3 ms·
Meta question for browser designers... is there any possible reason or purpose for toolbar addons other than spamming users? No? Oh, then take out the entire
by VLM 13y ago
Meta question for browser designers... is there any possible reason or purpose for toolbar addons other than spamming users? No? Oh, then take out the entire functionality, please. It'll be a massive net gain to humanity.
Since they won't, makes you wonder how much they're being paid to leave it in.
- icebraining 13y agoOn Firefox, toolbars are just one of the many functionalities that extensions have available, and that allow them to completely modify the UI. And yes, those capabilities are useful: see Firebug, Vimperator, etc.
- VLM 13y agoI don't disagree with your assessment of usefulness, solely with the assumption that useful = net gain to humanity. As a guy who uses firebug, I'd much rather download a special built executable of firebug for myself, once, than spend a lifetime cleaning up relatives browser bars. (edited to rephrase, what I'm asking for is a market bifurcation where stereotypical end users can't install toolbars and stuff to get owned, but devs are given the ability to screw their browsers up. Or we simply distribute dev tools separate from end user tools.)
- icebraining 13y agoWhat makes you think that spammers won't convince your relatives to download "special built executables" that add those toolbars? In the IE world, the way to create one of those toolbars is to develop an executable - a DLL -, but we all know that didn't stop them. In the end, browsers can only do so much; you need full process isolation at the OS level to avoid these problems.
- nknighthb 13y agoYes. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/search-apps/toolbar https://chrome.google.com/webstore/search-apps/toolbar
- spyder 13y agoTaking out the toolbar functionality would do nothing because add-ons can modify the content of webpages so they can create fake toolbars on top of every page.