7 ms·
Is Math a Young Man's Game? (2003)
- acangiano 13y ago(2003). I have a simple theory. Math is not a young man's game, but math at these levels is extremely demanding and all consuming of one's mind. As you get older life gets more complicated, you get a wife, kids, dog, etc. Your mind is no longer focused on one thing and one thing only. So it's exceptionally rare to see someone with a normal life do extraordinary discovery in mathematics past a certain age. Paul Erdős is often mentioned as a counterexample to the young mathematician. Yet, Erdős pretty much lived for mathematics and didn't really have a set place let alone a normal life with wife and kids. I'm not saying that this is the only contributing factor, but I'm willing to bet it's a big one.
- auggierose 13y agoAgreed. Caring about people very much distracts your mind from mathematics and such. So, best not to care if you have those kinds of ambitions.
- dgallagher 13y agoI don't believe it's not about "not caring". I think it's more about having a finite number of productive brain-cycles per day, and what you spend them on (opportunity cost). If you spend all day thinking about others, you won't get any math done. If you spend all day thinking about math, you won't be in tune with others. If you can balance things out properly, you can do both. Sometimes it's necessary to go to one extreme for a long period of time. If you're working on a really hard problem, it might be best to isolate yourself from society for days/weeks/months at a time to figure it out. If a close family member is stricken with a major illness like cancer, it might be best to focus and spend your thoughts, time, and emotions entirely with them. In reality it's usually a balancing act between different things. But you can understand why it's sometimes necessary to go to extremes.
- wslh 13y agoI also think that in the adult life you search positive feedback in other critical things like life standard. When you are young it is enough to receive positive and easy feedback in your family or school. I recommend to read the Kasparov's book: how life imitates chess (not the best title) where he mention different chess player personalities and ages. But we can't forget that there are huge brain changes when you are young.
- S4M 13y agoIn the same vein as Kasparov's book, there is this interview of Kramnik where he talks about the world champions before him [0]. It's interesting how he explains how different qualities can offset each other, for example, discipline and creativity. [0] http://www.kramnik.com/interviews/61 http://www.kramnik.com/interviews/61
- skc 13y agoThe thing I find fascinating about both this article and now your comment is that regardless of who's game it is, it seems to be taken as fact that it's a MANS game. You said "you get a wife"...I suppose history isn't littered with too many breakthrough female mathematicians.
- j2kun 13y agoNot many, but a few. Gender aside, nobody would think of Emmy Noether as anything less than one of the greatest mathematicians who ever lived.
- claudius 13y agoUnless, of course, you consider her a physicist and those as less than mathematicians…
- magicalist 13y agoI'll happily look down on applied mathematics, but classifying Emmy Noether as only a physicist would be ridiculous, as a large part of her life's work was indeed pure mathematics. I can't imagine the abuse of history needed to assert otherwise. And remember, even Hardy, most famous of the Purists, often slummed it with (hold your nose) physicists and on a few occasions even with (the horror) biologists.
- acangiano 13y agoI believe the article followed Hardy's quote, and I followed the article lead. I realized after posting that it might be seen as male oriented but I believe the same is true for female mathematicians. There are quite a few female mathematicians who made important contributions. My wife wrote a top 10 of sort on my blog a few years ago: http://math-blog.com/2008/09/28/10-remarkable-female-mathematicians/ http://math-blog.com/2008/09/28/10-remarkable-female-mathema...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- socrates1998 13y agoI agree. Math seems to be a one man or two man show, so you need to be absolutely focused on what you are doing. Businessmen can delegate and use the system set up in their young adult years to continue their trajectory. Franchising is an example that comes to mind. I have always admired Paul Erdős, a really interesting life doing something he loved.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoMaths is a game for anyone with the inclination to play. http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/05/16/1206569109.abstract http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/05/16/1206569109.abst...
- wulczer 13y agohttp://xkcd.com/447/ http://xkcd.com/447/
- Cyph0n 13y agoSimilarly, I believe, due to the vast amount of information accumulated in all different fields in the last century or so, polymaths have simply ceased to exist. The last true polymath I know of was John von Neumann. I guess it just can't be done anymore.
- morganherlocker 13y agoOn the other hand, it would seem that many of the top experts today are masters at mashing up the frontiers of multiple fields. Just think of all of the applications of Neuroscience + X (CS, Philosophy, Psychology, Chemistry, etc.). Sure, there are few (no?) people today that can claim mastery of 10 or 20 fields, but most of the cutting edge research does seem to require expert knowledge of 2 or 3.
- gdubs 13y agoI'd put Alan Kay forward as a living polymath. It's a shame that research has become siloed -- so many great discoveries came about because someone had insights perpendicular to their field.
- claudius 13y agoAre you talking about Alan Kay as in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Kay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Kay ? He doesn’t seem to have made any major contributions to physics, mathematics, the natural sciences or basically any other field, apart from software engineering.
- gdubs 13y agoPolymath needn't mean 'makes major contributions to multiple fields' (though, of course it, it can.) It means someone has deep knowledge across a wide array of subjects, and typically draws inspiration from fields which are orthogonal to their primary field of interest. In Kay's case, it's applying the concepts of biology, genetics, mathematics, and architecture, to computer science, to create Object Oriented Programming. A major breakthrough in his primary field (computer science) came about because of a wide (rather than narrow) field of study.
- leobelle 13y agoEverything in this article is about youth, not being male, so I don't get why they chose to put "Man" in the title. Are there not any young women born as genius?
- moistgorilla 13y agoHe is referencing a quote by G.H. Harding "No mathematician should ever allow himself to forget that mathematics, more than any other art or science, is a young man's game." Try reading the article before getting insulted.
- leobelle 13y agoI didn't know that, thanks.
- breckinloggins 13y agoThe title is in reference to a famous mathematical assertion and is a direct allusion to a G. H. Hardy quote from 1940.
- lutusp 13y ago> Are there not any young women born as genius? Mathematics and mathematical physics have many accounts of brilliant female mathematicians. The first computer programmer was a woman (Ada Lovelace: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_Lovelace), at a time when programming was almost purely mathematical. In spite of serious obstacles throughout history, examples abound. My favorite contemporary example: https://www.physics.harvard.edu/people/facpages/randall https://www.physics.harvard.edu/people/facpages/randall Quote: "Professor Lisa Randall studies theoretical particle physics and cosmology at Harvard University. Her research connects theoretical insights to puzzles in our current understanding of the properties and interactions of matter. She has developed and studied a wide variety of models to address these questions, the most prominent involving extra dimensions of space."
- nickthemagicman 13y ago
- morganherlocker 13y agoAbout 6 months ago I began writing a library[1] that focuses on topology (much of what was discussed in the article) and geospatial stats. I am by no means a math genius, and my library does nothing too novel from a mathematical perspective. Still, it has been nearly all consuming to grok the immense amount of math that goes into this sort of thing. I can only imagine the creative energy it must have taken to actually design these algorithms from scratch. [1] https://github.com/morganherlocker/turf https://github.com/morganherlocker/turf
- Someone 13y agoAs far as I can tell, your library does topo_graphy_, not topo_logy_. Topology ignores such things as corners, distances, and convexity. That makes it hard to combine with GIS systems.
- nathancahill 13y agoWhat? Everything about this comment is wrong. > "Topology ignores such things as corners, distances, and convexity." No, that's what topology is. > "That makes it hard to combine with GIS systems." No, GIS systems rely heavily on topology. Here are two definitions: Topology: 1. the study of geometric properties and spatial relations unaffected by the continuous change of shape or size of figures. Topography: 1. the arrangement of the natural and artificial physical features of an area.
- zodiac 13y agoThe code samples used to demonstrate that library loads a trees.geojson file with features like 'oak' and 'maple', so I think he definitely meant 'topography'. What makes you say it's a topology library?
- nathancahill 13y agoSee the authors comment above. The library does do a lot more than topology, but the see the sections titled: joins, measurement and transformation. These are all topological functions.
- karmicthreat 13y agoI've thought about this for the last few months. I'm in my 30's and never really cared about math until the last couple years. I'm discovering that it has become somewhat easier now for me to understand and learn new math. I had the usual engineering calc set and hated it. But now that I actually have some goals associated with it I have been able to make progress. I've been particularly interested in ASR and AI/ML. I was deficient in the math needed for it but now I'm getting up to speed rapidly. I think the key is to have had some in-depth exposure to math earlier in life though.
- analog31 13y agoIn my view the simple explanation that there's more to learn before reaching the cutting edge seems credible. Biology is another area. I live in a town where there's a lot of biology research, and there are start-up businesses, but they aren't formed by kids who skipped college to get rich. Instead, the typical start-up founder could be anywhere from 40 to 60. It takes a long time to learn biology. Another possibility to consider is that math research takes more time now because it resembles more of a search than an inventive process. If proof is computer-aided, for instance, then an Edisonian approach could be applied to finding a proof for a theorem (or at least, finding important steps), resulting in discovery of proofs being a matter of time, even for the most brilliant mathematician. (edited for spelling)
- j2kun 13y agoMake no mistake, math research is very much an inventive process. In particular, it's much more than just proving theorems. Mathematicians need to come up with ideas worth investigating, and that (in addition to writing proofs) often requires creativity.
- analog31 13y agoAbsolutely, and thanks for clarifying. My thought is simply that the creativity has evolved towards work that takes longer to reach fruition.
- serf 13y agoErdos said no.
- dominotw 13y agohttp://mathoverflow.net/questions/25630/major-mathematical-advances-past-age-fifty http://mathoverflow.net/questions/25630/major-mathematical-a...
- ergoproxy 13y agoI think ageism is implicit in modern Western culture. The Fields Medal has ageism built right into it: "a prize awarded to two, three, or four mathematicians not over 40 years of age." Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fields_Medal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fields_Medal However, skimming down the list of Abel Prize winners, those guys are no spring chickens, and do great work in mathematics well into their senior years.