5 ms·
Another rant on IAP in the games market. Here is the sticking point for me, if its suicide then great these things will fail and like the original DivX idea it
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
Another rant on IAP in the games market.
Here is the sticking point for me, if its suicide then great these things will fail and like the original DivX idea it will be some cautionary tale in the past.
But what is really the rant? Is the rant it costs me more to play this game? Is that it? Your $5 game is not as entertaining for as long as your $50 game? I agree that the nickel and diming is annoying but they offer the "big bag of tokens" for some big price $50 - $70. If you buy that you can whiz right through things, and they don't "re-lock" so in the case of the racing game the cars are there forever, except you had to pay $50 for that game instead of the $1 - $5 you thought it cost.
- kaonashi 13y agoThe rant is that it's exploitative and anti-consumer. You're removing value from your product in order to increase revenue. That it works and perpetuates is not an argument in its favor.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI get the exploitive accusation, but don't quite understand the emotional argument yet. Las Vegas is the town of exploitation and yet people go there all the time and have a good time. My sister plays Candy Crush and thinks it is lots of fun. My neighbor goes to movies in 3D. All various ways to be exploited and get more cash out of you. I choose not to be exploited in those ways but I am not mad or sad that some people enjoy it. That is where I'm struggling to understand.
- kaonashi 13y agoCancer cells grow and thrive just fine in their environment, what's all the fuss about?
- Mithaldu 13y agoThat "big bag of tokens" is never, in any of these games, enough to just "buy the whole game". At best it's 25% cheaper than the "normal" price, which in every case still runs in the thousands. Anyhow, the question you ask, what is really the rant, is this: A large portion of human effort in the game producing industry is spent on an activity that can honestly only be described in one manner: Legally defrauding customers. This will in the long term breed distrust to the entire industry and wastes talent that could be used in furthering the art. And while, yes, eventually this will die out, the problem is that in the western world it will take about half a generation and in the eastern world might never happen due to certain cultural differences.
- grblmrbl 13y agoHow is offering a few extra lives, extra moves, a powerup, or another set of levels for a buck or two apiece at all fraudulent? Do you think users don't understand what they're buying? Or is your issue just with the fact that some games offer unlimited opportunities to spend money? There are many areas of the economy where you can blow as much cash as you desire, I hardly think that alone should qualify something as "defrauding customers".
- Mithaldu 13y ago> How is offering a few extra lives, extra moves, a powerup, or another set of levels for a buck or two apiece at all fraudulent? This article explains it in more detail: http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/RaminShokrizade/20130626/194933/ http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/RaminShokrizade/20130626/1949... The short of it is: Games who rely on IAP invariably have this progression: They start out as games where player skill determines progress, which has the two-fold effect of causing players to invest time in the game (and become emotionally attached) AND generating favourable reviews from journos who only have limited time to test a game. Then they gradually begin to slow progress of the player by increasing difficulty, and in especially cruel cases prevent the player from playing by introducing longer and longer timers; both of which can be circumvented with IAP to make the game at least superficially resemble its beginning state again. And this is a bait-and-switch, pure and simple. The player, having invested time, having become emotionally attached, and having memories of an enjoyable game have then these three choices: Walk away, force themselves to endure pain and uphold their investment, invest more to make the game resemble their memories again. And none of this is obvious from the outset. > Do you think users don't understand what they're buying? As i summarized above, they likely understand it, but have several pressures on them causing them to make an emotional choice, not a rational one.
- cm2012 13y agoSo - like any arcade game? All that I remember were absurdly hard the further you went, and you had to pay a lot more than $1 or $10 to beat them.
- kevingadd 13y ago'if it's suicide then great these things will fail' is missing the point. These strategies are dramatically revenue-positive in the short term, where short term is defined as say 6-36 months. Nobody is thinking long term, so these practices thrive in the industry, they make investors happy, they make executives happy. Everyone is doing them. The problem is that eventually these practices scorch the earth, just like how Zynga's fabulous success was built on completely destroying the effectiveness of viral pathways on Facebook.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI agree with everything you say, except I miss the 'scorch the earth' part. There is infinite demand for "games" type entertainment. So this technique ends up making a lot of companies short term wealthy until they shrivel up and die. Then they go away and it is hard to get investment to build another one. But the demand for games is still out there, and someone will fill it with some other plan. I completely get that if you're trying to sell a game on one of these platforms for $20 and getting no traction at all because all your money is being sucked out by Candy Crush it feels like the end of the world but look at World of Warcraft, that sucked a lot of the oxygen out of the PC space and now its off dying. Opening up once again opportunities.
- kevingadd 13y agoInfinite demand is absolutely false and the example I cited is really blatant: Eventually there is a backlash against destructive practices and they either get banned or die out. Nobody can leverage the acquisition/retention techniques Zynga used to get big because they don't work anymore. The idea of infinite demand for entertainment is trivial to disprove anyway: Gamers only have so much time in the day that they can devote to games, and only so much money they can afford to spend on games every month. If someone already plays multiple games, you're competing to either grab an increasingly tiny slice of their time or convince them to replace one of the games they're playing with yours. Note that this is compensated for by the traditional model because the up-front payment provides an incentive for the player to finish the games they've already bought; for F2P/subscription games there's no incentive to stick with a single title unless they find ways to keep you there. Also, the claim that either WoW or the PC space are dying is blatantly false. PC games are doing fine and WoW still brings in tons of money (even if its subscription numbers are way down). It is true that the nature of the MMO and PC industries has changed but it's not as if WoW killed anything.
- grblmrbl 13y agoWhen I think how much money I spent sinking quarters into Galaga at the local diner as a child, I just can't feel that bad when people complain about Candy Crush charging $0.99 for another 5 lives to people that are too impatient to wait a couple hours for the free set. Is that really so exploitative? Meh. I played past level 100 on Candy Crush without spending a cent, which is probably dozens of hours of gameplay. The market is speaking pretty clearly: it is not even close to profitable to make premium casual games, the group of hardcore people that are willing to pay up front is way too small to make it worthwhile. IAP lets you get many more people enjoying your game, and you make a lot more money doing it, which is IMO a win on both ends. I get that a lot of gamers hope these games will fail, but as of right now, this is the most profitable and fast growing sector in the games industry, so I'd be hesitant to predict its downfall yet. If there was some magical way to get the same number of mass market users to pay a fair $5 up front for games (hell, even $1 would be great), every one of us in the game industry would be thrilled to hear it, because it's much easier to make premium games than freemium. I'm open to ideas, but I haven't heard many realistic ones. Disclaimer: I work on F2P games (not for King), so take all of this with a grain of salt based on self-interest.
- watwut 13y agoHow many people/kids were willing/allowed to sink that much money into Galaga? It was not mainstream hobby. At least, my parents taught me it is not wise investment and I plan to teach my kids the same about level ups in seemingly free games. Speaking about exploitation, I recall one especially ugly example. A game with kiddy graphics and story had crying Bambi 10 minutes into play. You came there and Bambi told you that he is dying and the only way to save him is to pay money. If this is not emotional manipulation I do not know what is.
- Paradigma11 13y agoDo you have a link for further reference.
- Mithaldu 13y ago> Is that really so exploitative? Read this, then look at the games you make and tell me what you think: http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/RaminShokrizade/20130626/194933/ http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/RaminShokrizade/20130626/1949... Frankly, at this point i have to assume that you're either shilling, or are simply unaware of the psychological effects at work because you only work with the technology.