3 ms·
You say "the correct 'universal law' to use...". I think this shows very well why Kant's imperative is so useless. It simply replaces judgement on the original
by fauigerzigerk 19y ago
You say "the correct 'universal law' to use...". I think this shows very well why Kant's imperative is so useless. It simply replaces judgement on the original question with judgement on the right way to generalise it.
- amalcon 19y agoWell, there are a pretty easy set of rules for this: You cannot generalize something to be universal, while still maintaining any of the specifications therein. I do agree that it's useless in practice, though -- it is philosophy, after all. Philosophy has never had concrete practical applications. It's only interesting as a curiosity.
- olavk 19y agoIt's a lot more useful than eg. "Don't be evil". No, it does not free you from having to use your judgment. But no philosophy or religion will do that for you.
- fauigerzigerk 19y agoNothing frees us from judgement of course. But science is about giving us tools to make better judgements. I don't see how Kant's imperative does that.