2 ms·
Obvious Western propaganda piece is propaganda. And like the best sort of propaganda has enough kernels of truth to be dangerous. China's military is optimized
by bane 13y ago
Obvious Western propaganda piece is propaganda. And like the best sort of propaganda has enough kernels of truth to be dangerous.
China's military is optimized for maintaining internal stability and national unity. A civil war is the worst case scenario for China's leadership. You don't need a deep water navy, or a massive air force to achieve this goal. You need a massive tier-2 riot police force with some heavy hardware to augment when things really get out of control.
Along with almost no practical combat experience beyond internal stability operations, the PLA is simply not optimized for engagements outside of the national borders. There's pitifully few deployable logistics units.
However, on the few times China has chosen to mobilize against neighbors, the PLA has shown an ability to move truly unbelievable number of soldiers moderate distances away from the border.
There's also some debate if the PLA acquitted themselves better during the Korean War than during the later Sino-Vietnamese war. I think there's something to that, the end of the Chinese Civil War wasn't all that long before that, and it's likely that veterans of that conflict were in field command positions during the Korean War, but were not in the Sino-Vietnamese war. The outcome of the Sino-Indian war (1962) also probably falls at the career end of the same veteran commanders. In fact, China was at it's most muscular directly following the end of the Civil war (Tibet, Korea, India all between 1950 and 1962). The Soviet border conflict and the Sino-Vietnamese war, which were almost a decade later were not great victories for the PLA.
If that trend is true, the modern non-combat honed PLA may be lacking in critical modern battlefield experience. But it doesn't take a terribly long time for a military to gain that experience and capture it for a few years. Any conflict with the PLA, even if it started poorly for the PLA, would likely turn around not long after.
A friend of mine says that China is historically does not psychologically act in an outwardly facing expansionist way. It simply looks inward to admire itself, and sometimes to get a better view of the Middle Kingdom, steps backwards a few steps into somebody else's territory.
What remains to be seen, is if China's new economic policy creates a golden period of internal stability, if that gives military planners more time to regear and reoptimize the PLA for external conflicts rather than internal peace keeping. Right now, it's too distracted by domestic issues to really do this whole heartedly. But with a massive industrial capacity, I would predict that if such a shift were to occur, the world would be blindsided with how quickly that shift would happen.