5 ms·
Not entirely the same, but I really wish the concept of compulsory mechanical licensing that exists for music would cover more creative endeavors. I'm kind of
by dagw 13y ago
Not entirely the same, but I really wish the concept of compulsory mechanical licensing that exists for music would cover more creative endeavors. I'm kind of OK with creator of the original Duke Nukem character getting royalties for uses of his character, I'm less OK with him being able to forbid anybody else from ever making a 'cover' of his game.
- jiggy2011 13y agoWhat would a 'cover' of a game be? You can make a game which is very very similar to Duke Nukem as long as you don't reuse characters , assets or code from the original.
- girvo 13y agoTell that to anyone who cloned any Nintendo game ever, even if they recreated everything.
- jiggy2011 13y agoDo you have any examples? There are a ton of platformers which are very mario-like and I don't think got into any trouble. Of course if you reproduce a mario game with a mario character even if you redrew him you would be in trouble.
- girvo 13y agoThat latter sentence of yours is entirely the point! Wouldn't it be cool to get a "mechanical license" to allow you to recreate (I'm your own way) Super Mario Bros with the original characters (even if you make the graphics yourself)? Quite literally a "cover", in a way that's more recognisable than just sheer mechanics? You can argue that you almost can now, and in some cases yes, but I'd love to pay royalties to someone to "cover" my favourite RPG from the Megadrive, beyond just making a "spiritual successor"!
- jiggy2011 13y agoI wonder if this could work for games in the same way it does for music. With music there is a significant "brand" around the artist to the point where the success of some artists seems to be more down to their image and persona than their actual music. This means that a cover version of a song performed by some tribute band is not really a substitute in any way for a performance by the real artist even if the cover band can reproduce the original with very high accuracy. Game developers don't really have the same halo and fame surrounding them, so perhaps customers would be happy with a cheaper clone of a game provided that the assets etc were of at least a similar quality to the original even if not identical.
- aestra 13y agoPlenty of covers are just as good as the original some more famous. http://www.businessinsider.com/17-cover-songs-better-than-the-original-2013-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/17-cover-songs-better-than-th... http://mentalfloss.com/article/53336/20-songs-you-might-not-know-were-covers?bypass=1 http://mentalfloss.com/article/53336/20-songs-you-might-not-...
- saraid216 13y agoWorth noting: Game mechanics aren't copyrightable. They're patentable. And the "mechanical license" you talk about is exactly what licensing a patent is. The graphics, the text, etc. are copyrightable/trademarkable.
- NAFV_P 13y ago> I'm kind of OK with creator of the original Duke Nukem character getting royalties for uses of his character, I'm less OK with him being able to forbid anybody else from ever making a 'cover' of his game. Duke Nukem is about as original as beans on toast. I don't see the point in making a cover of a caricature whose cultural origins could be traced back to the Second World War.
- ANTSANTS 13y agoI'm not sure if dagw was referring to this or not, but last year some musicians put a Duke Nukem cover album together, and the original composer refused to accept royalties and got it taken down shortly after its release in the "Game Music Bundle." My memory is a little hazy, but I guess he was able to do so because they released the album before they had the rights to do the covers (I seem to remember someone saying he had not responded in months after they attempted making contact). Unfortunately it seems most information of the fiasco has been wiped from the face of the internet; the vgmdb entry[1] is about the only thing left. It's just another example of pirates being more interested and/or capable of preserving history than the creators of history itself are: If fans weren't circulating this in the usual channels, we'd have lost such masterpieces as "BRO IT OUT YOUR ASS" to time forever. [1] http://vgmdb.net/album/39540 http://vgmdb.net/album/39540