/ http://drexel.edu/now/news-media/releases/archive/2013/Decem...
- kyrra 13y agoAnd your parent post talked nothing about changing how humans use the resources of this earth. He was pointing that if you look at data a certain way, you can use it to fit conclusions that may be incorrect. He was just making the point that you need to have context when looking at data. Framing data to prove your point doesn't make your point correct (though, it doesn't make it incorrect either). Weather at a macro level is extremely complicated. Knowing if we understand all the variables involved is a very difficult task. Be careful to the conclusions you jump to on such a small data set. Even 1000 years of perfect weather data when a planet that is billions of years old may not be as helpful as one would hope.
- RivieraKid 13y ago> What is the worst thing that happens if we try to address global warming, human caused or not? It costs money. And why should we? If humans are really able to have a significant impact on the climate, we should try to warm the planet. I would personally prefer about 3 C warmer climate (central europe). > Stop it. No, you stop being so fucking patronizing.
- bottled_poe 13y ago> And why should we? 3 C rise in atmospheric temperature is not what I'd be worried about. It's the increased sea temperature, which will result in higher sea levels and greater levels of moisture in the air. Meteorological events could become vastly more frequent and powerful. But you are right, 3 C rise will be balmy. You know best.
- RivieraKid 13y ago> higher sea levels I'm sure we'll deal with it. It's a (good) price for low energy prices. > Meteorological events could become vastly more frequent and powerful. I hope so, the weather is pretty boring here.
- anodari 13y agoSorry, but just as you are worried about having to spend to pay the cost of cleaning the air, others are worried about the cost of having their homes flooded or go through a prolonged drought ... therefore, it is good to try to think on both sides too.
- Geee 13y agoYou think we should 'try to fix it' even if it's not human-caused (CO2)? Even if it's caused by sun or natural cycles or something else? That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard.
- unsigner 13y agoThis is basically Pascal's Wager (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal's_Wager http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal's_Wager), and I don't think it resulted in many Christians recently. Why do you think it would work better wrt attitude towards global warming?
- glasz 13y agoman-made global warming is a joke. but if you like to try and keep the (always dynamic) climate in a near constant state, good luck. and feel good paying the tax.