5 ms·
Sadly, the gaming public has brought this fate upon itself, because so many people don't respect game developers and routinely pirate the results of their hard
by Silhouette 13y ago
Sadly, the gaming public has brought this fate upon itself, because so many people don't respect game developers and routinely pirate the results of their hard work.
I remember having this discussion on forums like Slashdot a few years ago. I argued that although pirating games was easy in the Internet age, if people kept doing it then the only surviving game developers would be those who adapted to models that prevented it. The usual response was mumbled with the eloquence of a five year old, and said something about copyright infringement not being the same as theft and whatever the developers did someone would just crack it so why should anyone pay for games?
Fast forward a few years, and almost all the AAA games are heavily linked with some on-line element and the most successful games tend to be either multiplayer subscription models or rely heavily on in-app purchases and DLC. If you actually wanted to make a good standalone, single-player, one-time-purchase game today, I wonder how hard it would be to make real money on it. It seems like the only winning options along that path are to make a relatively low-budget game like a puzzler and sell it for an order of magnitude less so it's attractive to a long tail of customers and/or to be hit-it-out-of-the-park successful. Of course, for every Minecraft or Angry Birds there are probably thousands more titles that never quite made it.
I have some hope that crowd-funding models will help to end this kind of stand-off, because they tap into a genuine desire many gamers have for good and original titles to play but they also bridge that reality gap and illustrate in concrete terms why money is needed to make them. I've seen several very promising games get funded far beyond their original goals on Kickstarter, including RPG, RTS and even space combat titles. Whether any of them will actually be able to pull off what they promised with slimmed down teams remains to be seen, as I don't think any of the really big ones have actually launched yet, but this is a field where I'm optimistic about an alternative model to the old copyright vs. piracy conflict.
- wpietri 13y agoI am suspicious of your explanation. Who pirates iPad and iPhone games? Approximately nobody. But the problem describe in the article is acute for game publishers regardless of platform. The public has brought this upon themselves, sure, but more by being cheapskates. And I think Apple has contributed to this as well; their app store design isn't helping.
- sergiotapia 13y agoOn the iOS family you can install Cydia which lets you install 3rd party non-apple-sanctioned apps. This in turn let's you download things like Installous which lets you download every single popular App for free, pirated. There is a HUGE amount of people who pirate iOS apps.
- banachtarski 13y agoThis is silly. You're suggesting that at one point, there were high quality games that people pirated in the first place. I was in the mobile games industry for a while. There weren't and saying that a "HUGE" amount of people pirated those games is total bs.
- wpietri 13y agoI just don't believe it, not without data. The approach you describe requires a jailbroken phone, plus going through a lot of shenanigans. Even most of the nerds I know haven't bothered to jailbreak their iPhones. I'm very skeptical that a significant number of civilians do it. Certainly not a significant number of civilians who would otherwise pay for games. I've talked a lot with friends who started an iPhone games company two years back. They have mentioned a ton of issues in the marketplace, but worrying about piracy has never come up. Ever.
- sergiotapia 13y agoYou're assuming all people who pirate jailbreak their phones themselves. Nope. Lots of people pay some kid to do it and install N amount of apps.
- wpietri 13y agoI'm not assuming that. I've seen no data on "lots of people". Even if it happens, I've seen no evidence that it's a significant concern of people writing iPhone games. And if it were a significant concern, I'd still be skeptical that there's a real financial impact, as opposed to the erhmagerd school of "they are stealing my precious things" freak-out. And if there were a measurable financial impact, which I don't think there is, then I'd expect it to be an order of magnitude smaller than the concerns raised in the article.
- bananacurve 13y ago>whatever the developers did someone would just crack it so why should anyone pay for games? Isn't this largely mitigated on iOS with code signing? Unless you jailbreak, which most won't bother with, it doesn't matter if it is cracked, you won't be able to load it.
- r0s 13y agoThat sounds like the old chestnut of blaming pirates for the fade of the album in the music industry. We don't need to invent reasons, the death of physical retail is enough to drastically change the landscape. I'd say the new pricing models are a consequence of digital distribution, no more and no less. In app purchases were simply impossible with physical media games, why would we assume piracy has anything to do with it? (It doesn't)
- pnathan 13y agoIn the game I'm developing, although it'd be considerably simpler to write it client-side, I'm writing it server side. No point in building something that will be easy to rip off by a "fast follower".