5 ms·
I love Argentina, the people, the cities, the mountains, the food. But the government is absurd; petty corruption is endemic, the politicians are expected to b
by CapitalistCartr 13y ago
I love Argentina, the people, the cities, the mountains, the food. But the government is absurd; petty corruption is endemic, the politicians are expected to behave like Roman leaders taking care of "their" people. Until popular expectations change, the government will continue to tank the economy.
- hcarvalhoalves 13y agoIt's not just Argentina, it's most of south america. Politics is dysfunctional here. "Socialism" is the default, and the best way to get votes here: welfare programs (that never work) gets you the votes of the poor and the intellectual elite, while a big and wasteful government is the #1 client of the private sector in a weak economy. It's triple win. Then, when the economy fails (because of taxation, evading investment, unprepared workforce) they can always blame on "the man", "USA", "neoliberalism", whatever... And another term begins. Argentina went downhill because they've been in this process longer. Ignoring the pathological cases (Venezuela, Bolivia), if the other countries here like Uruguay or Brazil don't rev up, we'll have another Argentina 5-10 years down the line. This year the Brazilian government was caught masquerading economic indicators for 2013 to keep inflation inside the goal.
- oscargrouch 13y agoEquating Brazil, with Argentina, Venezuela, Bolivia and Uruguay just because they are in the same continent, is a very common mistake analists from The Economist and other specialized media with the same ideological values does.. without really knowing what they are talking about.. I can understand the fact they cant understand it very well because of the lack of a cultural perspective to do it right.. (and the people they represent) What i dont understand is people from inside, reverberating that sort of speech.. making clear you dont know very well what are you talking about.. or which class you are defending with this speech.. (and its probably not yourself, unless you are part of the top 1%) But its very simple to measure how bad we are.. Take a look at your own economical condition, to see if you did not improve it with time..
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- slurry 13y agoArgentine government is especially bizarre because the party system has historially not made any damn sense at all. People used to give US politics flack for having clear cut left and right parties. But the Argentine party system has typically been liberals (UCR and allies) vs. nationalists (Peronists and allies), with each having left and right factions, but also factions based on personalities, and on support/opposition to whatever the most recent dictatorship happened to be. So, if you met an Argentine and find out only that he is a member of, say, the UCR that gives you as about as useful information as finding out someone was a Democrat in 1955, when that might have meant anything from a John Birch society segregationist to a left social democrat. That's a big opportunity for corruption, in both the Argentine and historic US cases. Things have gotten a little more 'normal' since the Kirchers have been so polarizing and the old parties have broken down some. But it's still in my opinion a source of great inefficiency not to have a well-established left-right party system.
- ronaldx 13y agoI find it bizarre that you think a left-right two-party system is good. People should have the right to vote for whatever they value, and should have the right for that vote to count (via representation of those values). A two-party system suppresses those rights. It's 'efficient' if you happen to agree with one of the two parties - but, it is not fit for purpose if you think the point of democracy is to represent the people in political decision-making. A political system which implies that there are only two valid points of view (or one valid axis) is the poorer for it.
- tptacek 13y agoIt might not be good in the sense of maximizing the value of the franchise, but it might be better along other axes, such as creating long-term coherent policy objectives. It can take a long time to change things in the US, which is sometimes bad, but also sometimes good.
- jkn 13y agoInteresting. I think that long-term coherent policies are best supported by strongly multi-party systems: when the power is shared by several parties, you don't get the political swing after each election that can happen with two-party systems. To take it to the extreme, consider Switzerland, where the largest party has only 26.6% of the votes. 11 parties are represented in the parliament, and the executive power is shared equally among 7 ministers representing 4 different parties. The system offers an unusual continuity in the executive branch: The Swiss executive is one of the most stable governments worldwide. Since 1848, it has never been renewed entirely at the same time, providing a long-term continuity. From 1959 to 2003 the Federal Council was composed of a coalition of all major parties in the same ratio: 2 each from the Free Democratic Party, Social Democratic Party and Christian Democratic People's Party and 1 from the Swiss People's Party. Changes in the council occur typically only if one of the members resigns (merely four incumbent members were voted out of the office in over 150 years); this member is almost always replaced by someone from the same party (and often also from the same linguistic group). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Switzerland#Executive_branch http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_Switzerland#Executi...
- djKianoosh 13y agoI was a little kid growing up in Argentina in the early 80's. I remember my dad explaining the crazy economy down there, showing me a 1,000 peso bill and saying, today you can take these zeros off and that's what this is worth. Soooo glad we left in 85. Anyway, the point is, the economy down there has been turbulent like this for a verrrry long time.. Makes smart people throw their hands in the air and say eff it, pass me a malbec :)
- ZeppelinDePlomo 13y agoArgentine here (born and raised in Buenos Aires). That's considered the main issue in all latin americans countries, to a more or lesser extent: endemic corruption and poverty that perpetuates the vicious circle of charismatic demagoges that, most of the time, have a short-term goals. The corruption exists because the institutions are weak, so because there are no well-developed systems to "get things done" the people that do it are the ones that go ouside "the system" (and the law). Making "things happen", either feeding the poor or running companies, imply bribes, leveraging personal relations and participating in a "favour" economy. It's all to navigate the broken argentine institutions (and, of course, the people at the top of the political food chain are the best players in the "corruption" game).
- mgleason_3 13y agoYes, and the "progressive" movement in the US profligates similar ideas and yet can't recognize the parallels.