5 ms·
All consensual and non-coercive transactions are ethical. Another contractor and I are bidding to build a website. The customer is a guy in his 90s who wants a
by michaelt 13y ago
All consensual and non-coercive transactions are ethical.
Another contractor and I are bidding to build a website. The customer is a guy in his 90s who wants a website for his antique furniture shop. The customer requirements aren't water-tight as he's not really into computers. For example they don't say the website should be accessible from the public internet or that I should hand over the source code and hosting credentials. My competitor has bid $1000. Is it ethical for me to bid $900 then later to demand an extra $200 to connect it to the internet, work that only I can do?
- radisb 13y agoIt is as long as you say it upfront
- michaelt 13y agoOf course I wouldn't say it upfront without being asked - Caveat emptor. If I wanted to be upfront I would have just quoted $1100 to begin with!
- akater 13y agoExploiting contracts is OK. Providing public with detailed info about contract exploiters is OK either.
- sleazebreeze 13y agoWhen I was a consultant in the construction industry world, our contracts all had an clause requiring a "reasonable standard of care". Basically, if something would be reasonably expected to be included (say accessing a website from the public internet which is the reason it's being built in the first place), you need to provide it. Whether software contracts include that same kind of verbiage, I don't know.
- sneak 13y agoThat's simple extortion, and is obviously nonconsensual.
- michaelt 13y agoIt sounds to me like you've redefined 'consensual' to make your philosophy produce the results you want. Both transactions were consentual and noncoercive. There were no threats of violence. An adult business owner signed a contract for services which were provided exactly as specified. The customer didn't have to agree to the first, poorly negotiated contract. And they don't have to pay extra for the extra services later on - it's entirely their choice. It's no more extortion than if you need a new ink cartridge for your printer and you find they're expensive. I put it to you that the situation I've outlined is unethical, even though it's consensual and non-coercive.
- brc 13y agoIn most jurisdictions, that would be in violation of laws. The laws are created to prevent shady operators, like people who go around 'fixing' the roof for old people. They agree to the work, then get charged a fortune for overages, which usually just amount to painting the gutters. Another example is the phone scammers offering 'virus fixes'. These are generally in violation of different laws.