3 ms·
"Offshoring countries provide huge subsidies to their homegrown services companies to stimulate growth in the market, so it makes sense to provide offsetting in
by Tichy 17y ago
"Offshoring countries provide huge subsidies to their homegrown services companies to stimulate growth in the market, so it makes sense to provide offsetting incentives for companies to look at local talent."
On the other hand, why not accept the free gift from the offshoring countries? The subsidies they pay (if they really do) translate directly into savings of your tax payers. On the other hand any "offshore tax" would just come directly out of the pocket of your tax payers by way of having to pay higher prices for the products of the off-shoring country. So there would be no net gain.
Just to name another way to look at it. I don't know what the best course is, but that article seemed to be all claims and little reason.
- friism 17y agoRight on. Industrial subsidies in countries like China translate to a net transfer of wealth from Chinese taxpayers to taxpayers in countries buying the subsidised service. From a standpoint of global economic utility, subsidies shouldn't be encouraged however, because they lead to sub-optimal allocation of resources. It seems to me that a good way to get rid of subsidies is to make the case to the taxpayers footing the bill. If prompted, it seems unlikely that the Chinese populace would want to pay for westerners getting artificially cheap goods and services. (Just using China as an example here)
- Tichy 17y agoI am not sure that the subsidies really exist - labor simply is cheaper in some countries. Perhaps the best way to react is to accept the free gifts and transform them into innovation? That would be tax the own population that benefits from the cheap imports (subsidized or not), and invest the collected money into diversification and research? It seems unlikely to me that the industries subject to offshoring will ever fully recover. Or, if the industries seem likely to recover, maybe they should receive the tax money? After all, aren't the subsidies an attempt to squeeze competition out of the market, to come back with higher prices once the monopoly is established? So the tax money should maybe be spent on helping the industries survive. For example lots of money could be spend on fancy software projects, that have no pressure to make money. Then, when India and other countries can not keep the prices low any longer, there will still be software companies in the own country. They can then turn back to producing serious stuff. (Just thinking for fun here). On the other hand, maybe the no-worries exploration phase yields some interesting results that bring in money later on. Also, where to draw the line? Is it realistic to watch the whole world for "fair labor prices"? It seems more realistic to try to make one's own country "fair", you can't solve everybody else's problems, too.