4 ms·
The problem that this criminal complaint will face is the "Alliiertes Vorbehaltsrecht". "erstens der Überwachungsvorbehalt, das Recht, den in- und ausländische
by weinzierl 13y ago
The problem that this criminal complaint will face is the "Alliiertes Vorbehaltsrecht".
"erstens der Überwachungsvorbehalt, das Recht, den in- und ausländischen Post- und Fernmeldeverkehr in der Bundesrepublik auch weiterhin zu überwachen; zweitens den Geheimdienstvorbehalt, das Recht, die alliierten Geheimdienste mit Unterstützung des Bundesamtes für Verfassungsschutz außerhalb des deutschen Recht zu stellen, wenn es geheimdienstliche Interessen erforderte."
"firstly, the surveillance exception, the right to continue to monitor the domestic and international postal and telecommunications traffic in the Federal Republic, and secondly the intelligence exception, the right to the Allied intelligence with the support of the German Federal Office for Protection of the Constitution to act outside the German law if intelligence interests requires so."
While the "Treaty on the Final Settlement with Respect to Germany" is considered to have made Germany become fully sovereign, the "Alliiertes Vorbehaltsrecht" is still in effect according to [1] and [2] (both links in German only, sorry, there seems to be no online source in English).
[1] http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliiertes_Vorbehaltsrecht http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliiertes_Vorbehaltsrecht
[2] http://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2013-10/nsa-uerberwachung-merkel-interview-foschepoth/seite-1 http://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2013-10/nsa-uerberwac...
- DangerousPie 13y agoIs there any proper source for this? The wiki page states that the Alliiertes Vorbehaltsrecht ended when Germany was reunited in 1990. The only sentence indicating anything else seems to be a reference to some "secret contracts seen by Josef Foschepoth", but with no further details. This is the same author that is being interviewed in your second link, so it sounds a bit like this is just one guy trying to sell books...
- weinzierl 13y agoThe Wikipedia article I linked explicitly says it didn't end when Germany was reunited in 1990 ("Sie gelten weiterhin.", last sentence). But you are right in that all sources originate from the historian Josef Foschepoth. If it is one guy trying to sell books or one guy speaking an inconvenient truth, I don't know. If someone can point to an independent source I would be grateful.
- Xylakant 13y agoThere's a big debate whether those secret treaties exist and if they do, whether they say what Foschepoth says they do - i.e. if they allow spying on all german citizens by allies secret services - and if they allow it, whether the german government can sign (secret) treaties that violate principles of the german Grundgesetz (constitution). See for example this blog post http://www.internet-law.de/2013/10/darf-die-nsa-in-deutschland-die-telekommunikation-ueberwachen.html http://www.internet-law.de/2013/10/darf-die-nsa-in-deutschla... and the following discussion. So if the lawsuit ever makes it to court, these questions need to be debated - and I'm very interested in seeing the result. Edit: Just for clarity: The situation may be quite well that currently the german governments allows allies surveillance based on contracts that are illegal in itself.
- rbehrends 13y agoThis is the stuff of conspiracy theories. The German constitution is pretty specific when it comes to whether and how the government can limit fundamental rights. Article 10 of the Basic Law says that "telecommunications privacy shall be inviolable" and that "restrictions may be ordered only pursuant to a law". Secret agreements are no laws, so they cannot give the government the right to enact restrictions on telecommunications privacy. This requires a law passed by the German parliament following normal procedures (such as the G10 Act). Prior to 1991, there might have been a (weak) international law argument based on Germany's limited sovereignty, but since 1991, this doesn't work, either. The links you give rely entirely on the assumption that secret agreements can have the force of law; they do not.